Skip to main content
EatStreet Logo
  • profile
    Sign In
  • cart
    Cart
Back to Restaurant Search
Andy's Pizza Menu and Delivery in West Haven CT, 06516
  • Andy's Pizza

  • Pizza, Chicken Wings
  • 38 Sawmill Rd West Haven CT, 06516
    - 47 ratings
  • Hours 11:00am - 12:00am
  • ETA 40 - 55 min
  • Delivery Minimum $15.00
  • Delivery Cost $2.00

Popular Items

Cheese Pizza & Sauce Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$7.95+
Heaven Special Deal Large 16" cheese pizza, 12 buffalo wings, garlic cheese bread and a 2-liter soda.
$19.95
2-Liter Soda
$2.75
Milkshakes Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry or Oreo.
$3.75
Boneless Wings Choice of 12 pieces, 24 pieces, 36 pieces, or 40 pieces.
$11.95+

Coupons

Buy Any 1-Topping Party Pizza (32 Slices), Get A 2 Liter Soda Free Deal
$21.00
Heaven Special Deal Large 16" cheese pizza, 12 buffalo wings, garlic cheese bread and a 2-liter soda.
$19.95
Pizza & Wings Deal 2 Large Cheese Pizzas, 12 Buffalo Wings & 2 Liter Soda.
$26.95
Party Special Deal 2 Party Cheese Pizzas, 24 Buffalo Wings & 2 Liter Soda.
$49.95
Combo Meal Deal 1 medium cheese pizza, large tossed salad, garlic bread, and a 2-liter soda.
$19.95
Meal Deal 1 Small Cheese Pizza, 8 Buffalo Wings & a Can of Soda.
$12.95
2 For Deal 2 Large 16" Cheese Pizzas.
$18.95
Pizza Party Deal 1 - 24" Party Size Cheese Pizza (32 Slices), 24 Buffalo Wings & a 2 Liter Soda.
$29.95
2 Pizza Deal Large Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon & Meatballs), Small Cheese Pizza & a 2 Liter Soda.
$22.95

Pick Up Specials

16" Large Cheese Pizza Pick up Special
$8.95
24" Party Cheese Pizza Pick up Special

takeout-only Takeout orders only

$15.95

Appetizers

Chicken Fingers (6 Pieces)
$7.95
Chicken Nuggets (8 Pieces)
$5.95
French Fries
$3.50
French Fries with Melted Cheese
$4.00
Curly Fries
$3.50
Curly Fries With Melted Cheese
$4.25
Onion Rings
$3.95
Fried Calamari
$7.75
Potato Skins with Melted Cheese
$6.00
Potato Skins with Bacon & Melted Cheese
$7.50
Fried Shrimp (7 Pieces)
$7.95
Fried Mushrooms
$7.25
Fried Dough with Powdered Sugar or Sauce
$4.00
Spinach Pie
$4.75
Spinach Pie with Greek Salad
$8.25
Fried Clams
$6.95
Jalapeno Poppers (8 Pieces)
$7.75
Andy's Sampler 3 chicken fingers, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 jalapeno poppers.
$7.95
Fried Mozzarella Sticks (8 Pieces)
$7.95
Garlic Bread
$3.00
Garlic Bread with Cheese
$3.75
Garlic Bread with Pepperoni & Cheese
$4.95
Garlic Bread with Broccoli & Cheese
$4.00
3 Meatballs
$4.25
3 Sausages
$4.25

Wings

Choice of BBQ, Mild or Hot. Served with celery & ranch or bleu cheese. Extra dressing for $0.75.

Jumbo Buffalo Wings Choice of 8 pieces, 12 pieces, 24 pieces, 36 pieces, or 40 pieces.
$7.95+
Boneless Wings Choice of 12 pieces, 24 pieces, 36 pieces, or 40 pieces.
$11.95+

Salads

Available Dressing Choices: Bleu Cheese, Italian, Ranch, French, Caesar, Creamy Italian, Thousand Island or Oil & Vinegar. Extra Dressing for $0.75.

Garden Salad Choice of small or large.
$5.00+
Garden Salad w/ Chicken Choice of small or large.
$6.95+
Greek Salad Choice of small or large.
$6.50+
Greek Salad w/ Chicken Choice of small or large.
$7.95+
Caesar Salad Choice of small or large.
$5.95+
Caesar Salad w/ Chicken Choice of small or large.
$7.25+
Antipasto Salad Ham, salami, pepperoni & cheese. Choice of small or large.
$7.50+
Chef's Salad Ham, salami, turkey, roast beef, boiled eggs & cheese. Choice of small or large.
$7.25+
Tuna Salad Choice of small or large.
$6.50+
Cobb Salad Grilled chicken, bacon, boiled eggs, & Swiss cheese. Choice of small or large.
$7.95+
Crispy Chicken Salad Choice of small or large.
$7.95+
Andy's Salad Buffalo chicken. Choice of small or large.
$7.95+
Spinach Pie & Greek Salad
$8.50

Legendary Gourmet Pizza

Your choice of white or red sauce.

Dream of Heaven Pizza Beef gyro meat, feta & spinach. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$10.50+
Margherita Pizza Sliced tomatoes, garlic & basil. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$10.95+
Pollo Chicken Pizza Chicken, broccoli, tomatoes & basil. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
Meat Lovers Pizza Pepperoni, sausage, bacon & meatballs. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
Mexican Pizza Pepperoni, sausage, jalapeno peppers, bacon & tabasco sauce. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
Clam Casino Pizza Fresh garlic, bacon & sauteed clams in white wine. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$10.95+
Philly Steak Pizza Onions, peppers, mushrooms & philly steak. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
BBQ Chicken Pizza BBQ chicken & mozzarella. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$9.95+
Four Cheese Pizza Ricotta, mozzarella, provolone & grated romano. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$10.95+
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Buffalo chicken & mozzarella, served with a side of bleu cheese. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$9.95+
Andy's Works Pizza Bacon, pepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms & peppers. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
Fisherman Delight Pizza Shrimp, clams & calamari seasoned with garlic & white wine. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$12.95+
Pizza Fra Diavolo Jalapeno peppers, sausage, onions & tabasco. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
Hawaiian Pizza Ham, pineapple & mozzarella. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$9.95+
California Dream Pizza Roasted peppers, eggplant, artichoke hearts, olives & mushrooms. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
Eggplant Gourmet Pizza Eggplant, ricotta, sliced ham & mozzarella. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$10.95+
Veggie Pizza Mushrooms, onions, peppers, tomatoes, olives & broccoli. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
Pizza alla Bella Chicken cutlet, tomatoes, onions & garlic. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
Happy Lappy Pizza Grilled chicken, hot sauce, broccoli, roasted peppers, onions & garlic. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$11.95+
Salad Pizza Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, olives, peppers, feta & cucumbers, with Italian dressing. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$10.95+

Build Your Own Pizza

Your choice of white or red sauce.

Cheese Pizza & Sauce Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".
$7.95+

Calzones

Ricotta & Mozzarella Calzone Choice of small or large.
$7.95+
Veggie Calzone Choice of small or large.
$11.00+
Meatlovers Calzone Choice of small or large.
$11.95+

Strombolis

Broccoli, Spinach & Garlic Stromboli Choice of small or large.
$9.95+
Sausage, Onion, Peppers & Mushrooms Stromboli Choice of small or large.
$10.95+
Sausage, Bacon & Pepperoni Stromboli Served with marinara. Choice of small or large.
$11.00+

Dinners

Served with ziti, spaghetti or linguini, dinner salad, garlic bread and dressing on the side. Extra dressing for $0.75.

Spaghetti, Ziti or Linguini with Marinara Sauce
$7.95
Spaghetti, Ziti or Linguini with Meat Sauce
$8.25
Spaghetti, Ziti or Linguini with Meatball or Sausage
$9.25
Spaghetti, Ziti or Linguini with Sausage & Peppers
$8.75
Pasta with Clam Sauce Red or white.
$12.50
Cheese Ravioli
$9.50
Stuffed Shells
$9.50
Manicotti
$9.50
Baked Ziti With meatball or sausage for $1.00.
$8.95
Lasagna (Homemade)
$9.95
Chicken Parmigiana
$10.50
Veal Parmigiana
$10.50
Sausage & Pepper Parmigiana
$9.95
Eggplant Parmigiana
$9.95
Shrimp Parmigiana
$12.50
Chicken, Broccoli & Garlic
$10.95
Shrimp Scampi
$13.95
Italian Combo 2 stuffed shells, 2 manicotti, 2 cheese ravioli.
$10.95

Fried Dinners

Served with French Fries & tartar sauce. Substitute onion rings or curly fries for $1.00.

Fried Chicken Nuggets (12 Pieces)
$8.95
Shrimp Basket
$9.55
Fried Jumbo Shrimp (8 Pieces)
$9.55
Fried Chicken (4 Pieces)
$9.55
Fried Chicken Fingers (6 Pieces)
$9.45
Fried Scallops
$9.45
Fried Clam Strips
$9.55
Fish & Chips
$9.55
Seafood Combo Shrimp, clam, scallops & fish chips.
$12.45

Grinders, Sandwiches & Pitas

Served with lettuce, tomatoes & mayo. Add Meat for $1.50, Fries for $2.00 & Cheese for $0.50.

BLT Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Hamburger Choice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.
$5.00+
Turkey Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Ham & Cheese Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Salami Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Pepper & Egg Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Veggie Mushrooms, onions, peppers, olives, tomatoes, & broccoli. Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Roast Beef Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Grilled Turkey Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Grilled Chicken Choice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.
$5.50+
Buffalo Chicken Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.25+
Bacon Steak & Cheese Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.50+
Pepperoni Steak & Cheese Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.50+
Steak & Cheese Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Cheesebuger Choice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.
$5.00+
Chicken Cutlet Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Pastrami Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
Italian Combo Ham, salami, pepperoni & cheese. Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.00+
BBQ Chicken Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.
$5.25+

Hot Grinders

Served with cheese & sauce.

Meatball Grinder
$6.95
Sausage Grinder
$6.95
Meatball & Sausage Grinder
$7.50
Eggplant Grinder
$6.95
Chicken Parmigiana Grinder
$7.25
Veal Parmigiana Grinder
$7.25
Shrimp Parmigiana Grinder
$7.95
Sausage & Pepper Grinder
$7.25

Wraps

Served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & cheese. Make It a Deluxe with Fries, Curly Fries or Onion Rings for $2.00. Add Toppings for $0.50 each.

Chicken Cutlet Wrap
$6.95
Grilled Chicken Wrap
$6.95
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap
$6.95
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
$6.95
Steak Wrap
$6.95
BBQ Chicken Wrap
$6.95
Cheesebuger Wrap
$6.95
Ham & Cheese Wrap
$6.95
BLT Wrap
$6.95
Veggie Wrap
$6.95
Tuna Wrap
$6.95
Turkey Wrap
$6.95

From the Grill

All served with lettuce, tomatoes & mayo. Deluxe served with french fries & a pickle. Substitute onion rings or curly fries for $2.00.

Hamburger Choice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.
$5.25+
Bacon Hamburger Choice of regular or deluxe.
$6.25+
Double Hamburger Choice of regular or deluxe.
$7.00+
Cheesebuger Choice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.
$5.50+
Bacon Cheesebuger Choice of regular or deluxe.
$6.50+
Double Cheesebuger Choice of regular or deluxe.
$7.25+
Pizza Buger Choice of regular or deluxe.
$5.00+
Grilled Chicken Choice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.
$5.50+
Tuna Melt On rye with tomatoes. Choice of regular or deluxe.
$5.95+
Grilled Cheese Choice of regular or deluxe.
$3.95+
Grilled Cheese w/ Bacon or Ham Choice of regular or deluxe.
$4.95+
Grilled Cheese w/ Tomatoes Choice of regular or deluxe.
$4.45+
Pastrami Reuben Choice of regular or deluxe.
$5.95+
Beef Gyro or Chicken Souvlaki Greek Pitas Pita, cucumber sauce, feta, lettuce, tomatoes, onion. Choice of regular or deluxe.
$6.25+

Clubs

Served with bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo, french fries & a pickle. Substitute onion rings or curly fries for $1.00. Add cheese for $0.50.

BLT Club
$7.50
Ham Club
$7.50
Tuna Club
$7.50
Roast Beef Club
$7.50
Cheeseburger Club
$7.75
Grilled Chicken Club
$7.95
Turkey Club
$7.75
Hamburger Club
$7.50
Steak Club
$7.95
Salami Club
$7.25
Italian Combo Club
$7.50

Desserts

Ice Cream
$2.50
Cheese Cake
$3.50
Carrot Cake
$3.50
Chocolate Cake
$3.50
Baklava
$3.50

Beverages

20 oz. Soda
$1.75
Can of Soda
$1.25
2-Liter Soda
$2.75
Milkshakes Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry or Oreo.
$3.75
Bottled Water
$1.25
Snapple
$1.75

Catering Trays

Small Tray Serves 8-10 People & Large Tray Serves 15-18 People.

Meatballs Tray Choice of small or large.
$29.95+
Baked Ziti Tray Choice of small or large.
$29.95+
Ziti with Sauce Tray Choice of small or large.
$21.95+
Chicken Parmigiana Tray Choice of small or large.
$39.95+
Fried Calamari Tray Choice of small or large.
$50.95+
Eggplant Parmigiana Tray Choice of small or large.
$40.95+
Lasagna Tray Choice of small or large.
$40.95+
Stuffed Shells Tray Choice of small or large.
$35.95+
Manicotti Tray Choice of small or large.
$35.95+
Chicken & Broccoli Tray Choice of small or large.
$40.95+
Chef's Salad Tray Choice of small or large.
$32.95+
Garden Salad Tray Choice of small or large.
$18.95+
Antipasto Salad Tray Choice of small or large.
$30.95+
Buffalo Wings Choice of serves 100 or serves 150.
$75.95+

Back to Menu

Reviews for Andy's Pizza

2 Reviews
2 Reviews
Rated 2 out of 5
Jan 11, 2020
Melissa G
Ordered wings. They arrived extremely hard and dry hardly any buffalo sauce. Disappointed to say the least.
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 5 out of 5
Jul 27, 2018
Sarah L
Food was great
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate

Back to Menu

Share your menu feedback with us: menus@eatstreet.com
All Pizza delivery & takeout options in New Haven
  1. Home
  2. New Haven, CT
  3. All New Haven Restaurants
  4. Andy's Pizza

Your Order

Start Group Order
Andy's Pizza
Proceed to Checkout $0.00
Empty Cart Illustration

Famished? Fill me up!

EatStreet
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Become a Driver!
Support
  • For Customers
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Restaurant Dashboard
  • API
  • Get EatStreet
  • Get Help
Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • California Privacy Notice
  • Restaurant Terms
Get the App
? 2021 EatStreet
Live Chat
We collect your Personal Information when you use this Site. By continuing to use our Site, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy