- Popular Items
- Cheese Pizza & SauceChoice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$11.40+
- 2-Liter Soda$4.20
- MilkshakesChocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry or Oreo.$5.40
- Heaven Special DealLarge 16" cheese pizza, 12 buffalo wings, garlic cheese bread and a 2-liter soda.$27.54
- Boneless Wings$9.54+
- Coupons
- 2 Large Pizzas2 Large 16" cheese pizzas.$23.94
- Pizza Party Deal1 - 24" Party Size Cheese Pizza (32 Slices), 24 Buffalo Wings & a 2 Liter Soda.$73.19
- Heaven Special DealLarge 16" cheese pizza, 12 buffalo wings, garlic cheese bread and a 2-liter soda.$27.54
- 2 Pizza DealLarge Meat Lovers (Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon & Meatballs), Small Cheese Pizza & a 2 Liter Soda.$28.74
- 2 Medium Pizzas2 Medium 14" Cheese pizzas.$21.54
- 24" Party Side2 Topping Pizza (32 Slices.).$27.54
- Pizza & Wings Deal2 Large Cheese Pizzas, 12 Buffalo Wings & 2 Liter Soda.$33.54
- Party Special Deal2 Party Cheese Pizzas, 24 Buffalo Wings & 2 Liter Soda.$59.94
- Combo Meal Deal1 medium cheese pizza, large tossed salad, garlic bread, and a 2-liter soda.$23.94
- Meal Deal1 Small Cheese Pizza, 8 Buffalo Wings & a Can of Soda.$16.74
- Pick Up Specials
- 16" Large Cheese Pizza Pick up Special$11.99
- 24" Party Cheese Pizza Pick up Special
$20.34
- Appetizers
- Chicken Fingers (6 Pieces)$9.54
- Chicken Nuggets (8 Pieces)$7.14
- French Fries$4.74
- French Fries with Melted Cheese$5.40
- Curly Fries$4.80
- Curly Fries With Melted Cheese$5.70
- Onion Rings$5.40
- Fried Calamari$9.30
- Potato Skins with Melted Cheese$7.20
- Potato Skins with Bacon & Melted Cheese$9.00
- Fried Shrimp (7 Pieces)$9.54
- Fried Mushrooms$8.70
- Fried Dough with Powdered Sugar or Sauce$5.40
- Spinach Pie$6.00
- Fried Clams$8.34
- Mozzarella Sticks (8 Pieces)$9.54
- Andy's Sampler3 chicken fingers, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 jalapeno poppers.$9.54
- Garlic Bread$3.60
- Garlic Bread with Cheese$5.99
- Garlic Bread with Pepperoni & Cheese$5.94
- Garlic Bread with Broccoli & Cheese$5.94
- 3 Meatballs$5.94
- 3 Sausages$5.94
- Garlic Knots (10)$9.54
- Wings
- Choice of BBQ, Mild or Hot. Served with celery & ranch or bleu cheese.
- Jumbo Buffalo WingsChoice of 8 pieces, 12 pieces, 24 pieces, 36 pieces, or 40 pieces.$9.54+
- Boneless Wings$9.54+
- Salads
- Available Dressing Choices: Bleu Cheese, Italian, Ranch, French, Caesar, Creamy Italian, Thousand Island, Balsamic Vinaigrette or Oil & Vinegar.
- Garden SaladChoice of small or large.$6.90+
- Garden Salad w/ ChickenChoice of small or large.$10.20+
- Greek SaladChoice of small or large.$8.34+
- Greek Salad w/ ChickenChoice of small or large.$10.14+
- Caesar SaladChoice of small or large.$7.20+
- Caesar Salad w/ ChickenChoice of small or large.$10.20+
- Antipasto SaladHam, salami, pepperoni & cheese. Choice of small or large.$10.20+
- Chef's SaladHam, salami, turkey, roast beef, boiled eggs & cheese. Choice of small or large.$10.20+
- Tuna SaladChoice of small or large.$7.80+
- Cobb SaladGrilled chicken, bacon, boiled eggs, & Swiss cheese. Choice of small or large.$10.50+
- Crispy Chicken SaladChoice of small or large.$10.50+
- Buffalo Chicken SaladChoice of small or large.$10.20+
- BBQ Chicken SaladChoice of small or large.$10.20+
- Mexican SaladGrilled chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, green peppers, olives, pepperoncini, jalapenos & bacon. Choice of small or large.$10.50+
- Spinach Pie & Greek Salad$11.40
- Legendary Gourmet Pizza
- Your choice of white or red sauce.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch PizzaCrispy chicken, bacon & mozzarella with ranch drizzle. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$15.00+
- Dream of Heaven PizzaBeef gyro meat, feta & spinach. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Pollo Chicken PizzaChicken, broccoli, tomatoes & basil. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Mexican PizzaPepperoni, sausage, jalapeno peppers, bacon & tabasco sauce. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Philly Steak PizzaOnions, peppers, mushrooms & philly steak. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Four Cheese PizzaRicotta, mozzarella, provolone & grated romano. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Andy's Works PizzaBacon, pepperoni, sausage, onions, mushrooms & peppers. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Pizza Fra DiavoloJalapeno peppers, sausage, onions & tabasco. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- California Dream PizzaRoasted peppers, eggplant, artichoke hearts, olives & mushrooms. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Veggie PizzaMushrooms, onions, peppers, tomatoes, olives & broccoli. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Happy Lappy PizzaGrilled chicken, hot sauce, broccoli, roasted peppers, onions & garlic. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Margherita PizzaSliced tomatoes, garlic & basil. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Meat Lovers PizzaPepperoni, sausage, bacon & meatballs. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Clam Casino PizzaFresh garlic, bacon & sauteed clams in white wine. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- BBQ Chicken PizzaBBQ chicken & mozzarella. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Buffalo Chicken PizzaBuffalo chicken & mozzarella, served with a side of bleu cheese. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Fisherman Delight PizzaShrimp, clams & calamari seasoned with garlic & white wine. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$15.54+
- Hawaiian PizzaHam, pineapple & mozzarella. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Eggplant Gourmet PizzaEggplant, ricotta, sliced ham & mozzarella. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$13.14+
- Pizza alla BellaChicken cutlet, tomatoes, onions & garlic. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Salad PizzaLettuce, tomatoes, onions, olives, peppers, feta & cucumbers, with Italian dressing. Choice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$14.34+
- Build Your Own Pizza
- Your choice of white or red sauce.
- Cheese Pizza & SauceChoice of small 10", medium 14", large 16", or party 24".$11.40+
- Calzones
- Ricotta & Mozzarella CalzoneChoice of small or large.$9.54+
- Veggie CalzoneChoice of small or large.$13.20+
- Meatlovers CalzoneChoice of small or large.$14.34+
- Strombolis
- Broccoli, Spinach & Garlic StromboliChoice of small or large.$13.20+
- Sausage, Onion, Peppers & Mushrooms StromboliChoice of small or large.$13.20+
- Sausage, Bacon & Pepperoni StromboliServed with marinara. Choice of small or large.$13.20+
- Dinners
- Served with ziti, spaghetti or linguini, dinner salad, garlic bread and dressing on the side.
- Spaghetti or Ziti with Marinara Sauce$11.94
- Spaghetti or Ziti with Meat Sauce$13.14
- Spaghetti or Ziti with Meatball or Sausage$13.14
- Pasta with Clam SauceRed or white.$15.00
- Cheese Ravioli$13.14
- Stuffed Shells$13.14
- Manicotti$13.14
- Baked Ziti$13.14
- Lasagna (Homemade)$14.34
- Chicken Parmigiana$14.34
- Veal Parmigiana$14.34
- Sausage & Pepper Parmigiana$14.34
- Eggplant Parmigiana$14.34
- Shrimp Parmigiana$16.20
- Fried Dinners
- Served with French Fries & tartar sauce.
- Fried Chicken Nuggets (12 Pieces)$10.74
- Shrimp Basket$11.94
- Fried Jumbo Shrimp (8 Pieces)$12.90
- Fried Chicken (4 Pieces)$13.14
- Fried Chicken Fingers (6 Pieces)$11.94
- Fried Clam Strips$12.90
- Fish & Chips$13.14
- Seafood ComboShrimp, clam, scallops & fish chips.$16.74
- Grinders, Sandwiches & Pitas
- Served with lettuce, tomatoes & mayo.
- BLTChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- HamburgerChoice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.$7.20+
- TurkeyChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- Ham & CheeseChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- SalamiChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- Pepper & EggChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- VeggieMushrooms, onions, peppers, olives, tomatoes, & broccoli. Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- Roast BeefChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- Grilled TurkeyChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- Grilled ChickenChoice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.$7.50+
- Buffalo ChickenChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- Bacon Steak & CheeseChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.50+
- Pepperoni Steak & CheeseChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.50+
- Steak & CheeseChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- CheesebugerChoice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.$7.20+
- Chicken CutletChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- PastramiChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- Italian ComboHam, salami, pepperoni & cheese. Choice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- BBQ ChickenChoice of grinder, sandwich, or pita.$7.20+
- Hot Grinders
- Served with cheese & sauce.
- Meatball Grinder$10.50
- Sausage Grinder$10.50
- Meatball & Sausage Grinder$10.50
- Eggplant Grinder$10.50
- Chicken Parmigiana Grinder$10.50
- Veal Parmigiana Grinder$10.50
- Shrimp Parmigiana Grinder$10.50
- Sausage & Pepper Grinder$10.50
- Wraps
- Served with lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & cheese. Make It a Deluxe with Fries, Curly Fries or Onion Rings.
- Chicken Cutlet Wrap$10.74
- Grilled Chicken Wrap$10.74
- Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap$10.74
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap$10.74
- Steak Wrap$10.74
- BBQ Chicken Wrap$10.74
- Cheesebuger Wrap$10.74
- Ham & Cheese Wrap$10.74
- BLT Wrap$10.74
- Veggie Wrap$10.74
- Tuna Wrap$10.74
- Turkey Wrap$10.74
- From the Grill
- All served with lettuce, tomatoes & mayo. Deluxe served with french fries & a pickle.
- HamburgerChoice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.$6.90+
- Bacon HamburgerChoice of regular or deluxe.$8.10+
- Double HamburgerChoice of regular or deluxe.$9.30+
- CheesebugerChoice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.$7.20+
- Bacon CheesebugerChoice of regular or deluxe.$8.40+
- Double CheesebugerChoice of regular or deluxe.$9.60+
- Pizza BugerChoice of regular or deluxe.$7.50+
- Grilled ChickenChoice of grinder, sandwich, pita, regular, or deluxe.$7.80+
- Tuna MeltOn rye with tomatoes. Choice of regular or deluxe.$8.10+
- Grilled CheeseChoice of regular or deluxe.$4.74+
- Grilled Cheese w/ Bacon or HamChoice of regular or deluxe.$5.94+
- Grilled Cheese w/ TomatoesChoice of regular or deluxe.$5.34+
- Chicken MeltGrilled chicken breast on rye bread with grilled mushrooms, peppers onion & swiss. Choice of regular or deluxe.$8.10+
- Beef Gyro or Chicken Souvlaki Greek PitasPita, cucumber sauce, feta, lettuce, tomatoes, onion. Choice of regular or deluxe.$7.80+
- Clubs
- Served with bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, mayo, french fries & a pickle. Substitute onion rings or curly fries.
- BLT Club$10.50
- Ham Club$10.50
- Tuna Club$10.50
- Roast Beef Club$10.50
- Cheeseburger Club$10.50
- Grilled Chicken Club$10.50
- Turkey Club$10.50
- Hamburger Club$10.50
- Steak Club$10.50
- Salami Club$10.50
- Italian Combo Club$10.50
- Desserts
- Ice Cream$4.20
- Cheese Cake$4.74
- Carrot Cake$4.74
- Chocolate Cake$4.74
- Baklava$4.74
- Oreo Cake$4.74
- Beverages
- Can of Soda$1.50
- 20 oz. Soda$2.40
- 2-Liter Soda$4.20
- MilkshakesChocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry or Oreo.$5.40
- Catering Trays
- Small Tray Serves 8-10 People & Large Tray Serves 15-18 People.
- Meatballs TrayChoice of small or large.$35.94+
- Baked Ziti TrayChoice of small or large.$35.94+
- Ziti with Sauce TrayChoice of small or large.$26.34+
- Chicken Parmigiana TrayChoice of small or large.$47.94+
- Fried Calamari TrayChoice of small or large.$61.14+
- Eggplant Parmigiana TrayChoice of small or large.$49.14+
- Lasagna TrayChoice of small or large.$49.14+
- Stuffed Shells TrayChoice of small or large.$43.14+
- Manicotti TrayChoice of small or large.$43.14+
- Chicken & Broccoli TrayChoice of small or large.$49.14+
- Chef's Salad TrayChoice of small or large.$39.54+
- Garden Salad TrayChoice of small or large.$22.74+
- Antipasto Salad TrayChoice of small or large.$37.14+
- Buffalo WingsChoice of serves 100 or serves 150.$91.14+
Back to Menu
Reviews for Andy's Pizza
2 Reviews
Back to Menu
- Home
- New Haven, CT
- All New Haven Restaurants
- Andy's Pizza