Wooden Nickel Sports Bar & Grill Menu & Delivery Appleton WI 54911 | EatStreet.com
Wooden Nickel Sports Bar & Grill Menu and Delivery in Appleton WI, 54911

Wooden Nickel Sports Bar & Grill

Burgers, Subs & Sandwiches
112 ratings

Back to Menu

Reviews for Wooden Nickel Sports Bar & Grill
112 ratings
    Jun 4, 2026

    My mini corn dogs were burnt. Everything else was fine

    Jan 1, 2025

    Amazing

    Mar 18, 2024

    My mozzarella sticks were harder than a rock, and all of it was lukewarm. Not happy at all.

    Nov 24, 2023

    The food is good, but their prices are a joke. Love the burger but $12 for a burger that you have to pay additionally for cheese, tomato & lettuce?! Crazy. Fries not even included either. The lettuce was not even a full leaf, and I asked for ketchup mustard and mayo and didn't get a single one on my burger. Guess you have to pay for that too. My appetizer meal I had to pay extra for the sauce too, guess what, didn't get the one I paid for. That was cool.

    Nov 14, 2023

    Burger came plain and was missing all the toppings

    Sep 10, 2023

    Chippers were cold and soggy. Normally very good but the ball was dropped

    Jul 25, 2023

    Normally the food is great. It seemed like it had been sitting there for awhile.

    May 28, 2023

    The food was too soggy to eat. Ended up throwing it away, it was terrible.

    May 20, 2023

    Item was missing and one item wasn?t right

    Apr 24, 2023

    The food was not cooked well, and some stuff was burnt, the delivery driver was rude and I dis not appreciate how he acted.

    Apr 17, 2023

    Burgers where undercooked fries and onion rings where overcooked wasn?t happy

    Apr 2, 2023

    Food is usually good, it was cool this time.

    Jan 11, 2023

    We have ordered many times over several years, and have yet to have our order be made correctly more than once. It is always missing items or has incorrect substitutes. This last time was the final straw, completely wrong meal was given, and when called insisted that it was correct. Drove there to get the correct food and they gave food that was so burnt it was nearly inedible.

    Dec 19, 2022

    Burger way under cooked. Waffle fries, way over cooked

    Sep 30, 2022

    Very disappointed in our last order. Normally one of the best burgers in town, but this time all of our food was EXTREMELY overdone. The burgers were obviously burnt but they sent them out anyway. Normally I would ignore it and chock it up to a fluke, but there is no way that anyone could have looked at those burnt patties and thought they were alright to serve....they must have literally been on fire! Very disappointed. Anyone can make a mistake and burn something, but admit the mistake and make some new burgers for the order.

    Aug 23, 2022

    Missing items

    Mar 14, 2022

    I ordered 5 minutes before they closed, and they accepted the order and made sure to rush it to me. Everything was delightful! I so appreciate their helpfulness. Will be ordering again, when able.

    Mar 9, 2022

    I liked the hot wings but didn?t care for the jumbo mozzarella sticks. It was an egg roll wrap instead of breaded.

    Feb 6, 2022

    Food was ok nothing special Burger was not that good

    Nov 30, 2021

    Food was over an hour late

    Nov 29, 2021

    Food showed up cold and did not eat it.

    Nov 1, 2021

    half of our food was missing from our order with no explanation. giving two stars instead of one because the food we did receive tasted good.

    Oct 17, 2021

    very cold food

    Oct 17, 2021

    Awesome food and good prices!

    Aug 12, 2021

    food was good, did not get fries with the order. and got a shitty credit instead of a refund. if i receive another credit to my account instead of receiving money back into my hands i will not use this app again

    Apr 25, 2021

    Once we got the food, it was ok. Cold fries. Didn?t get an entires meal!

    Feb 1, 2021

    chicken wings were raw on the inside

    Jan 19, 2021

    Food was piping hot and excellent as always! Chips were crispy and the burger was perfectly done

    Jan 9, 2021

    Food was cold when I got it and 30 min later than originally promised. Also, the restaurant listed said there was no delivery charge and I was charged one.

    Jan 2, 2021

    The steak sandwich was excellent. It was very tender. Everything was delivered hot and fresh b

    Dec 14, 2020

    Excellent food

    Nov 30, 2020

    Great food, very underrated.

    Nov 25, 2020

    Great food very reasonable

    Oct 21, 2020

    Hamburgers were hard, delivery time kept changing.

    Oct 19, 2020

    The wings and chips I ordered were tasty and made on-time. Pretty good deal at $11

    Oct 12, 2020

    Everything we ordered was great but the steak sandwich was a very small steak for the price.

    Sep 29, 2020

    The food was not good. No flavor, fries had no seasoning. I?m going

    Aug 31, 2020

    We only got about half the cheese curds I would expect for the $8 price.

    Jul 12, 2020

    Asked for buffalo on the side, my chicken wrap was drenched in it. Also asked for ranch which didn?t happen. Took an hour to deliver when I live 5 minutes away.

    Jun 30, 2020

    Sandwich was awesome as usual, but the mozzarella sticks are gross to me, especially for $9

    May 9, 2020

    Lukewarm at best. Disappointed with the ?cheap? buns. $34.00 for 2 fish sandwiches was way overpriced. $3.50 EXTRA for 5 onion rings and some ?pieces. ?

    Jan 18, 2020

    I have eaten at Wooden Nickle before. Their food is top notch. When I got my food it was cold. For a seven dollar delivery charge the food should not be cold. what else can I say. I may use you again but not for a burger and fries.

    Jan 4, 2020

    Not great. Way to expensive.

    Dec 1, 2019

    Missing the fries

    Oct 27, 2019

    My experience with ordering from the delivery service was wonderful! Food order was delivered on time and I had mentioned it was my daughter's Birthday. The delivery person wished her a Happy Birthday, so thoughtful. The food was delicious and they were so happy with the surprise meal. I would highly recommend this place to anyone.

    Sep 24, 2019

    The Wooden Nickel Has Very GOOD Food And Would Definitely Order From Them Again!

    Jul 24, 2019

    Very good burgers!!

    Jul 21, 2019

    Always awsome.

    Jul 16, 2019

    The burgers we ordered were rarer than rare, raw. Had to remove and cook. Not acceptable.

    Jul 4, 2019

    Burgers were overcooked, sides were cold

Back to Menu

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to enhance your experience on our site. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy