Nitty Gritty - Sun Prairie Menu & Delivery Sun Prairie WI 53590 | EatStreet.com
Nitty Gritty - Sun Prairie Menu and Delivery in Sun Prairie WI, 53590

Nitty Gritty - Sun Prairie

Burgers, Subs & Sandwiches
107 ratings

Back to Menu

Reviews for Nitty Gritty - Sun Prairie
107 ratings
    Aug 5, 2025

    I ordered my Gritty burger with extra sauce, which I was charged $1 for, and it arrived with absolutely no sauce. A Gritty burger with no sauce - how dreadful. Then I paid $6 to upgrade my side to cheese curds. I received one giant curd (literally the size of a chicken tender) and about six small curds - totally not worth it.

    Dec 21, 2024

    The quality of the food was consistent with previous orders. Unfortunately, the food wasn't as hot as we've enjoyed in previous orders.

    Aug 23, 2024

    I didn't get my Ceasars salad, and the driver just left it at my door and left. WTF happened to ringing the doorbell and handing the food to the person. The driver already has the tip so why bother trying

    May 20, 2024

    I think it was kinda dope

    Sep 10, 2023

    Food arrived extremely late and cold.

    Jul 2, 2023

    Pretty good

    Feb 25, 2023

    Not nitty gritty...but deluvery....took an hr after ready...cold dried out

    Jul 1, 2022

    Food was cold and fries and onion rings got soggy

    Jun 9, 2022

    Order was incorrect. First, an item was missing. Got home and realized both burgers were incorrect also.

    Mar 20, 2022

    Ordered a grilled Buffalo chicken sandwich and the chicken was tiny; extremely overpriced for what I got.

    Sep 24, 2021

    Missing items

    Apr 23, 2021

    It?s the last time I?ll order there. My last order was incorrect but I ignored it trying to support local restaurants. My Cobb salad was missing key ingredients (avocado) and the chicken had a weird crunchy skim on it and dark flesh on half of it like it?s was bad. Needless to say, I thre the salad out. The Mac n cheese seemed to be straight out of a Velveeta box. Sorry, none of it was restaurant quality and worth the price in my opinion.

    Feb 8, 2021

    Onion ring were very soggy. I did not eat them but paid 9$ for them. The wings were subpar definitely not deserving of the ?king wing? award.

    Feb 1, 2021

    After spending almost $100, waiting for a very long time with no updates whatsoever, our food arrived very cold.

    Jan 9, 2021

    Packaging was awesome. Food was hot and the fries and curds were crispy.

    Jan 6, 2021

    I went outside of my normal routine of salads or burgers and ordered the turkey, bacon, avacado sandwich. It was wonderful! Also, the pub chips were very crisp (sometimes the delivery in styrofoam causes side dishes to lose crispiness) so they were great as well!

    Dec 4, 2020

    Super dope! Unlike some of the other local burger joints, our food was amazing. Fries were crispy and our burgers had soft buns that weren't soggy and squishy. Definitely the best spot in town for burger delivery

    Sep 29, 2020

    Food was fantastic! When an item was missing from the order a manager called us back and had it brought over almost immediately. Great service and excellent food!

    Sep 24, 2020

    Great

    Jul 28, 2020

    Food was cold and the soda was missing

    Jul 11, 2020

    Great food. Great service!

    Jun 1, 2020

    Love and miss my gritty fam, thanks for a great dinner!

    May 2, 2020

    Even though it was delivery, everything was warm crispy and delicious. Would definitely order from them again

    Feb 15, 2020

    Food was not good. How do you eat a salad without salad dressing? It was tough. Won?t order from here again

    Feb 12, 2020

    Burger was fantastic cook the way I wanted it. Coleslaw was very good,

    Feb 1, 2020

    My order was messed up. I was missing items. Had to drive back to pick up missing items. Left got home realized that had the wrong thing again. Nitty did comp us though so 5 stars for customer service.

    Jan 17, 2020

    $10 for 18 cheese curds, yikes! (Yes, I counted)

    Dec 19, 2019

    They forgot the salad dressing.

    Nov 17, 2019

    Everything was great except my order was super late getting out, which meant the other order I had placed was cold by the time I got all the food and got home.

    Aug 19, 2019

    Didn?t forget my sauces! Arrived and cooked In awesome timing.

    Aug 11, 2019

    Good food

    Jul 28, 2019

    I did not eat the food that was delivered and ended up calling the restaurant to place a second order that I went and picked up myself because the EatStreet app offered no way to A) remove the Gritty sauce from my burger and B) did not offer fries (I?ve gotten non-seasoned fries countless times in the restaurant and since there was no such option on EatStreet I assumed the pub chips must be what they call non-seasoned fries). EatStreet should provide the same menu that?s available to restaurant patrons who order takeout directly from the restaurant. Also, I did not get the add-on I requested (malt vinegar, which I?ve had many times at the actual restaurant) and received neither an explanation or apology for the omission.

    Jul 18, 2019

    These burgers are amazing!!!

    Jul 11, 2019

    Delicious, perfectly cooked burgers delivered before expected time!

    May 20, 2019

    Cold Hamburger didn?t have any flavor

    May 18, 2019

    Great service! Fast quality food!

    May 17, 2019

    both burgers were cooked poorly, dry, lacked taste, the curds were overcooked to the point that the cheese inside was dried out. my first and last time eating from this place

Back to Menu

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to enhance your experience on our site. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy