Skip to main content
EatStreet Logo
  • profile
    Sign In
  • cart
    Cart
Back to Restaurant Search
Pizza Plus #2 menu in New Haven, CT 06511
  • Pizza Plus #2

  • Pizza
  • 157 Hamilton St New Haven CT, 06511
    - (0)
  • Hours Closed

Restaurant is not currently accepting online orders.

Next Delivery at 11:00 AM

Popular Items

Traditional Wings Choice of 6 wings, 12 wings, 18 wings, 24 wings, or 30 wings,
$16.20+
French Fries - Small Choice of small or large.
$5.10
Monster Energy Drink
$3.54
Caesar Salad - Large With romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese & croutons. Choice of small or large.
$11.70
Cobb Salad - Small With grilled chicken, bacon, hard boiled egg. Choice of small or large.
$12.90

Value Combos

# 1-1 Large Cheese Pizza, 10 Wings & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$29.10
# 1-1 X-Large Cheese Pizza, 10 Wings & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$32.40
# 2-1 Small Cheese Calzone, 10 Wings & 2-LiterSoda Additional toppings cost extra.
$27.95
# 2-1 Large Cheese Calzone, 10 Wings & 2-LiterSoda Additional toppings cost extra.
$31.86
# 3-1 Party Size Cheese Pizza, 20 Wings & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$50.03
# 4-2 Large Cheese Pizzas Additional toppings cost extra.
$30.18
# 4-2 X-Large Cheese Pizzas Additional toppings cost extra.
$36.90
# 5-2 Party Size Cheese Pizzas Additional toppings cost extra.
$48.06
# 6-2 Large Cheese Pizzas, 15 Wings & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$50.34
# 6-2 X-Large Cheese Pizzas, 15 Wings & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$57.00
# 7-2 Two Toppings Large Pizza & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$24.60
# 7-2 Two Toppings X-Large Pizza & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$30.18
# 8-1 Large Cheese Pizza & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$18.72
# 8-1 X-Large Cheese Pizza & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$22.38
# 9-Party Size 1-Topping Pizza & 2-Liter Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$31.86
# 10-Small Cheese Pizza, 6 Wings & 20 Oz. Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$22.38
# 11-Small 2-Topping Pizza & Can Soda Additional toppings cost extra.
$16.20

Appetizers

Tex Mex Fries Topped with Chili & Cheese.
$13.14
Pizza Plus Fries (Enough for 2) French fries topped with bacon, steak & mozzarella cheese.
$13.14
Steak Fries (Enough for 2) French fries topped with steak & mozzarella cheese.
$12.60
Mega Fries (Enough for 2) French fries topped with bacon & mozzarella cheese.
$12.60
French Fries Choice of small or large.
$5.10+
Onion Rings Choice of small or large.
$6.60+
Fried Calamari
$14.03
Fried Shrimp Choice of 6 pieces or 10 pieces.
$8.34+
Fried Ravioli Choice of 6 pieces or 10 pieces.
$7.80+
Mozzarella Sticks Choice of 6 pieces or 10 pieces.
$7.80+
Jalape?o Peppers Choice of 6 pieces or 10 pieces.
$7.80+
Chicken Tenders Choice of 6 pieces or 10 pieces.
$9.00+
Buffalo Tenders spicyChoice of 6 pieces or 10 pieces.
$9.54+
Curly Fries Choice of small or large.
$5.70+

Wings

Traditional or boneless. Our signature Buffalo wings are hand tossed in your favorite Buffalo wing sauce. Served with bleu cheese or ranch dressing.

Traditional Wings Choice of 6 wings, 12 wings, 18 wings, 24 wings, or 30 wings,
$9.60+
Boneless Wings Choice of 6 wings, 12 wings, 18 wings, 24 wings, or 30 wings,
$9.60+

Platters

All platters served with French Fries.

Buffalo Wings (8) Served with french fries.
$14.03
Boneless Wings (8) Served with french fries.
$14.03
Fried Shrimp (8) Served with french fries.
$14.34
Buffalo Chicken Tenders (4) With bleu cheese.Served with french fries.
$10.20
Wings (6), Chicken Tenders (2) Served with french fries.
$14.03
Mozzarella Sticks (8) Served with french fries.
$13.14
Chicken Tenders (4) Served with french fries.
$9.54

Soups

Chicken Noodle Soup
$6.35
Chicken & Meatball Soup
$6.35
New England Clam Chowder Soup
$6.35
Chili
$6.35
Italian Wedding Soup
$6.35

Salads

All salads include romaine lettuce, cucumbers, red onions & tomatoes unless noted. *Nothing will be put on the side except dressing.

Garden Salad Choice of small or large.
$9.30+
Garden Salad with Grilled Chicken Garden salad topped with grilled chicken. Choice of small or large.
$12.30+
Garden Salad with Tuna Garden salad topped with tuna. Choice of small or large.
$12.00+
Garden Salad with Shrimp Garden salad topped with baby shrimp. Choice of small or large.
$12.60+
Caesar Salad With romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese & croutons. Choice of small or large.
$9.30+
Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken With romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, chicken & croutons. Choice of small or large.
$12.30+
Cobb Salad With grilled chicken, bacon, hard boiled egg. Choice of small or large.
$12.90+
Chef Salad With turkey, ham, provolone cheese, hard boiled egg. Choice of small or large.
$12.00+
Antipasto Salad Fresh garden salad with sliced Genoa salami, ham, pepperoni and provolone cheese. Choice of small or large.
$12.00+
Greek Salad With romaine lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, feta cheese & black olives. Choice of small or large.
$12.00+
Southwestern Salad With romaine lettuce, croutons, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, spicy chicken. Choice of small or large.
$12.60+

NY Style Pizza

Create Your Own Pizza Fresh homemade dough made daily, topped with our delicious pizza sauce, topped with the highest quality cheese and the freshest pizza toppings. Choice of 12', 16', or 18"x26".
$12.30+

Gourmet Pizza

Pizza Plus Special Pizza Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, mushroom, onion & peppers. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$16.80+
Meat Lover Pizza Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon & ham. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$16.80+
Veggie Lover Pizza Broccoli, eggplant, black olives, onions, mushrooms, peppers & spinach. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$17.40+
Philly Steak Pizza Steak meat, mushrooms, onions & pepper. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$18.00+
Hawaiian Pizza Ham and pineapple. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$15.60+
Shrimp Casino Pizza Baby shrimp, parsley & garlic. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$18.60+
Clam Casino Pizza Fresh clams, bacon & fresh garlic. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$17.40+
Five Cheese Pizza (Red or White) Mozzarella, cheddar, feta, ricotta & grated romano cheese. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$18.60+
Mexican Pizza Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, bacon, ham & jalape?o. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$17.10+
Greek Pizza Peppers, onions, black olives & feta cheese. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$16.50+
Mediterranean Pizza (Red or White) Ricotta cheese, feta cheese, spinach & eggplant. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$17.70+
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$16.50+
BBQ Chicken Pizza Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$16.50+
Grilled Chicken & Broccoli Pizza Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$17.40+
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Crispy chicken, bacon and ranch dressing. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$18.60+
Margherita Pizza Fresh tomato, basil, & garlic. Choice of 12" new york style pizza, 16" new york style pizza, 18" new york style pizza or 18" x 26" party size pizza.
$15.60+

Calzones

All served with 8oz marinara sauce.

Create Your Own Calzone Choice of small calzone or large calzone.
$14.70+
Meat Lovers Calzone With sausage, meatball, pepperoni and ham. Choice of small calzone or large calzone.
$17.40+
Veggie Lover Calzone With eggplant, spinach, olives and pepper. Choice of small calzone or large calzone.
$17.40+
Greek Lovers Calzone With Feta cheese, onions, & olives. Choice of small calzone or large calzone.
$17.10+
Southwestern Calzone Chicken cutlet with jalape?os and marinara sauce. Choice of small calzone or large calzone.
$17.40+
Chicken, Eggplant Parm Calzone Choice of small calzone or large calzone.
$17.40+
Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone Choice of small calzone or large calzone.
$17.70+

Stuffed Bread/Rolls

12" made fresh to order from fresh dough, with 8oz marinara sauce.

Buffalo Chicken Served with bleu cheese on the side.
$16.80
Crispy Chicken
$16.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch
$17.51
Broccoli
$15.11
Broccoli & Sausage
$15.59
Broccoli, Chicken, Spinach
$17.51
Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon
$17.51
Ham
$15.11
Eggplant
$15.11

Cold Grinders

All cold grinders served with lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.

Turkey Bacon Club Turkey breast, bacon, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
$13.80
Turkey Grinder Served with lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese.
$12.60
Tuna Grinder Served with lettuce, tomato, mayo
$12.00
Ham Grinder Served with lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese.
$12.00
Salami Grinder Served with lettuce, tomato, mayo and american cheese.
$12.00
Italian Combo Grinder Served with salami, ham, pepperoni, american cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo.
$12.60

Hot Grinders

All hot grinders served with lettuce, tomato, mayo & American cheese.

Steak & Cheese Grinder With lettuce, tomatoes, mayo, & American cheese.
$12.00
Hamburger Grinder
$12.00
Cheeseburger Grinder
$12.60
Bacon Cheeseburger Grinder
$13.20
Crispy Chicken Grinder
$12.00
Grilled Chicken Melt Grinder
$13.20
Chicken Bacon Ranch Grinder Sub
$13.80

Parmigiana Grinders

Buffalo Chicken Sub Parmigiana Grinder
$13.80
Shrimp Parmigiana Grinder
$13.80
Chicken Sub Parmigiana Grinder
$13.20
Meatball Sub Parmigiana Grinder
$13.20
Sausage Sub Parmigiana Grinder
$12.00
Sausage & Pepper Sub Parmigiana Grinder
$13.80
Sausage & Meatball Sub Parmigiana Grinder
$13.80
Eggplant Sub Parmigiana Grinder
$13.20
Chicken & Eggplant Sub Parmigiana Grinder
$13.80

Burgers

1/2 lb burger served with lettuce, tomato & mayo.

Hamburger
$7.80
Cheeseburger
$8.40
Bacon Cheeseburger
$9.00
Crispy Chicken Burger
$7.80
Grilled Chicken Burger
$8.40
Fillet of Fish (1/4 lb)
$8.10

Quesadillas & Wraps

Quesadillas served with ranch dressing quesadilla and wrap served with french fries.

Grilled Chicken Quesadilla or Wrap With lettuce, tomato, onion & cheese.
$12.00
Grilled Chicken Caesar Quesadilla or Wrap With romaine, lettuce, tomato, bleu cheese & cheese.
$12.00
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla or Wrap With lettuce, tomato, onion, & cheese and bleu cheese on the side.
$12.60
Steak Quesadilla or Wrap With lettuce, tomato, & cheese.
$12.00
Philly Steak Quesadilla or Wrap With onion, mushrooms, peppers & cheese.
$12.60

Breads

8 pieces each. Served with 8oz marinara sauce.

Garlic Sticks (8 Pieces)
$9.60
Cheese Sticks (8 Pieces)
$11.40
Garlic Cheese Sticks (8 Pieces)
$12.00

Parmigiana Dinners

All pasta dishes are topped with mozzarella cheese & served with bread.

Chicken Parmigiana
$17.70
Meatball Parmigiana
$16.80
Sausage Parmigiana
$16.80
Eggplant Parmigiana
$16.50
Sausage & Meatball Parmigiana
$17.70
Chicken & Eggplant Parmigiana
$18.30
Chicken, Sausage, & Meatball Parmigiana
$19.20
Baked Ziti with Ricotta Cheese
$15.60
Baked Ziti with Chicken
$18.60
Baked Ziti with Meatball
$18.00
Baked Ziti with Sausage
$18.00
Baked Ziti with Eggplant
$18.00
Baked Ziti with Sausage & Meatball
$18.60
Baked Ziti with Chicken & Eggplant
$18.60
Baked Ziti with Chicken, Sausage, & Meatball
$19.20
Stuffed Shells
$16.20
Stuffed Shells with Ravioli
$18.00
Stuffed Shells with Meatball
$18.60
Stuffed Shells with Sausage
$18.60
Stuffed Shells with Sausage, Meatball, & Ravioli
$19.20

Pasta Dinners

Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, or angel hair.

Marinara Sauce
$13.20
Marinara Sauce with Meatballs
$15.60
Marinara Sauce with Sausage
$15.60
Marinara Sauce with Sausage & Meatball
$16.50
Marinara Sauce with Chicken
$16.80
Marinara Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli
$17.40
Marinara Sauce with Sausage & Broccoli
$17.40
Pink Marinara Sauce
$14.40
Pink Marinara Sauce with Meatballs
$16.80
Pink Marinara Sauce with Sausage
$16.80
Pink Marinara Sauce with Sausage & Meatball
$17.40
Alfredo Sauce
$14.40
Alfredo Sauce with Chicken
$18.60
Alfredo Sauce with Baby Shrimp
$19.80
Alfredo Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli
$19.20
Alfredo Sauce with Shrimp & Broccoli
$20.40
Alfredo Sauce with Chicken & Bacon
$19.80
White Cream Sauce
$14.40
White Cream Sauce with Chicken
$18.60
White Cream Sauce with Chicken & Bacon
$19.20
White Cream Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli
$19.20
White Cream Sauce with Ham, Bacon, Onion
$19.20
White Cream Sauce with Chicken, Mushrooms, & Peas
$19.20
White Cream Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli
$19.20
White Cream Sauce with Sausage & Broccoli
$19.20
Alla Vodka Sauce
$14.40
Alla Vodka Sauce with Chicken
$18.00
Alla Vodka Sauce with Baby Shrimp
$19.20
Alla Vodka Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli
$19.20
Alla Vodka Sauce with Baby Shrimp & Broccoli
$20.10
Alla Vodka Sauce with Chicken & Bacon
$19.20
Bolognese Sauce (Meat Sauce)
$16.80
Bolognese Sauce with Chicken
$20.40
Bolognese Sauce with Chicken & Bacon
$21.00
Bolognese Sauce with Sausage
$19.20
Bolognese Sauce with Meatball
$19.20
Bolognese Sauce with Bacon
$20.40
Bolognese Sauce with Sausage & Bacon
$20.40
White Wine Sauce with Chicken & Spinach
$16.80
White Wine Sauce with Chicken, Mushrooms, Peas
$18.00
White Wine Sauce with Chicken & Broccoli
$18.00
White Wine Sauce with Chicken, Sausage, Mushrooms
$19.20
White Wine Sauce with Chicken, Sausage, Broccoli
$19.20
White Wine Sauce with Baby Shrimp & Broccoli
$19.80

Chicken Dinners

Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, or angel hair.

Chicken Francese Chicken breast dipped in egg & saut?ed in a lemon white wine sauce.
$18.60
Chicken Marsala Chicken breast saut?ed with mushrooms in a brown marsala wine sauce.
$18.60
Chicken Florentine Chicken spinach & tomatoes saut?ed in a white wine sauce.
$19.20
Chicken Pizzaiola Chicken topped with saut?ed onions, peppers, mushrooms, broccoli, & mozzarella cheese.
$18.60
Chicken, Sausage & Broccoli Entree Sauteed with tomatoes in a sherry wine sauce.
$15.00

Seafood

Served with bread. Choice of pasta: spaghetti, penne, linguine, or angel hair.

Jumbo Shrimp Francese Jumbo shrimp saut?ed in a lemon butter white wine sauce.
$20.40
Jumbo Shrimp Marinara Jumbo shrimp over marinara sauce.
$19.80
Jumbo Shrimp Scampi Jumbo shrimp saut?ed with a lemon white wine sauce.
$20.40
Jumbo Shrimp Fra Diavolo Jumbo shrimp over spicy marinara sauce.
$20.40
Jumbo Shrimp Alla Supremo Jumbo shrimp & clams saut?ed in a light marinara sauce.
$21.00
Jumbo Shrimp Florentine Jumbo shrimp, spinach & tomatoes saut?ed in a white wine sauce.
$21.00
Jumbo Shrimp Florio Jumbo shrimp, mushrooms, peas & spinach saut?ed with garlic & oil.
$21.00
Clams Alla Supremo Baby clams, onion, garlic & bacon in a creamy white sauce.
$19.20
Clam Sauce (Red) Baby clams, onion, garlic & bacon in a creamy red sauce.
$16.20
Clam Sauce (White) Baby clams, onion, garlic & bacon in a creamy white sauce.
$16.20

Fried Dough

Fried Dough Choice of small or large.
$11.94+

Sides

Grilled or Breaded Chicken (1 Piece)
$5.40
Meatballs (4) Served with marinara sauce.
$8.40
Sausage (3) Served with marinara sauce.
$9.00
Saut?ed Spinach Saut?ed with garlic and oil.
$8.40
Saut?ed Vegetables Saut?ed with garlic and oil.
$9.60

Desserts

Cheesecake
$4.74
Cannoli
$3.90
Chocolate Cake
$5.40
Tartufo Ice cream dessert.
$7.14
Carrot Cake
$5.40

Smoothies

Strawberry Smoothie Choice of 16 oz. or 24 oz.
$5.10+
Strawberry Banana Smoothie Choice of 16 oz. or 24 oz.
$5.70+
Pineapple Smoothie Choice of 16 oz. or 24 oz.
$5.10+
Pineapple Banana Smoothie Choice of 16 oz. or 24 oz.
$5.70+
Mango Smoothie Choice of 16 oz. or 24 oz.
$5.10+
Tropical Rainbow Smoothie Choice of 16 oz. or 24 oz.
$6.00+

Ice Cream

Vanilla Ice Cream Choice of small 8 oz. or pint.
$3.60+
Chocolate Ice Cream Choice of small 8 oz. or pint.
$3.60+
Strawberry Ice Cream Choice of small 8 oz. or pint.
$3.60+
Cookies N Cream Ice Cream Choice of small 8 oz. or pint.
$3.60+

Milkshakes

Vanilla Milkshake Choice of small 16 oz. or large 24 oz.
$5.40+
Chocolate Milkshake Choice of small 16 oz. or large 24 oz.
$5.40+
Strawberry Milkshake Choice of small 16 oz. or large 24 oz.
$5.40+
Strawberry Banana Milkshake Choice of small 16 oz. or large 24 oz.
$6.00+

Cold Beverages

Gatorade Lemon Lime, Orange, Fruit Punch.
$2.70
Snapple Lemon, Peach, Mango, Fruit Punch, Kiwi Strawberry.
$2.70
Canned Drink (12 oz.) Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mist Twist (Lemon-Lime Soda), Orange Soda, Iced Tea.
$1.50
Bottled Soda (20 oz.) Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Ginger Ale, Mist Twst (Lemon-Lime Soda), Orange Soda, Pineapple Soda, Grape Soda.
$3.90
Bottled Water
$1.50
2-Liter Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Root Beer, Ginger Ale, Mist Twist (Lemon-Lime Soda), Grape Soda, Fruit Punch, Iced Tea.
$3.90
Monster Energy Drink
$3.54
Red Bull (8.4 oz.)
$3.54
Homemade Iced Tea (24 oz.)
$2.10
Mango Punch (24 oz.)
$2.40
Homemade Lemonade
$2.40

Reviews for Pizza Plus #2

No reviews yet.

Back to Menu

Share your menu feedback with us: menus@eatstreet.com
All Pizza delivery & takeout options in New Haven
  1. Home
  2. New Haven, CT
  3. All New Haven Restaurants
  4. Pizza Plus #2

Your Order

Start Group Order
Pizza Plus #2
Proceed to Checkout $0.00
Empty Cart Illustration

Famished? Fill me up!

EatStreet
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Become a Driver!
Support
  • For Customers
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Restaurant Dashboard
  • API
  • Get EatStreet
  • Get Help
Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Restaurant Terms
Get the App
? 2022 EatStreet
Live Chat