Name: The Pie Guys Pizzeria
Address: 3106 James St., Syracuse, NY, 13206
Rating: 3.9

Wednesday Special

Everyday Specials

Brick Oven Pizza

Specialty Pizzas

Choice of medium 14" or large 16".

Gyros

Calzones/Stromboli

Wings

Fish Fry

Hot Heros

Subs

Appetizers

Fresh Salads

Monday Special

Medium specialty pizza special.

Hours Today: Unavailable all day.

These items are not currently available

Reviews for The Pie Guys Pizzeria

278 ratings

Jul 11, 2025
The food was good, but I think they just left my delivery on the counter and forgot about it, the app showed it "out for delivery" for an excessive amount of time (more than an hour). After 2 hours I called and they said it would be to me in 4 minutes, I am 5 minutes away according to Google. You make your own inference from that. But again, the food was very good, and I believe a good value.
Jun 5, 2025
Fast delivery, reasonable prices, delicious food
Feb 7, 2025
we order here weekly. Always great pizza, ready on time and delicious!
Dec 14, 2024
I order the same thing pretty much every week. it always ready, Hot, fresh and tasty
Nov 2, 2024
The food was good, they forgot my order, waited 40 minutes at the establishment had to leave, they deliver my pizza later. I ordered the pizza online at around 4:15, receive my pizza at 5:45. Unacceptable.
Nov 1, 2024
Order was lost, took 40 minutes at the restaurant waiting. Had to leave, it had to be delivered. Placed order 415, didn?t receive the pizza to almost 6 o?clock.
Sep 27, 2024
Instead of knocking on the door, pizza was left on my NEIGHBORS porch??..found it about 20 minutes after it was supposed to be delivered. So it was pretty cold. Why was it cut like breadsticks? It might have been good hot??.
Nov 25, 2023
Antipasto was completely different than the previous times we ordered it and was not as good . Pizza was delicious
Aug 25, 2023
I ordered online the pepperoni and onion pizza. It was ready when I got there. Absolutely delicious.
Feb 19, 2023
Didnt recieve my order, place was closed
Dec 14, 2022
pizza was ice cold (and not from being outside) and was not what I ordered. Delivery was fast ,
Oct 3, 2022
We didn't get the pizzas that we ordered online.
Aug 14, 2022
Awesome pizza. Can't have enough of their sauce. They provide an option for extra sauce on the pizza. I wish they provided an option for extra extra sauce on the pizza. Great experience will definitely be a repeat customer.
Aug 13, 2022
Very hot fresh and delicious pizza
Jun 28, 2022
The calzones were not cooked all the way through. I can handle a little bit of dough as I realize the cheese and any toppings you might have would make it hard to cook thoroughly, but it was only cheese and pepperoni and it was literally globby dough in the thickest parts. I had enough cooked to satisfy me for the meal, so I didn't call and complain. Just some constructive criticism.
Mar 21, 2022
First time ordering from here, and if in the area again, will definitely go back. Chicken wing pizza - crispy chicken, perfect amount of sauce, delicious thin crust. Now the sandwich?.wasnt sure how big it would be so went for a large. And LARGE it was. Italian meat sandwich. Thickest cut ham, salami and provolone i have ever seen. Soft italian roll. Drizzled in sweet italian dressing. Sloppy and amazing all at the same time. Could barely eat a half. SO GOOD!!
Feb 21, 2022
Forgot part of my order but brought it back quickly. And I seemed to have the wrong gyro too so that was fixed.
Jan 9, 2022
Pie Guys are excellent. We have enjoyed several menu items. The delivery man was wonderful too - timely, polite and friendly. Great experience all around!
Dec 13, 2021
Hot and fresh
Aug 5, 2021
Great pizza. Also great fried haddock. And they know to poke holes in the take out container so it doesn't get soggy...
Jul 30, 2021
Awesome!! Pizza delicious, everyone raved about the wings
Jul 25, 2021
Best pizza I've had in quite awhile. Ate leftovers for breakfast and dinner next day.
Jul 9, 2021
Amazing. My new favorite pizza place!!
Jun 24, 2021
I had food delivered for the admin staff at the office. I was told it was enjoyed and good, delivery was earlier than I had anticipated but the time I had hoped for.
Jun 10, 2021
Great Pizza
Jun 9, 2021
Food was great, timing was off a bit (had to wait extra 15 mins).
May 28, 2021
Very tasty. Pizza was hot and. Ready on time.
May 23, 2021
Great! On time. Would order again.
Apr 25, 2021
Was so easy ordering online, was ready when we were told to pick up. Pizza and wings were perfect! Service was very friendly and quick. Highly recommebd
Mar 20, 2021
Never a issue
Feb 28, 2021
I paid $50.00 for the driver to spill our wings all over. Her car was disgusting. Needless to say I wasn't even able to eat it.
Jan 21, 2021
My favorite is the Supreme. The crust was crunchy outside which I like.
Jan 7, 2021
Great pizza, highly recommend PieGuys
Dec 31, 2020
Great Pizza and very friendly employees. Will be going back soon!
Dec 7, 2020
It made us sick
Nov 28, 2020
Delicious, flavorful pizza. Amazing wings. Tasty chicken tenders.
Nov 12, 2020
Best pizza around.
Nov 10, 2020
Always great pizza and wings. My go-to pizza place in Syracuse.
Oct 4, 2020
Great service and tasty food!
Sep 13, 2020
Excellent food and great prices.
Aug 5, 2020
Contact less delivery was even quicker than stated and the pizza was delicious!
Jun 25, 2020
Never disappointed
Dec 12, 2019
I literally don't know how you guys could improve because your that good!! Will be ordering again and again
Nov 21, 2019
We ordered a small antipasto and two hot subs! Everything was amazing! Would definitely recommend.
Nov 15, 2019
Very good product
Nov 2, 2019
As always delicious wings! The extra condiments were not packaged well and all dumped
Sep 1, 2019
Our pizza would have been much better if the dough was a bit thinner. it didn't taste like it was cooked enough. It was too thick to enjoy it. Also, when I place the order on line, it had pepperoni on it, which I didn't want. I was able to call and have the item removed before they made the pie, but if I hadn't gone over everything carefully, it would have been easily over looked. It seems like it's easy to make a mistake ordering n the internet.
Jul 18, 2019
The driver from eat streets was fast and friendly!! How ever I received my FIRST EVER unsatisfying pizzas yet! My pizzas were under cooked but for 2yrs I have been eating pizza from guy's pizza and NEVER once until last night not been happy.
Jul 6, 2019
Got the Potato Pizza, flavor was good, wish it had been cut in slices more conventionally.
May 19, 2019
Great service .. we love the menu

Back to Menu

The Pie Guys Pizzeria

Popular Items