Monty's Blue Plate Diner Menu & Delivery Madison WI 53704 | EatStreet.com
Monty's Blue Plate Diner Menu and Delivery in Madison WI, 53704

Monty's Blue Plate Diner

Diner Food, Burgers
903 ratings

Back to Menu

Reviews for Monty's Blue Plate Diner
903 ratings
    Oct 25, 2025

    I didn?t like the hamburger. Maybe it was a combination of pork and beef. I like beef only burgers and rarely partake of pork products.

    Sep 29, 2025

    Forgot Orange Juice

    Sep 21, 2025

    Very good and a good portion delivery was also great

    Sep 19, 2025

    I'm a HUGE fan of their coffee oat ice cream shake. Delicious.

    Sep 17, 2025

    My food was delicious however the service was not as amazing which was unusual. So maybe an off day for the counter person but whatever the case I hope they are having a better day.

    Aug 28, 2025

    Ordered 2 burgers and a scoop of overram

    Jul 12, 2025

    Monty?s does not disappoint. My tofu scramble was so good! The waffle fries were very good as well. I highly recommend Monty?s!!

    Jun 12, 2025

    Had a big breakfast with coconut cream pie. Both were delicious.

    May 30, 2025

    Delivery was timely. Food was great !! Good communication.

    May 12, 2025

    Ordered 5 entrees with a mix of omelets, burger, sandwiches, and slice of pie for pick up to eat at our hotel. Made comment in order for mustard, ketchup etc. No condiments or plastic silverware to eat with?? Instead of 2 bags to carry, they stuffed all 5 entrees in bag and put pie on side???!!! So pie was all busted up and falling apart. When ordering for take out, people need utensils to eat. Do better

    May 12, 2025

    Food was great! I wish there was a way to be informed of things that aren't available so I could change my order instead of just being refunded.

    Mar 4, 2025

    The food seems a bit sloppy. They also forgot the rolls. The delivery was fine.

    Feb 24, 2025

    There was a bug in my son's chicken Sesame salad. Food was below average.

    Jan 26, 2025

    Tried the fish fry, I am meatloaf fan. Literally dumped uncooked fries in my container. Two small oily fish. Up yours!

    Jan 11, 2025

    The kids lived their meals. Thank you.

    Sep 20, 2024

    It was

    Sep 15, 2024

    Monty's food is quite good overall, but the fish fry was disappointing. The batter was very oily and slid off the fish when I took a bit. I wish the cole slaw had been creamy rather than vinegary.

    Aug 2, 2024

    The chicken on the chicken sandwich is pounded so thin and then deep fried. The most dry chicken sandwich I have ever had. I thought I was eating a chicken potato chip. Lol. Will not order that sandwich again

    Jun 29, 2024

    Great food - just what I needed.

    Jun 28, 2024

    The food was okay. I ordered a meal with English muffins. The muffins were like hockey pucks.

    Jun 20, 2024

    Usually the food is excellent but this order was not as good as usual. Mashed potatoes were oversalted, and vegetables were undercooked.

    Mar 14, 2024

    My food was delicious except that the fries were not hot and I was missing the shake, so I had to re-order it and pay double.

    Mar 4, 2024

    Always good food from Monty?s!

    Mar 2, 2024

    The burger was good. The rest of the order did not come. I ordered 2 slices of pie that did not make it. I was given my money back for the pie. I feel like it should have been delivered anyway. If a mistake was made go get the pie and bring it to me. The person I spoke to blamed it on Montys, which is also wrong. The delivery person should confirm the order. I am a long time user of eatstreet, but lately there has been poor service. I use it because it is a local company, but may go to a more professional service.

    Jan 22, 2024

    Food is always good- the menu on Eatstreet needs to be updated though. Items that say what kind of egg prepartaion is included (for example, eggs mornay says poached) then require you to pick how you want your egg prepared and lists every option BUT poached. (over easy, hard, scrambled, etc). Then I have to leave a comment to the kitchen instructing them to ignore the egg preparation I selected and prepare how it's normally done which I'm sure is annoying and confusing. I believe I've submitted this feedback before and it's been messed up for quite some time, so it would be cool if whoever is in charge of updating eatstreet options would fix that

    Jan 20, 2024

    The delivery took over an hour and I had to reheat some of it.

    Dec 13, 2023

    they forgot my salad

    Oct 29, 2023

    Order was delivered to the wrong address. It took them forever to straighten it out and by the time they decided to just credit us, it was late and we were hungry

    Oct 22, 2023

    Good poisoning

    Oct 5, 2023

    Shake was missing from the order and the sandwich came with waffle fries instead of regular fries.

    Sep 10, 2023

    The food tasted good but we got sick after eating and we just ate half.

    Aug 30, 2023

    Food was not correct that was delivered

    Aug 30, 2023

    One diner received a burger with a bun that was deliberately sliced in a way so that the bun fell apart. The burger had to be eaten with a knife and fork. One diner received a sandwich that was made with TWO bread ends. The creamy tomato soup was curdled. Really, Monty's? Diner food should be reliably good or great. This was definitely not good.

    Jul 29, 2023

    The food was very good. The side of potatoes in my order was about half of what I normally get though.

    Jul 13, 2023

    The staff & management at this restaurant always provide delicious food and an enjoyable experience--although Monty's Blue Plate Diner has been in operation _forever_, their menu presents fresh twists to delight us !

    Jul 2, 2023

    The staff & management at this restaurant always provide delicious food and an enjoyable experience--although Monty's Blue Plate Diner has been in operation _forever_, their menu presents fresh twists to delight us ! Laurie W.

    Jun 24, 2023

    Friday Fish Fry, huge salads, and breakfast all day - what else could anyone possibly want? :)

    Jun 18, 2023

    Monty?s forgot to include the dinner rolls. I do not see this as an error of Eat Street but of Monty?s. I wanted Eatstreet to know.

    Jun 4, 2023

    The fish was very good, I did not like the coleslaw, it seemed bitter. The fries were a bit soggy but still good. I wasn't thrilled with the bun, it seemed old. Of course everything would have been better if I had gone to the restaurant.

    May 12, 2023

    More great food from Monty's Blue Plate ! The carrot cake for dessert was the tastiest I have ever had ! ! Laurie W.

    May 1, 2023

    For the most part, the whole experience was good. Arrived fast, excellent food. The only problem is that I ordered 2 vegan shakes (under the ?vegan desserts? heading on the EatStreet menu), which say that they are made with oat milk ice cream in the description, but do not ring up or show up on the receipt as vegan. So, they arrived was dairy milkshakes. This was particularly upsetting to the person who ordered with us and is a strict vegan. The vegan shake is the only thing they ordered, and thank goodness it arrived with whipped cream on it, which tipped us off that they may contain dairy *before* they ate it. It is important that Monty?s review their EatStreet menu and how the items are appearing on the receipt and how they are prepared.

    Apr 27, 2023

    Food was cold and hard as concrete.

    Apr 1, 2023

    Great - wish I had more mashed potatoes.

    Mar 17, 2023

    If you don?t have the pie I want please don?t replace it. Please refund instead.

    Mar 11, 2023

    Everything was outstanding as always !

    Mar 10, 2023

    The food was good. My burger was rare, which I didn't request, so if you don't want your burger rare, you should specify. It was a lot of food. We ordered two cheeseburgers (one with vegetarian patties) and fries for two people for dinner and we ate the rest for lunch the next day.

    Mar 8, 2023

    Excellent, as always !

    Feb 22, 2023

    The staff & management at this restaurant always provide delicious food--although Monty's Blue Plate Diner has been in operation _forever_, they consistently provide outstandingly favorable dishes year after year !

    Feb 20, 2023

    The food I received was good. An item was missing however.

    Dec 21, 2022

    Excellent once again.

Back to Menu

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to enhance your experience on our site. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy