Eat The Best Pizza Menu & Delivery Madison WI 53703 | EatStreet.com
Eat The Best Pizza Menu and Delivery in Madison WI, 53703

Eat The Best Pizza

Pizza, Italian Food
16 ratings

Back to Menu

Reviews for Eat The Best Pizza
16 ratings
    Apr 6, 2025

    It took over an hour & was cold when it got here. The garlic cheese knots looked like store bought dinner rolls, not even separated from each other with shredded mozzarella 1/2 melted (stuck to the box & not on the bread at all) BUT in the last 3-4 times I?ve ordered from eat street, this is the 1 time my order wasn?t cancelled

    Oct 7, 2024

    The pizza is good, but the delivery sometimes takes a long time and the pizza arrives cold.

    Feb 27, 2023

    It?s late night pizza. It?s not that great by daylight hour standards, but when it?s late, any pizza will do, even a $7 slice with mozzarella but no basil as advertised. The crust was The carrot cake was dry cake drenched in simple syrup (didn?t offset the dryness) and I?m not sure what the icing was, but it absolutely was not buttercream frosting. I thought gif a minute it might be thickened cool whip. It made the cake inedible. My friend?s tiramisu was frozen solid. SOLID. I know these places buy premade frozen Sysco or mass supplier desserts?they still shouldn?t be as bad as that carrot cake or as ice cube tiramisu.

    Oct 22, 2022

    The order took almost 2hrs to arrive when the estimate was 40mins. The food was excellent though.

    Jul 4, 2022

    It was arguably the worst pizza I?ve ever had.

    Jun 25, 2022

    Pizza was quite good for the price. Pepperoni bread was really good!!

    Jun 10, 2022

    Pizza cold by time it arrives

    Jun 1, 2022

    Ordered online. Processed order and charged my card,. Then never sent anything, Eat street eventually cancelled my order and refunded my card. Meh.

    May 23, 2022

    I ordered 2 different slices, a salad and tiramisu. Ultimately I was only able to eat one slice, half the salad and the tiramisu. Both slices were cold and one of the slices, the crust was so soggy it was inedible. They also missed a topping that I paid extra for. Plus the salad was supposed to have kalamata olives not black olives. I would?ve never ordered the $10 salad if I knew it was black olives, so was disappointed and couldn?t finish the salad (had also asked for not too much feta but that request was ignored. I did like one of the slices despite being cold and the tiramisu was very good. I will give them another try? maybe getting a full pizza or the slices I liked will be better. Also, Somehow with the delivery fee, the Eatstreet fee and the tip, it costed me $40?. I know that?s not the restaurant?s fault, just wish more restaurants would allow ordering directly from their own site to save money for themselves and the customer?

Back to Menu

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to enhance your experience on our site. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy