- Popular Items
- Soda, 12 oz. CanPepsi, Diet Pepsi, Starry, Starry Zero, Mountain Dew.$1.79
- Kids: Mini Corn DogsServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Classic MilkshakeVanilla, chocolate, strawberry, oreo, peanut butter cup, snickers.$9.50
- Gourmet MilkshakeOrange cream, nutella choctacular, mocha espresso, bananas foster, strawberry cheesecake, chocolate peanut butter.$9.50
- Vegan Milkshake$10.99
- Chili
- ChiliSeasonal.$4.99+
- Kid's Meals
- Kids: Chicken StripsServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Mini HamburgersTwo mini-hamburgers. Served with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Mini Corn DogsServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Hot DogServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Grilled CheeseServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Mac & CheeseServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Pantry Items
- Lime$1.50
- Lemon$1.50
- Orange$1.50
- Avocado$3.00
- Gritty Sauce, 8 oz.$3.50
- Homemade Salsa, 16 oz.$5.50
- Origin Breads Sourdough Loaf$10.00
- Sheboygan Hard Rolls, 6-Pack$8.00
- Stella's Hot & Spicy Cheese Bread Rolls, 6-Pack$15.50
- Pretzilla Pretzel Buns$8.25
- Dole Orange Juice, 16.9 oz. Bottle$3.00
- Donuts (3)Full size glazed.$6.75
- Milkshakes and Desserts
- Hubbard Ave. Diner Caramel Apple Pie Slice$6.75
- Hubbard Ave. Diner Tin Roof Pie SliceChocolate and caramel cream pie with peanuts and marshmallows.$6.75
- Donuts (3)Full sized glazed donuts.$6.99
- Classic MilkshakeVanilla, chocolate, strawberry, oreo, peanut butter cup, snickers.$9.50
- Gourmet MilkshakeOrange cream, nutella choctacular, mocha espresso, bananas foster, strawberry cheesecake, chocolate peanut butter.$9.50
- Vegan Milkshake$10.99
- Chocolate Chip Cookies (Large)$6.99
- Beverages
- Soda, 12 oz. CanPepsi, Diet Pepsi, Starry, Starry Zero, Mountain Dew.$1.79
- Orange Mango Vita Ice$4.25
- Mountain Dew Kickstart - Fruit PunchFruit Punch, Blueberry Pomegranate.$4.25
- Starbucks Double Shot Energy Vanilla$4.25
- Bubl'r Cherry Guava$4.25
- Gatorade Zero Glacier Cherry$4.00
- Party Starters
These items are not currently available- Crispy White Cheddar Cheese CurdsWhite cheddar with gritty sauce.$13.50
- Seasoned Waffle Cut FriesJumbo order.$10.25
- Onion RingsBeer battered and deep fried to a golden brown.$10.50
- Chicken StripsServed regular or tossed in buffalo, honey garlic or bbq sauce, with side of ranch of gritty sauce.$13.75
- Chicken WingsChoose from regular, buffalo, honey garlic or bbq sauce. Served with a side of celery and bleu cheese or ranch.$16.99
- Veggie Hummus PlateSeasonal veggies and flatbread, side of ranch and hummus.$11.25
- Chips and SalsaHomemade mild salsa.$6.99
- Corn DogsHomemade pretzel mustard.$9.50
- Soft Pretzel SticksSide of nacho cheese and homemade pretzel mustard.$10.99
- Itty Bitty GrittiesMini versions of our award winning gritty burger.$13.99+
- Salads
These items are not currently available- Caesar SaladRomaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, Parmesan cheese and croutons.$11.99
- Caesar Salad with Grilled ChickenRomaine lettuce tossed with Caesar dressing, Parmesan cheese and croutons.$14.99
- Fried Chicken Club SaladRomaine and spring mix lettuce, cherry wood smoked bacon, hard-boiled egg, shredded cheddar, tomato and hand-breaded fried chicken breast.$17.50
- Cobb SaladRomaine and spring mix lettuce, grilled or hand-breaded crispy chicken breast, bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, avocado, hard-boiled egg, tomato, red onion.$17.50
- Strawberry & Pistachio Salad with Grilled ChickenRomaine and spring mix lettuce, fresh strawberries, pistachios, Nasonville dairy feta cheese, and dried cranberries.$16.50
- Strawberry & Pistachio Salad with Grilled SalmonRomaine and spring mix lettuce, fresh strawberries, pistachios, Nasonville dairy feta cheese, and dried cranberries.$18.50
- Asian Chicken SaladRomaine and spring mix lettuce, roasted almonds, mandarin oranges, crunchy ramen, toasted sesame vinaigrette, and honey garlic grilled chicken breast.$16.50
- BBQ Chicken SaladRomaine and spring mix lettuce, carrots, tomato, corn, black beans, Monterey jack cheese, tortilla strips and grilled BBQ chicken.$16.50
- Chicken and Fish
These items are not currently available- Chicken Bacon Ranch WrapGrilled or crispy chicken, bacon, shredded cheddar, lettuce, tomato, flour tortilla and side of ranch.$14.00
- Mark's Buffalo Chicken SandwichGrilled or hand-breaded fried chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, honey wheat sesame bun, side of ranch.$12.25
- Baja Fish TacosThree tortillas filled with cajun seasoned seared cod, topped with pico de gallo, shredded jack cheese, lime crema, lettuce, served with a side of chips and homemade salsa.$17.50
- Chicken StripsTenders breaded in whole wheat and yellow corn flour, served regular or tossed in buffalo, honey garlic, or bbq sauce, with a side of ranch or gritty sauce.$13.75
- Grilled Salmon Fillet Sandwich5 oz. Alaskan salmon, caper dill sauce, lettuce, tomato, red onion, brioche bun.$15.49
- Fried Chicken Pretzel SandwichHand breaded fried chicken breast, cherry wood smoked bacon, homemade pretzel mustard, mayo, lettuce, tomato, and soft pretzel roll.$14.00
- Pesto Chicken Flatbread SandwichGrilled chicken, parmesan and nasonville dairy mozzarella cheese, homemade pesto, spring mix lettuce and tomato.$13.49
- Hot Honey Fried Chicken SandwichHand-breaded fried chicken breast, hot honey sauce, sliced pickles, garlic aioli, soft pretzel roll.$12.25
- Nashville Hot Fried Chicken SandwichHand-breaded fried chicken breast, nashville hot dry rub, sliced pickles, lettuce, mayo, brioche bun.$12.25
- World Famous Burgers
These items are not currently available- Pretzel Bender BurgerNasonville dairy cheddar, homemade pretzel mustard, crispy onion rings, lettuce, tomato, soft pretzel roll.$14.00
- Raspberry Chipotle BurgerNasonville dairy pepper jack, raspberry chipotle aioli, lettuce, tomato, stella's hot & spicy cheese bread roll.$14.49
- The Big Gritt Burger12 oz. Of ground chuck, double-stacked patties, nasonville dairy cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, gritty sauce on honey wheat sesame bun.$16.25
- Farmers Market BurgerWisconsin meadows beef cooperative 100% grass-fed beef, jones dairy farm pork belly, creamy boursin cheese, bacon onion jam, stella's hot & spicy cheese bread roll.$15.49
- Sunrise BurgerCherry wood smoked bacon, fried egg, nasonville dairy cheddar, gritty sauce, crispy onion string, sheboygan hard roll.$14.75
- Roasted Garlic BurgerForemost Farms mozzarella, sweet roasted garlic, crispy onion strings, brioche bun, side of ranch.$14.00
- Gritty BurgerAward winning 6 oz. Ground chuck burger, secret gritty sauce, honey wheat sesame seed bun.$12.25
- Wisconsin Meadows 100% Grass-Fed Beef BurgerLocal naturally raised, grass-fed, lean beef from wisconsin, meadows cooperative, nasonville dairy cheddar, lettuce, tomato, red onion, honey wheat sesame seed bun.$14.49
- Black & Bleu BurgerBlackened with cherry wood smoked bacon, mindoro creamery bleu cheese, garlic aioli, red onion, brioche bun.$14.49
- Cow Friendly Burgers
These items are not currently available- Meggie's Falafel BurgerPatty of walnuts, garbanzo beans and spices, cucumber dill sauce, lettuce, tomato on brioche bun.$11.75
- Black Bean BurgerPatty of beans, rice and southwestern spices, topped with Foremost Farms mozzarella cheese, chipotle aioli, crispy onion strings, lettuce, tomato on honey wheat sesame seed bun.$11.75
- Impossible Gritty BurgerVegan impossible burger, vegan gritty sauce, vegan cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, vegan sheboygan hard roll.$13.75
- House Favorites
These items are not currently available- Marsh's Tuna Salad SandwichHouse recipe, lettuce, choice of Madison Sourdough Co. sourdough, multigrain, dark rye, or Texas toast.$9.49
- Grilled Cheese SandwichChoice of two cheeses on texas toast.$8.49
- Eric's Italian Melt SandwichSalami, pepperoni, turkey, melted Foremost Farms mozzarella, red pepper aioli, lettuce, tomato, banana peppers, flatbread.$14.00
- Sheboygan Style Double Brat SandwichTwo Johnsonville brats, raw onion and Sheboygan hard roll.$10.75
- Jason's Pork Pretzel SandwichHouse-made pulled pork, cherry wood smoked bacon, Nasonville dairy cheddar, sliced pickles, garlic aioli, soft pretzel roll.$13.00
- Classic Chicago DogRegular jumbo dog with chicago style relish.$8.75
- Deluxe Grilled Cheese SandwichCedar Valley mozzarella, basil pesto, tomato, texas toast.$9.75
- Reuben SandwichHouse-made corned beef, Swiss Valley Farms Swiss, sauerkraut, dark rye, side of gritty sauce.$13.75
- Turkey Bacon Avocado SandwichSmoked turkey, Swiss, cherry wood smoked bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, red pepper aioli and multigrain bread.$13.49
- Mac & Cheese
These items are not currently available- BBQ Pork Mac & CheeseHomemade mac and cheese topped with BBQ pulled pork, scallions and onion strings. Served with a buttermilk biscuit.$16.50
- Buffalo Chicken Mac & CheeseHomemade mac and cheese topped with a hand-breaded fried buffalo chicken breast, a drizzle of ranch and scallions. Served with a buttermilk biscuit.$16.50
- Bacon Cheeseburger MacHomemade mac and cheese tossed with ground chuck, bacon, pickles and red onion. Topped with sesame seeds. Served with a buttermilk biscuit.$16.50
- Plain Mac & CheeseHomemade mac and cheese served with a buttermilk biscuit.$13.50
- Fish Fry
- Available all day Friday.
These items are not currently available - Cod DinnerBeer-battered cod fillets, choice of side, and coleslaw with tartar sauce.$15.00
- Walleye DinnerBeer-battered walleye fillets, choice of side, and coleslaw with tartar sauce.$16.49
- Shrimp DinnerA half-pound of breaded shrimp, choice of side, and coleslaw with cocktail sauce.$14.00
- Brunch Menu
These items are not currently available- Classic Flatbread SandwichJones Farm bacon or sausage, fried egg, cheddar cheese, flatbread.$11.99
- Southwestern Breakfast BurritoSeasoned ground beef, chicken, or pork, nasonville dairy pepper jack, scrambled eggs, black beans, sriracha, lime crema, flour tortilla.$14.99
- Classic ComboTwo fried eggs, over well, choice of four strips of bacon or two sausage links, breakfast potatoes, and a buttermilk biscuit.$12.99
- CalifornianJones farm bacon, nasonville dairy pepper jack cheese, fried egg, avocado, spring mix, lime crema, brioche bun. Served with a side of parmesan herb breakfast potatoes.$13.50
- Classic French ToastThick vanilla almond challah bread, powdered sugar, maple syrup, whipped butter.$10.99
- Strawberry French Toast$11.99
- Corned Beef HashHomemade corned beef, bell peppers, onions, celery, and potatoes. Topped with a fried egg and scallions.$13.75
- Sunrise Burger6 oz. ground chuck burger, cherrywood smoked bacon, fried egg, Weyauwega Star cheddar, Gritty sauce, crispy onion rings, Sheboygan hard roll. Served with a side of Parmesan herb breakfast potatoes.$17.25
- Chicken and Waffleshand breaded fried chicken breast served with two waffles and a side of maple syrup.$15.25
- Donuts (3)Full sized glazed donuts.$6.99
- Brunch Kid's Meals
These items are not currently available- Kids: Chicken StripsServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Mini HamburgersTwo mini-hamburgers. Served with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Mini Corn DogsServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Hot DogServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Grilled CheeseServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Kids: Mac & CheeseServed with a choice of side, carrot sticks, a pickle spear, and goldfish giant cinnamon grahams.$7.99
- Brunch Menu Appetizers
These items are not currently available- Crispy White Cheddar Cheese CurdsWhite cheddar with gritty sauce.$13.50
- Seasoned Waffle Cut FriesJumbo order.$10.25
- Chicken StripsServed regular or tossed in buffalo, honey garlic or bbq sauce, with side of ranch of gritty sauce.$13.75
- Onion RingsBeer battered and deep fried to a golden brown.$10.50
- Veggie Hummus PlateSeasonal veggies and flatbread, side of ranch and hummus.$11.25
- Chips and SalsaHomemade mild salsa.$6.99
- Soft Pretzel SticksSide of nacho cheese and homemade pretzel mustard.$10.99
- Brunch Menu Salads
These items are not currently available- Strawberry & Pistachio Salad with Grilled ChickenRomaine and spring mix lettuce, fresh strawberries, pistachios, Nasonville Dairy feta cheese, and dried cranberries.$16.50
- Strawberry & Pistachio Salad with Grilled SalmonRomaine and spring mix lettuce, fresh strawberries, pistachios, Nasonville Dairy feta cheese, and dried cranberries.$18.50
- Fried Chicken Club SaladRomaine and spring mix lettuce, cherrywood smoked bacon, hard-boiled egg, shredded cheddar, tomato and hand-breaded fried chicken breast.$17.50
- BBQ Chicken SaladRomaine and spring mix lettuce, carrots, tomato, corn, black beans, Monterey jack cheese, tortilla strips and grilled BBQ chicken.$16.50
- Brunch Menu Burgers
These items are not currently available- Pretzel Bender BurgerNasonville dairy cheddar, homemade pretzel mustard, crispy onion rings, lettuce, tomato, soft pretzel roll.$14.00
- Gritty BurgerAward winning 6 oz. Ground chuck burger, secret gritty sauce, honey wheat sesame seed bun.$12.25
- The Big Gritt Burger12 oz. of ground chuck, double-stacked patties, nasonville dairy cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, gritty sauce on honey wheat sesame bun.$16.25
- Black & Bleu BurgerBlackened with cherry wood smoked bacon, mindoro creamery bleu cheese, garlic aioli, red onion, brioche bun.$14.49
- Sunrise BurgerCherry wood smoked bacon, fried egg, nasonville dairy cheddar, gritty sauce, crispy onion string, sheboygan hard roll.$14.75
- Black Bean BurgerPatty of beans, rice and southwestern spices, topped with foremost farms mozzarella cheese, chipotle aioli, crispy onion strings, lettuce, tomato on honey wheat sesame seed bun.$11.49
- Roasted Garlic BurgerForemost Farms mozzarella, sweet roasted garlic, crispy onion strings, brioche bun, side of ranch.$14.00
- Impossible Gritty BurgerVegan Impossible burger, vegan Gritty sauce, vegan cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, vegan Sheboygan hard roll.$13.49
- Brunch Menu Sandwiches
These items are not currently available- Classic Chicago DogRegular jumbo dog with Chicago style relish.$8.49
- Reuben SandwichHouse-made corned beef, swiss valley farms swiss, sauerkraut, dark rye, side of gritty sauce.$13.49
- Grilled Cheese SandwichChoice of two cheeses on Texas toast.$8.25
- Chicken StripsTenders breaded in whole wheat and yellow corn flour, served regular or tossed in Buffalo, honey garlic, or BBQ sauce, with a side of ranch or Gritty sauce.$13.49
- Mark's Buffalo Chicken SandwichGrilled or hand-breaded fried chicken breast tossed in buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, honey wheat sesame bun, side of ranch.$11.75
- Grilled Salmon Fillet Sandwich5 oz. Alaskan salmon, caper dill sauce, lettuce, tomato, red onion, brioche bun.$15.25
- Sheboygan Style Double Brat SandwichTwo johnsonville brats, raw onion and sheboygan hard roll.$10.49
- Nashville Hot Fried Chicken SandwichHand-breaded fried chicken breast, Nashville hot dry rub, sliced pickles, lettuce, mayo, brioche bun.$12.00
- Hot Honey Fried Chicken SandwichHand-breaded fried chicken breast, hot honey sauce, sliced pickles, garlic aioli, soft pretzel roll.$12.00
Back to Menu
Reviews for Nitty Gritty - Sun Prairie
1-15 of 28 Reviews
Rated 2 out of 5
Dec 21, 2024
The quality of the food was consistent with previous orders. Unfortunately, the food wasn't as hot as we've enjoyed in previous orders.
Connie and Randy B
Rated 1 out of 5
Sep 10, 2023
Food arrived extremely late and cold.
Gab R
Rated 5 out of 5
Jul 2, 2023
Pretty good
Jeremy O
Rated 1 out of 5
Feb 24, 2023
Not nitty gritty...but deluvery....took an hr after ready...cold dried out
Melissa M
Rated 2 out of 5
Jul 1, 2022
Food was cold and fries and onion rings got soggy
Chad W
Rated 2 out of 5
Jun 9, 2022
Order was incorrect. First, an item was missing. Got home and realized both burgers were incorrect also.
Josh R
Rated 1 out of 5
Mar 19, 2022
Ordered a grilled Buffalo chicken sandwich and the chicken was tiny; extremely overpriced for what I got.
Jacob S
Rated 3 out of 5
Sep 24, 2021
Missing items
Suzanne B
Rated 2 out of 5
Apr 23, 2021
It?s the last time I?ll order there. My last order was incorrect but I ignored it trying to support local restaurants. My Cobb salad was missing key ingredients (avocado) and the chicken had a weird crunchy skim on it and dark flesh on half of it like it?s was bad. Needless to say, I thre the salad out. The Mac n cheese seemed to be straight out of a Velveeta box. Sorry, none of it was restaurant quality and worth the price in my opinion.
Kelly A
Rated 2 out of 5
Feb 8, 2021
Onion ring were very soggy. I did not eat them but paid 9$ for them. The wings were subpar definitely not deserving of the ?king wing? award.
Shannon B
Rated 1 out of 5
Feb 1, 2021
After spending almost $100, waiting for a very long time with no updates whatsoever, our food arrived very cold.
Hannah K
Rated 5 out of 5
Jan 9, 2021
Packaging was awesome. Food was hot and the fries and curds were crispy.
Katie B
Rated 5 out of 5
Sep 29, 2020
Food was fantastic! When an item was missing from the order a manager called us back and had it brought over almost immediately. Great service and excellent food!
Zackeri D
Rated 5 out of 5
Sep 24, 2020
Great
Kenneth P
Rated 5 out of 5
Jul 11, 2020
Great food. Great service!
Marsha S
Back to Menu
- Home
- Madison, WI
- All Madison Restaurants
- Nitty Gritty - Sun Prairie