Name: Molly McGuire's
Address: 539 Campus Pl, Oshkosh, WI, 54901
Rating: 3.7

Pre Game

Wraps and Salads

Fan Favorites

Wings and More

Sandwiches and Burgers

All sandwiches and burgers come with your choice of fries, tater tots, coleslaw, or chips.

Quesadillas

After Party

Wednesday Special

Reviews for Molly McGuire's

308 ratings

Jun 6, 2026
Very good food, but could offer a side salad instead
Aug 23, 2025
Excellent quality, service, and prices... Always look forward to Molly's smile
Sep 22, 2024
Bacon burger was too salty! Threw half away!
May 28, 2024
VERY GOOD FOOD!!! Great prices
Apr 9, 2024
Wings were good!
Feb 27, 2024
Was very good. Very reasonably priced. And accommodated my special request. Really good food!!!
Jan 31, 2024
My steak sandwich was bland, over cooked, probably 1/4 of it was fat, and the added mushrooms didn't add anything and were canned. The chicken tender sandwich had barely melted cheese like it was microwaved and the bacon was mostly fat. Our tatertots were soggy, but I suppose the container didn't help. The chicken tortilla bites were decent, but I wish there was a description as to what they were because I imagined something like quesadilla bites. Also the brownies were good, but it's just listed as "Fudge Brownie" when they are prepackaged salted caramel brownies, maybe that's Eatstreets fault, but overall disappointed with our meal and won't be ordering again.
Dec 3, 2023
Excellent food as always
Dec 1, 2023
Prime rib sandwich was amazing as was the Irish potatoes
Nov 4, 2023
The food is always amazing. Extremely fast delivery piping hot when it gets here. Highly recommend
Oct 14, 2023
The food was semi cold when I got it and said it would take 35 mins took over an hour which doesn't really matter just would of been nice to of known is all.
Oct 4, 2023
The fish I ordered was disgusting. There was twice as much breading as fish - I weighed it after peeling burnt on the outside, gummy on the inside slabs of breading off in search of edible fish. Pro tip - check your fryer temperature. It was nearly inedible but I was hungry so I managed. Fortunately the cole slaw and potato salad were pretty tasty. The broasted chicken was a tad overbrown as well. Luckily it did not dry out the chicken. I had that and the mashed potatoes and gravy for breakfast this morning and it was tasty.
Sep 18, 2023
The chef is top notch. Food is always amazing.
Aug 23, 2023
My order sucked. First, the chicken was cooked in old oil and over cooked. Two, the six piece order only included dark pieces. At lease one breast should have been included. Last, the order was supposed to include potato salad and coleslaw. Neither were included.
Aug 17, 2023
Never a disappointment with Molly's. Best Quesada's around.
Jul 15, 2023
Was never notifies it was her waste of 80 bucks
Jun 2, 2023
Food was good and was delivered hot ..Very quick delivery.
May 17, 2023
Fast service! The food was delicious and fresh with great portions. I had their take on a Cuban with the spicy tater tots. I didn't read that the tots were spicy, so I was pleasantly surprised. Will definitely order again!
May 6, 2023
This chef is top notch excellent food never have been let down yet
Apr 30, 2023
Excellent!!
Apr 5, 2023
Portions were small, $6 for a tiny side of MASHED POTATOES that should already come with the $12 4pc boasted chicken anyway.. onion rings were burnt, fries were cold and soggy.. overall horrible experience for our group who spent over $100 on our meal. Will never return.
Mar 25, 2023
I would still give him a five-star even though our order was not exactly what we ordered. We wanted onions only on the chickens sandwich and we got all the extras and no onions. We ordered ranch dressing or tartar sauce for the french fries for one meal and we can get either. The sauce for the chicken had opened and spilled all over inside the bag so there wasn't any left to put it on the chicken... But with all that the food was still delicious and it's always delicious!!
Mar 12, 2023
Great food!
Feb 25, 2023
Chicken was overcooked to the point of having black skin. The mashed potatoes were box mix and for the price was a total rip off
Feb 23, 2023
Great.
Feb 10, 2023
Good burgers fries oversalted
Dec 18, 2022
Best hamburger I have ever eaten staffers friendly top notch chef couldn?t be any better
Dec 3, 2022
It was extra yummy all three chicken sandwiches were wonderful it's just that I think it's the second or third time that they forgot the raw onions on the one sandwich and that's kind of disappointing but it's not the end of the world. Always great service
Nov 11, 2022
The hamburger was amazing they just forgot the onions that we wanted on it which is kind of disappointing but it wasn't the end of the world. The coleslaw is good. The spicy chicken sandwich was great I love it. The tater tost we're really good too. thank you for asking
Sep 17, 2022
Both were burnt no salsa or sour cream like usual
Aug 3, 2022
I got the incorrect sauce on my wings; I ordered Honey BBQ and got something that looked and smelled like a Honey Mustard sauce instead. I have a slight allergy to mustard and as I couldn't be sure what it was, I couldn't eat these, I had to toss them. The sauce had a yellow color to it.
Jul 29, 2022
Delicious and delivered quickly!!
Jul 9, 2022
Good food. Decent prices came fast.
Jun 10, 2022
Asked for coleslaw, I got fries
May 6, 2022
Everything was pretty good, except the wings; I got the wrong flavor. I got Honey Mustard NOT Honey BBQ. I'm not sure why I do these surveys because I know nothing will happen.
Apr 9, 2022
My boyfriend and I were extremely impressed by the quality and taste of the food! It only took 20 minutes to get here on a Friday night. Amazing!
Feb 12, 2022
In the past I have enjoyed the food from Molly McGuire's, which is why I returned to order again. This time the broasted chicken tasted of old oil, and was very greasy. To find a way to make it palatable I had to bury the meat in a Tikka Masala sauce. When I unrolled the "ruben eggrolls" or whatever they call them I was seriously disappointed. I found only a few tiny specks of corned beef and a load of mashed potatoes. If you are going to sell potato perogies, call it that. To breathe the word "corned beef" around them was a bald faced lie. Sadly for me, I was counting on the protein from the beef to make a meal out of the rolls. Instead, I have a dish of mashed potatoes without any protein to be found. I am afraid it will be a long time before I return to McGuire's. There are other, better places in the area these days.
Feb 6, 2022
The food was just what we were looking for?quick, reasonably priced comfort food.
Feb 2, 2022
Food was amazing! We just got chicken sandwiches but the Irish rolls were super yummy as well as the fried pickles!! I ordered 2 regular chicken sandwiches and two spicy. I got 3 spicy and one regular. But it?s fine because they were all delicious!
Jan 20, 2022
The burgers are huge!
Dec 31, 2021
Always the best food! Love the extras !
Dec 20, 2021
Food was delivered 45 minutes after expected time and was out for delivery for 30 minutes. Food was cold and inedible
Dec 19, 2021
Food was perfect. Thank you!
Dec 4, 2021
My order was left on the ground and nobody rang my doorbell
Nov 22, 2021
It arrived hot and done to perfection.
Nov 13, 2021
No one let us know they delivered the food and that it was sitting on our porch. Mmmm ice cold wings and a BLT.
Oct 15, 2021
Great food and quick delivery
Sep 26, 2021
Food was OK fries were a bit overcooked
Sep 19, 2021
we LOVE mollys wings!
Sep 17, 2021
Burger was great, coleslaw hit the spot. Gotta love tato egg rolls. Yummy

Back to Menu

Molly McGuire's

Popular Items