Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - East Menu & Delivery Madison WI 53704 | EatStreet.com
Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - East Menu and Delivery in Madison WI, 53704

Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - East

Pizza, Subs & Sandwiches
1897 ratings

Back to Menu

Reviews for Glass Nickel Pizza Co. - East
1230 ratings
    Jun 29, 2026

    Best pizza I have had in ages.

    Sep 16, 2025

    It was a salad with slimy spinach and brown broccoli, The vegetables were clearly old.

    Apr 20, 2025

    The Couch Potato pizza is good, but they forgot to include the sour cream. :( Also, I wish they were still making it with potato wedges instead of the tots. Still one of my favorites, though.

    Jan 11, 2025

    The food was awesome, as usual. I did have an over powering amount of red onion in my Popeye salad but I picked them out.

    Oct 8, 2024

    Food good. But no delivery buzzer to apt. Food sat in dirty lobby until cold. We are 78 and one in wheelchair. Why ask for apt # then never even buzz? Deleted check mark for door delivery only. Expected more for $30! Last time for us. Very disappointed.

    Oct 8, 2024

    GNP always delivers fresh and so fast. Your acropolis salad SLAPS and I can?t tell you how much I appreciate you feeding me healthy, fresh food. The produce is always fresh and crispy. I love you guys so much. :?)

    Mar 8, 2024

    always delish, and their honey mustard sauce is the stuff of dreams...

    Dec 3, 2023

    We ordered 1 pizza and a salad. We got 2 pizzas and a salad. Neither pizza was correct. Both were poorly cooked and cut.

    Sep 22, 2023

    The pizza was hot and delicious. It was delivered early!

    Sep 19, 2023

    Unfortunately we didn?t have a great experience. Pizza was burnt. Breadsticks were burnt.

    Sep 6, 2023

    I did not get what I ordered. Very disappointed.

    Jun 15, 2023

    Horrible Overcooked Tossed 3/4 of it away!!!

    Jun 15, 2023

    Delicious pizza, it was hot. I was satisfied

    Feb 12, 2023

    Pizza and salad both were excellent. Delivery was fast and right to my door. Thank you.

    Oct 6, 2022

    Food was amazing. But the delivery driver sat in my driveway and honked his horn 5 times to let us know he was here. Didn?t even get out of his car to leave the food by the door or ring the doorbell? That was weird and annoying.

    Sep 20, 2022

    Great sandwhich, lots of ham and good bread

    Aug 13, 2022

    Took 1.5 hours to Get a pizza

    Jul 24, 2022

    Timely delivery, good salad, spinach bread sticks okay, and pizza fine. Overall, well done!

    Jun 20, 2022

    The pizza was burnt lol

    May 31, 2022

    The pizza was delicious however we ordered thin crust and got thick which am not a fan of.

    May 15, 2022

    Took 2 hours

    Apr 16, 2022

    Delicious! And the delivery was fast.

    Mar 31, 2022

    The pizza was pretty greasy but otherwise goid

    Mar 26, 2022

    BEST pizza in town.

    Mar 8, 2022

    excellent pizza

    Mar 7, 2022

    Food was good but they messed up the ingredients. Did not want to go through hassle of bringing it back and waiting

    Feb 21, 2022

    Ordered meat balls to go with two Ravioli entrees. Did not receive the meat balls, yet were charged for them. What we received was good.

    Jan 29, 2022

    My pizza order was wrong not sure why they added extra things to my pizza that I didn?t ask for!

    Jan 17, 2022

    My order was delivered to late (2:30 hrs)

    Jan 8, 2022

    The best!!!

    Dec 31, 2021

    Sorry 2nd time pizza was burnt

    Dec 21, 2021

    The dough wasn?t cooked fully, pepperoni and bacon weren?t cooked fully either

    Dec 13, 2021

    The Mac and cheese tasted like freezer burn/fridge smell

    Nov 28, 2021

    Really good food, lots of menu choices, convenient east side location.

    Nov 18, 2021

    Incredibly fast delivery!

    Nov 7, 2021

    Came fast, hot, tasted good.

    Nov 2, 2021

    Driver accidentally gave good to wrong customer

    Oct 10, 2021

    1 pizza was perfect but the 1 with Sausage and Pepperoni with 1/2 mushroom and 1/2 green pepper was a fail because they put nasty olives on my pizza instead of green pepper. I could only stomach 1 piece

    Sep 28, 2021

    no feta in salad and requested extra festa. I got changed for it. I was so hungry and so disappointed

    Sep 26, 2021

    Soggy crust even though we asked for crisp.

    Sep 7, 2021

    They forgot the garlic butter I ordered extra for $1.50

    Sep 2, 2021

    I ordered and paid through EatStreet. When I arrived the woman behind the counter asked me to pay again. I said I paid through EatStreet. She insisted I did not. I looked at my credit card and saw a charge, for glass nickel, for $14.72 which equals $13.95 for one medium cheese pizza plus 5.5% tax. I tell and show her this. She says something like EatStreet doesn?t charge tax. Obviously they do. She condescendingly turns her monitor towards me to show me my bill was $13.95, not $14.72, as if I was an idiot. She was confidently wrong. She was rude. I did nothing out of the ordinary. Was this her/their first EatStreet order? Regardless I?m not coming back.

    Aug 15, 2021

    Order mix up. Pizza cold, over baked and tasteless.

    Aug 9, 2021

    The pizza was over cooked. Black in some areas.

    Jun 26, 2021

    My order was wrong. My cheese curds were overcoocked to the point that some no longer had cheese inside. Will not be ordering again.

    Jun 21, 2021

    IT WAS TO SPICY.

    Jun 17, 2021

    Glass Nickel did not respond, so I did not get my order, it was canceled.

    May 18, 2021

    Food good

    Apr 25, 2021

    Order was correct and delivered on time!

    Apr 22, 2021

    my go to for comfort food

Back to Menu

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to enhance your experience on our site. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy