Skip to main content
EatStreet Logo
  • profile
    Sign In
  • cart
    Cart
Back to Restaurant Search
The Thirsty Goat Menu and Takeout in Madison WI, 53711
  • The Thirsty Goat

  • American, Burgers, Sandwiches, American (Traditional), Barbeque, Beer Bar, Desserts, Salad
  • 3040 Cahill Main Madison WI, 53711
    - 121 ratings
  • Hours Closed

Restaurant is Closed

Next Delivery at 11:00 AM

Popular Items

Smokehouse Sandwiches Pulled chicken or pork on a brioche bun with grilled onions and kettle chips. Make it a brisket for extra charge.
Smokehouse Sandwiches from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$17.59
$17.59
Build Your Own Served with kettle chips or substitute fries for extra charge. CHOOSE a Knoche?s beef burger, grilled chicken breast or veggie patty, on a brioche bun. ADD Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Jalape?os, Chipotle Mayo, American, Blue Cheese, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Provolone, Swiss, Saut?ed Mushrooms, Egg*, Guacamole, Smoked Bacon, Pulled Pork.
$13.19
Fresh Cut Fries
$4.39
Cheese Curds 10 oz of hand-breaded fried curds, served with house-made ranch.
$15.39
Sampler Platter Your choice of meats from the smokehouse. Choice of 2 meats or 3 meats.
$27.49+

No Silverware

No Silverware Required Add this item to your cart and the restaurant will exclude silverware with your order.
Add +

Starters

Nachos Tortilla chips, black beans, pico de gallo, sour cream, jalape?os, shredded cheese, with a drizzle of BBQ sauce. Choice of half order or full order.
Nachos from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$12.09+
$12.09+
Chicken Wings Naked or tossed in choice of buffalo or BBQ sauce. Choice of 5 piece or 10 piece.
Chicken Wings from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$9.89+
$9.89+
Cheese Curds 10 oz of hand-breaded fried curds, served with house-made ranch.
$15.39
Gouda Mac & Cheese Bites Cheesy bites with bacon, served with cajun ranch.
$14.29
Dip Trio Spinach artichoke, hot popper, and spicy buffalo chicken dips, served with veggies and tortilla chips.
$15.39
Basket of Fries
$17.59
Onion Rings Served with Cajun ranch.
$12.09
Stuffed Goat Skins Potato skins with mixed cheeses, bacon, onions, served with sour cream.
$13.19
Pretzel Bites Served with hot cheese dip.
$13.19
Burnt Ends Crisped, charred ?bark? from the fattier corners of the brisket tossed in BBQ sauce.
$17.59

Crocks & Salads

Wedge Salad Iceberg wedge covered with crumbled blue cheese, sliced tomatoes, and house made blue cheese dressing, topped with 2 strips of hot, thick-cut bacon.
Wedge Salad from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$17.59
$17.59
Chicken Noodle Soup Smoked chicken, noodles, carrots, celery, and onions.
$10.99
Creamy Chicken and Wild Rice Soup Smoked with wild rice and mushrooms
$10.99
Rib & Brisket Stew Topped with mashed potatoes and onion straws.
$13.19
Cranbacon Goat Salad Mixed greens, bacon, dried cranberries, cucumbers, apples, red onion, pepitas and a fried goat chees puck, served with cranberry apple vinaigrette
$19.79
Caesar Salad Romaine, parmesan and croutons, tossed in a creamy caesar dressing.
$15.39

From the Smokehouse

We use a special dry rub and smoke our meats over a variety of hardwoods. Our smokehouse meats are served with cornbread and a side.

Prime Brisket
Prime Brisket from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$28.59
$28.59
Premium Baby Back Ribs Choice of half rack or full rack.
Premium Baby Back Ribs from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$23.09+
$23.09+
Pulled Pork
$24.19
1/2 Smoked Chicken
$24.19
Kielbasa Sausage
$21.99
Sampler Platter Your choice of meats from the smokehouse. Choice of 2 meats or 3 meats.
$27.49+

Smokehouse Specialties

Smokehouse Sandwiches Pulled chicken or pork on a brioche bun with grilled onions and kettle chips. Make it a brisket for extra charge.
Smokehouse Sandwiches from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$17.59
$17.59
Smoked Sliders Smoked brisket, chicken, and pork, on mini brioche buns, served with kettle chips.
$17.59
Smokehouse Salad Spinach, arugula, and romaine, with pulled pork, chicken, tomatoes, blue cheese crumbles, and croutons with a side of sweet & tangy vinaigrette.
$18.69
Smokehouse Tacos Three chicken or pork soft-shell tacos with pico de gallo, sour cream, cilantro, and lime. Make it a brisket for extra charge.
$17.59

Broasted Chicken

Pressure fried genuine Broaster Chicken. Served with mashed potatoes & gravy and drunken peaches.

Broasted Chicken - 2 Pieces Combination of white & dark meat. Choice of 2 pieces or 4 Pieces.
$13.19
Broasted Chicken (4 Pieces) Combination of white & dark meat. 4 Pieces.
$18.69

Burgers & Sandwiches

Prime Rib Dip Smoked prime rib, topped with saut?ed mushrooms, onions, melted swiss cheese, served au jus on a hoagie, served with fresh cut fries.
Prime Rib Dip from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$19.79
$19.79
Build Your Own Served with kettle chips or substitute fries for extra charge. CHOOSE a Knoche?s beef burger, grilled chicken breast or veggie patty, on a brioche bun. ADD Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Jalape?os, Chipotle Mayo, American, Blue Cheese, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Provolone, Swiss, Saut?ed Mushrooms, Egg*, Guacamole, Smoked Bacon, Pulled Pork.
$13.19
Curdee Burger Beef burger topped with shredded lettuce, tomato, raw onion, mayo, pickles, and cheese curds on a pretzel bun
$20.89
Wisco Burger Knoche?s beef burger topped with a beer-cheese sauce, bacon, fried onions, and jalape?os, served with fresh cut fries.
$19.79
Ranch Chicken Melt Grilled chicken breast seasoned with ranch spices topped with cheddar, swiss and saut?ed mushrooms on grilled sourdough, served with a side of house made ranch dressing and sweet potato fries.
$17.59

House Favorites

Mac & Cheese Bake Topped with toasted breadcrumbs and served with a side salad.
Mac & Cheese Bake from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$17.59
$17.59
Grilled Salmon Served with cilantro-lime rice and seasonal vegetables Try it blackened!
Grilled Salmon from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$20.89
$20.89
12 oz. Prime Ribeye Served with salt crusted baked potato and seasonal vegetables
$32.99
The Big Burrito Mixed cheese, black beans, lettuce, pico de gallo, rice, topped with red salsa, sour cream and cheese.
$18.69
Sheperds Pie Minced beef and lamb with vegetables, topped with mashed potatoes, baked golden brown, and served with side salad
$19.79
Fettuccini Alfredo Fettuccini noodles with fresh cream sauce, mushrooms, onions, spinach, sundried tomatoes, served with breadsticks & side salad.
$19.79
Southwest Smothered Chicken Grilled chicken breast topped with pepper jack cheese, fire roasted peppers and onions, served with cilantro-lime rice and a salad.
$18.69
Fish Tacos Three soft-shell tacos with deep fried cod, topped with southwest slaw, pico de gallo, lime, and chipotle mayo.
$16.49
Garlic Chicken Alfredo Creamy garlic chicken with asparagus, mushrooms, and sundried tomatoes served over fettucine with garlic breadsticks
$18.69
Blackened Salmon Served with wild rice with mushrooms and seasonal vegetables.
$20.89
Chipotle Habanero (GF) - 12 ounce bottle The spiciest of them all! It's a mouthwatering sauce, if you can handle the heat.
$13.20
Bourbon Barbecue Sauce - 12 ounce bottle A crowd favorite, our bourbon sauce gives a very bold and robust taste with a warm smoky finish
$13.20
Classic House Barbecue Sauce - 12 ounce bottle Our full-bodied signature house sauce encompasses the dark d creamy flavors of Guinness, a hint of coffee, topped with accents of sweet basil.
$13.20
Sweet & Tangy Barbecue Sauce (GF) - 12 ounce bottle This adventurous sauce is a perfect combination offering acidic citrus flavors wile finishing with a sweet taste
$13.20

Gone Fishing

Grilled Salmon Salmon filet seasoned and grilled to order: try it blackened!
$27.49
Breaded Lake Perch Perch filets coated in crunchy breading, deep fried, served with tartar sauce.
$23.09
Bluegill Lightly breaded filets, fried and served with tartar and lemon
$21.99
Beer Battered Atlantic Cod Beer battered and fried, served with tartar sauce and lemon.
$20.89
Poor Man's Lobster Atlantic cod with classic Old Bay Seasoning, baked, served with drawn butter and lemon: try it blackened!
$21.99
Walleye Panko crusted & pan fried, served with lemon butter sauce. Choice of 6 oz. or 12 oz.
$18.69+
Fish Tacos Three soft-shell tacos with deep fried cod, topped with southwest slaw, pico de gallo, lime, and chipotle mayo?
$18.69

Sides

House-Made Kettle Chips
$4.39
Fresh Cut Fries
$4.39
Sweet Potato Fries
$4.39
Corn Bread
$4.39
Baked Potato
$4.39
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
$4.39
Cilantro-Lime Rice
$4.39
Mac & Cheese
$4.39
Coleslaw
$4.39
Drunken Peaches
$4.39
Side Salad
$4.39
Seasonal Vegetables
$4.39

Desserts

Bread Pudding With whipped cream and bourbon caramel sauce.
Bread Pudding from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$8.79
$8.79
Drunken Peaches Served over vanilla bean ice cream.
$8.79
Brownie Topped with whipped cream. Add a scoop of ice cream for extra charge.
$7.69

Back to Menu

Reviews for The Thirsty Goat

1-15 of 27 Reviews

Back to Menu

Share your menu feedback with us: menus@eatstreet.com
All American Food delivery & takeout options in Madison
  1. Home
  2. Madison, WI
  3. All Madison Restaurants
  4. The Thirsty Goat

Your Order

Start Group Order
The Thirsty Goat
Proceed to Checkout $0.00
Unlock Free Delivery! Get Free Delivery for 7 days with your The Thirsty Goat order!
Offer Terms and Conditions
Delivery Driver Image
Empty Cart Illustration

Famished? Fill me up!

EatStreet
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Become a Driver!
Support
  • For Customers
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Restaurant Dashboard
  • API
  • Get EatStreet
  • Get Help
Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Restaurant Terms
Get the App
? 2023 EatStreet
Live Chat