Skip to main content
EatStreet Logo
  • profile
    Sign In
  • cart
    Cart
Back to Restaurant Search
The Thirsty Goat Menu and Delivery in Madison WI, 53711
  • The Thirsty Goat

  • American, Burgers, Sandwiches, American (Traditional), Barbeque, Beer Bar, Desserts, Salad
  • 3040 Cahill Main Madison WI, 53711
    - 115 ratings
  • Hours Closed

Restaurant is Closed

Next Delivery at 11:00 AM

Popular Items

Smokehouse Sandwiches Pulled chicken or pork on a brioche bun with grilled onions and kettle chips. Make it a brisket for extra charge.
Smokehouse Sandwiches from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$17.59
$17.59
Build Your Own Served with kettle chips or substitute fries for extra charge. CHOOSE a Knoche?s beef burger, grilled chicken breast or veggie patty, on a brioche bun. ADD Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Jalape?os, Chipotle Mayo, American, Blue Cheese, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Provolone, Swiss, Saut?ed Mushrooms, Egg*, Guacamole, Smoked Bacon, Pulled Pork.
$13.19
Fresh Cut Fries
$4.39
Cheese Curds 10 oz of hand-breaded fried curds, served with house-made ranch.
$15.39
Sampler Platter Your choice of meats from the smokehouse. Choice of 2 meats or 3 meats.
$27.49+

No Silverware

No Silverware Required Add this item to your cart and the restaurant will exclude silverware with your order.
Add +

Starters

Nachos Tortilla chips, black beans, pico de gallo, sour cream, jalape?os, shredded cheese, with a drizzle of BBQ sauce. Choice of half order or full order.
Nachos from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$12.09+
$12.09+
Chicken Wings Naked or tossed in choice of buffalo or BBQ sauce. Choice of 5 piece or 10 piece.
Chicken Wings from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$9.89+
$9.89+
Cheese Curds 10 oz of hand-breaded fried curds, served with house-made ranch.
$15.39
Gouda Mac & Cheese Bites Cheesy bites with bacon, served with cajun ranch.
$14.29
Dip Trio Spinach artichoke, hot popper, and spicy buffalo chicken dips, served with veggies and tortilla chips.
$15.39
Basket of Fries
$17.59
Onion Rings Served with Cajun ranch.
$12.09
Stuffed Goat Skins Potato skins with mixed cheeses, bacon, onions, served with sour cream.
$13.19
Pretzel Bites Served with hot cheese dip.
$13.19
Burnt Ends Crisped, charred ?bark? from the fattier corners of the brisket tossed in BBQ sauce.
$17.59

Crocks & Salads

Wedge Salad Iceberg wedge covered with crumbled blue cheese, sliced tomatoes, and house made blue cheese dressing, topped with 2 strips of hot, thick-cut bacon.
Wedge Salad from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$17.59
$17.59
Chicken Noodle Soup Smoked chicken, noodles, carrots, celery, and onions.
$10.99
Creamy Chicken and Wild Rice Soup Smoked with wild rice and mushrooms
$10.99
Rib & Brisket Stew Topped with mashed potatoes and onion straws.
$13.19
Cranbacon Goat Salad Mixed greens, bacon, dried cranberries, cucumbers, apples, red onion, pepitas and a fried goat chees puck, served with cranberry apple vinaigrette
$19.79
Caesar Salad Romaine, parmesan and croutons, tossed in a creamy caesar dressing.
$15.39

From the Smokehouse

We use a special dry rub and smoke our meats over a variety of hardwoods. Our smokehouse meats are served with cornbread and a side.

Prime Brisket
Prime Brisket from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$28.59
$28.59
Premium Baby Back Ribs Choice of half rack or full rack.
Premium Baby Back Ribs from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$23.09+
$23.09+
Pulled Pork
$24.19
1/2 Smoked Chicken
$24.19
Kielbasa Sausage
$21.99
Sampler Platter Your choice of meats from the smokehouse. Choice of 2 meats or 3 meats.
$27.49+

Smokehouse Specialties

Smokehouse Sandwiches Pulled chicken or pork on a brioche bun with grilled onions and kettle chips. Make it a brisket for extra charge.
Smokehouse Sandwiches from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$17.59
$17.59
Smoked Sliders Smoked brisket, chicken, and pork, on mini brioche buns, served with kettle chips.
$17.59
Smokehouse Salad Spinach, arugula, and romaine, with pulled pork, chicken, tomatoes, blue cheese crumbles, and croutons with a side of sweet & tangy vinaigrette.
$18.69
Smokehouse Tacos Three chicken or pork soft-shell tacos with pico de gallo, sour cream, cilantro, and lime. Make it a brisket for extra charge.
$17.59

Broasted Chicken

Pressure fried genuine Broaster Chicken. Served with mashed potatoes & gravy and drunken peaches.

Broasted Chicken (4 Pieces) Combination of white & dark meat. 4 Pieces.
$18.69

Burgers & Sandwiches

Prime Rib Dip Smoked prime rib, topped with saut?ed mushrooms, onions, melted swiss cheese, served au jus on a hoagie, served with fresh cut fries.
Prime Rib Dip from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$19.79
$19.79
Build Your Own Served with kettle chips or substitute fries for extra charge. CHOOSE a Knoche?s beef burger, grilled chicken breast or veggie patty, on a brioche bun. ADD Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickle, Jalape?os, Chipotle Mayo, American, Blue Cheese, Cheddar, Pepper Jack, Provolone, Swiss, Saut?ed Mushrooms, Egg*, Guacamole, Smoked Bacon, Pulled Pork.
$13.19
Curdee Burger Beef burger topped with shredded lettuce, tomato, raw onion, mayo, pickles, and cheese curds on a pretzel bun
$20.89
Wisco Burger Knoche?s beef burger topped with a beer-cheese sauce, bacon, fried onions, and jalape?os, served with fresh cut fries.
$19.79
Ranch Chicken Melt Grilled chicken breast seasoned with ranch spices topped with cheddar, swiss and saut?ed mushrooms on grilled sourdough, served with a side of house made ranch dressing and sweet potato fries.
$17.59

House Favorites

Mac & Cheese Bake Topped with toasted breadcrumbs and served with a side salad.
Mac & Cheese Bake from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$17.59
$17.59
12 oz. Prime Ribeye Served with salt crusted baked potato and seasonal vegetables
$32.99
The Big Burrito Mixed cheese, black beans, lettuce, pico de gallo, rice, topped with red salsa, sour cream and cheese.
$18.69
Sheperds Pie Minced beef and lamb with vegetables, topped with mashed potatoes, baked golden brown, and served with side salad
$19.79
Fettuccini Alfredo Fettuccini noodles with fresh cream sauce, mushrooms, onions, spinach, sundried tomatoes, served with breadsticks & side salad.
$19.79

Gone Fishing

Grilled Salmon Salmon filet seasoned and grilled to order: try it blackened!
$27.49
Breaded Lake Perch Perch filets coated in crunchy breading, deep fried, served with tartar sauce.
$23.09
Bluegill Lightly breaded filets, fried and served with tartar and lemon
$21.99
Beer Battered Atlantic Cod Beer battered and fried, served with tartar sauce and lemon.
$20.89
Poor Man's Lobster Atlantic cod with classic Old Bay Seasoning, baked, served with drawn butter and lemon: try it blackened!
$21.99
Walleye Panko crusted & pan fried, served with lemon butter sauce. Choice of 6 oz. or 12 oz.
$18.69+
Fish Tacos Three soft-shell tacos with deep fried cod, topped with southwest slaw, pico de gallo, lime, and chipotle mayo?
$18.69

Sides

House-Made Kettle Chips
$4.39
Fresh Cut Fries
$4.39
Sweet Potato Fries
$4.39
Corn Bread
$4.39
Baked Potato
$4.39
Mashed Potatoes & Gravy
$4.39
Cilantro-Lime Rice
$4.39
Mac & Cheese
$4.39
Coleslaw
$4.39
Drunken Peaches
$4.39
Side Salad
$4.39
Seasonal Vegetables
$4.39

Desserts

Bread Pudding With whipped cream and bourbon caramel sauce.
Bread Pudding from The Thirsty Goat in Madison, WI
$8.79
$8.79
Drunken Peaches Served over vanilla bean ice cream.
$8.79
Brownie Topped with whipped cream. Add a scoop of ice cream for extra charge.
$7.69

Back to Menu

Reviews for The Thirsty Goat

1-15 of 27 Reviews
Rated 1 out of 5
Jan 2, 2023
The wings were not good at all. Lots of gristle and very dry. Cheese curds were oily. Way too over priced for the quality
Ivy H
Rated 5 out of 5
Nov 19, 2022
Food was delicious. Appreciated that the bun and chips were not soggy from the meat. Generous portion. Delivery was quick as promised.
Lynn D
Rated 1 out of 5
Nov 6, 2022
missed food
Brooke B
Rated 1 out of 5
Oct 15, 2022
fish was the worst I;ve ever had. tasted like it was cooked in old oil, fries were just as bad.
Richard S
Rated 5 out of 5
Aug 13, 2022
Terrific smokehouse sandwiches, packed really well for delivery. No soggy buns. Homemade chips. Great salad. Will order again.
Elisabeth G
Rated 3 out of 5
May 20, 2022
It was a little bland --- the burger was a little over cooked and the pub chips should be in a separate box because closed in the To-Go container they got very soggy.
Theresa H
Rated 3 out of 5
Oct 28, 2021
Food was cold
roy d
Rated 5 out of 5
Jul 13, 2021
Food was still warm after it sat for about 30 minutes at my office front desk while I was held up! It's always fast and delicious. Their chips that come with sandwiches are awesome!
Erin H
Rated 5 out of 5
Jun 15, 2021
Everything was great
Kathleen H
Rated 5 out of 5
Feb 24, 2021
The wings were amazing!
Athena L
Rated 1 out of 5
Feb 6, 2021
Terrible. I was literally in the parking lot waiting for my order and even so my fries were already cold and limp. The accompanying fish fry was about on par with grocery store frozen fish but way more greasy. The $7 piece of apple pie had absorbed unpleasant refrigerator odors and was truly disgusting and inedible.
connie s
Rated 3 out of 5
Feb 4, 2021
They were fast and the food portions was good
I didn't care for the BBQ sauces and the brisket was really dry.
Jonas G
Rated 5 out of 5
Jan 26, 2021
Ribs, pulled pork, and brisket are all excellent. My fries were better last time, this time they were undercooked and rubbery, but still tasty. One of the only side salads in town that I actually recommend, YUM! You would never known from the name that the BBQ and other food is so good!
Jennifer L F
Rated 3 out of 5
Jan 1, 2021
Ribs were delicious! Chicken was really greasy and tasteless
Lauralyn H
Rated 5 out of 5
Dec 19, 2020
Ordered for our Team Holiday Lunch. The Broasted Chicken was wonderful. The Prime Rib sandwich was great with Onion Rings to top it off. The Smokehouse Burger was very tasty.
Kathy D

Back to Menu

Share your menu feedback with us: menus@eatstreet.com
All American Food delivery & takeout options in Madison
  1. Home
  2. Madison, WI
  3. All Madison Restaurants
  4. The Thirsty Goat

Your Order

Start Group Order
The Thirsty Goat
Proceed to Checkout $0.00
Unlock Free Delivery! Get Free Delivery for 7 days with your The Thirsty Goat order!
Offer Terms and Conditions
Delivery Driver Image
Empty Cart Illustration

Famished? Fill me up!

EatStreet
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Become a Driver!
Support
  • For Customers
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Restaurant Dashboard
  • API
  • Get EatStreet
  • Get Help
Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Restaurant Terms
Get the App
? 2023 EatStreet
Get Help