- Popular Items
- Build Your Own PizzaChoice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$11.30+
- Cheesebread - Large (16 Inch)No ordinary cheese bread here. This is our homemade pizza dough hand tossed and topped with garlic butter and house-blend cheese then baked to perfection and served with a side of marinara sauce.$22.55
- Fried Mac & Cheese BitesEverybody's favorite! Creamy, cheesy macaroni and cheese dipped into a rich batter and then fried till crispy. Served with a side of ketchup. Oh my.$10.15
- Nickel NuggetsWe start with our pizza dough, cut it into bite size pieces, deep fry it and pile on parmesan cheese and garlic. Served with a side of our chunky marinara.$7.90
- Toasted Cheese RavioliHere's to cheese! Seasoned ricotta and parmesan cheese ravioli pasta, breaded with Italian spiced bread crumbs and delightfully fried until golden brown. Served with a side of marinara sauce.$9.00
- Appetizers
- Delicious starters to prime the pump!
- Cheesebread - Large (16 Inch)No ordinary cheese bread here. This is our homemade pizza dough hand tossed and topped with garlic butter and house-blend cheese then baked to perfection and served with a side of marinara sauce.$22.55
- Cheese CurdsAh Wisconsin! Squeaky fresh white cheddar cheese curds battered and fried to a golden brown pop-and-eat happy treat.$10.15
- ChipsDeep river brand. Call for selection.$2.00
- ColeslawMade fresh in house.$1.45
- Cream Cheese Jalapeno PoppersA one-two punch. Rich cream cheese tucked into a jalapeno pepper shell then breaded and fried to a golden brown. Served with your choice of ranch or marinara. Add a side of sour cream for just $0.95 more.$10.15
- Fried Mac & Cheese BitesEverybody's favorite! Creamy, cheesy macaroni and cheese dipped into a rich batter and then fried till crispy. Served with a side of ketchup. Oh my.$10.15
- Fried Mushrooms$7.90
- Garlic Toast$3.40
- Garlic Breadsticks$7.90
- Spinach Cheesebread (GF) (Small, 10 Inch)$13.30
- Cheesebread (GF) (Small, 10 Inch)$13.30
- French FriesFries, fries we all cry for fries! 3/8" cut russet potato strips fried golden and served piping hot. Choice of small or large.$3.40+
- TotsChoice of small or large.$4.25+
- Mozzarella SticksA classic combination. Sliced sticks of mozzarella cheese battered and deep fried. Served with a side of marinara sauce.$9.00
- Nickel NuggetsWe start with our pizza dough, cut it into bite size pieces, deep fry it and pile on parmesan cheese and garlic. Served with a side of our chunky marinara.$7.90
- Onion Rings$6.75
- Side SaladHouse mix lettuce with carrots, cucumber, tomatoes and red cabbage. Served with the dressing of your choice and garlic croutons.$6.50
- Toasted Cheese RavioliHere's to cheese! Seasoned ricotta and parmesan cheese ravioli pasta, breaded with Italian spiced bread crumbs and delightfully fried until golden brown. Served with a side of marinara sauce.$9.00
- Build Your Own Salad
- All salads come with croutons and your choice of dressing. Made fresh when you order! Small serves 1-2 people. Large serves 2-3.
- Build Your Own SaladYour choice of greens plus 4 toppings. All salads come with croutons and your choice of dressing! Choice of Small or Large.$7.85+
- Salads
- All salads come with croutons and your choice of dressing. Made fresh when you order! Small serves 1-2 people. Large serves 2-3.
- Acropolis SaladRomaine lettuce joined by ripe black olives, diced red onions, fresh red ripe tomatoes and sweet red bell peppers topped with crumbled feta cheese. Served with your choice of dressing (we recommend our greek dressing) and garlic croutons. Choice of small or large.$7.85+
- Bac-N- Blue Salad$9.00+
- Caesar SaladA classic mix of our fresh, crispy and delicious romaine lettuce topped with a heaping portion of fresh shredded parmesan cheese. Your choice of chicken or anchovies. Served with the dressing of your choice and garlic croutons. Choice of small or large.$7.85+
- Chef SaladAn all around favorite anyway we toss it. We start with our fresh and crispy house-mix lettuce blend, then pile on the toppings: ham and turkey, crumbled bacon, sliced hard boiled egg, shredded carrots and diced tomatoes, topped off with some of wisconsin's finest, crumbled cheddar cheese. Served with your choice of dressings and garlic croutons. Choice of small or large.$11.25+
- Club SaladA classic, perhaps delicious, fresh house-mix lettuce topped with crumbled bacon, boar's head oven gold turkey, diced fresh tomatoes and Wisconsin cheddar cheese. Served with garlic croutons and your choice of dressing. Choice of small or large.$11.25+
- Cobb SaladAn ode to Robert Howard cobb. Fresh romaine lettuce, tender chicken, crispy bacon, hard-boiled eggs, cheddar, tomatoes and avocados. Served with the dressing of your choice and garlic croutons. Choice of small or large.$11.25+
- Garden SaladWe start with our always fresh and crispy house-mix lettuces, then we add shredded carrot, diced green peppers, fresh tomatoes, red cabbage, diced red onions and sliced cucumbers. Top it off with any dressing of your choice and garlic croutons. Choice of small or large.$7.85+
- Popeye SaladChoice of small or large.$7.85+
- B.Y.O. Salad (Small)$5.15+
- Build Your Own Sub
- Make It hot or cold.
- Build Your Own Sub$10.15
- Build Your Own Veggie$10.15
- Build Your Own Vegan$10.15
- Hot or Cold Subs
- BLT SubThe omg BLT with crispy bacon, farm fresh tomatoes and cool, crisp lettuce. Served with a side of mayonnaise.$10.15
- Bomber SubHave to say it...Bombs away with our homemade meatballs, zesty marinara, mozzarella & parmesan cheese on your choice of bread.$10.15
- Carolina Club SubNothing could be finer then sliced chicken breast, swiss cheese, crispy bacon strips and sliced tomato, toasted on a hoagie roll and served with sides of cole slaw and thousand island dressing.$11.25
- Chef's Club SubThe chef has spoken with tender turkey and sweet sliced ham along with Wisconsin cheddar, provolone and swiss cheeses, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayo and French dressing.$11.25
- Chicken Cordon Bleu SubHits the spot with crispy chicken tenders, boar's head sweet slice ham, swiss cheese and a side of honey mustard dressing.$11.25
- Chicken Parmesan SubA crispy delight with three fried chicken tenders, marinara, mozzarella and shredded parmesan cheese.$10.15
- Hot Wing HoagieWith zip and zest we bring you crispy chicken tenders, cheddar cheese and frank's hot buffalo sauce with the right touch of lettuce.$10.15
- Italian SubHot or cold, you choose! Mangia! Mangia! Ham, genoa salami, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato and a side each of Italian dressing and mayonnaise. Viva Italia!$10.15
- Pepperoni Pile-On SubHang on because this one keeps coming. Made with generous amounts of pepperoni, mozzarella, spicy banana peppers and marinara. We told you so.$10.15
- Santa Fe SubGrab a handful of the southwest with sliced chicken, BBQ sauce, red peppers, red onions, spicy jalapenos and cheddar cheese.$10.15
- Shrimp Po'Boy SubThe big easy decision. Enjoy beer battered shrimp, lettuce and tomatoes on a delicious hoagie roll. Served with Cajun remoulade sauce. Done and done.$10.15
- Smothered Chicken SubThis is one decked out sub with chicken, leafy spinach, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes with mozzarella and a side of mayonnaise.$10.15
- Cod SubBeer battered fish fillets, cheddar, lettuce, tomatoes, and tartar sauce.$10.95
- Turkey Club SubGet your gobble on with tender turkey breast, cheddar cheese, crispy bacon, lettuce and tomato. Served with a side of mayo. Order it hot or cold.$12.40
- Veggie SubA garden in the sun with broccoli, red peppers, black olives and fresh mushrooms blossoming with marinara and mozzarella cheese.$10.15
- Build Your Own Pizza
- Our cooks can make just about anything...just ask! (Unless requested other, we start each pizza fresh with hand-tossed dough, classic sauce and special blend cheese). We also offer Par-Baked Pizzas!
- Build Your Own PizzaChoice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$11.30+
- Specialty Pizzas
- Bacon Cheeseburger PizzaNo bun, but you still use your hands. Homemade classic marinara sauce, topped with fresh ground beef, bacon, yellow onions and our house blend & cheddar cheeses. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Boaris Karloff PizzaThree boar's head brand meats: genoa salami, pepperoni, capicola ham, with banana peppers, tomatoes, five blend cheese, herbs and spices on a base of garlic and olive oil. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Border to Border Pizza - Small (10")Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40
- Buffalo Nickel Ranch Pizza - Small (10")The buffalo nickel features buffalo chicken tenders (tossed in frank's red hot sauce, fresh garlic and cilantro) on ranch dressing with celery, cheddar and house-blend cheese, topped with a drizzle of frank's red hot on hand-tossed crust. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40
- Buffalo Nickel PizzaThe buffalo nickel features buffalo chicken tenders (tossed in frank's red hot sauce, fresh garlic and cilantro) on ranch dressing with celery, cheddar and house-blend cheese, topped with a drizzle of frank's red hot on hand-tossed crust. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$24.30+
- Cardiac Arrest PizzaMmm, mmm it's mighty meaty! Pepperoni, crispy crumbled bacon, ham, sausage and extra house blend cheese atop our classic Italian sauce. A full allowance of deliciousness. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Cheeseasaurus Pizza - Small (10")Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40
- Chicken Alfredo PizzaDeeelish without the dish. Creamy alfredo sauce with our house blend cheese topped with marinated diced chicken, Wisconsin mushrooms, fresh garlic and .spinach Ciao and chow! Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Chicken Cordon Bleu PizzaWe start with our honey mustard sauce and house blend cheese, then we add diced ham, sliced fried chicken tenders and slices of melted Wisconsin swiss cheese. Indeed, a unique treat! Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Chicky Chicky Parm Parm PizzaYummy yummy fun fun! Creamy alfredo sauce, house blend cheese, chicken strips, basil and garlic topped with classic sauce, oregano and parmesan cheese. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Deluxe PizzaA traditional favorite everyone loves! Classic Italian pizza sauce topped with pepperoni, fresh sliced mushrooms, yellow onions, green bell peppers and zesty Italian sausage with house blend cheese. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Fetalicious PizzaMeet our top seller! Chunky marinara sauce topped with fresh spinach leaves, diced red onions, ripe tomatoes, sliced mushrooms and our house blend & feta cheeses. The 'za that started it all! Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Hawaii Pie-O PizzaClassic sauce, Canadian bacon, pineapple chunks, yellow onions, red peppers & banana peppers with crispy bacon and house blend cheese. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Mac Daddy PizzaAlfredo sauce, cavatappi noodles, house blend and cheddar cheeses, on a hand tossed crust with a crispy herb & cheese topping. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Margherita PizzaSimply scrumptious. Creamy ricotta sauce topped with fresh diced tomatoes, fresh basil leaves, minced garlic and house blend cheese. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Mediterranean PizzaZesty pesto sauce topped with house blend cheese, fresh diced tomatoes, ripe black olives and crumbled feta cheese. Dive into this fav. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Nacho Mama PizzaChoice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Pollo Diablo PizzaOh, we're bringin' the heat with this one. Tempting you with spicy ranch sriracha sauce, tender chicken, crispy bacon and red onions, then topping it off with house blend cheese and jalape?os to get you all fired up! Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Portabella Lugosi PizzaClassic marinara, portabella mushrooms, sausage, onions, basil, toasted garlic and mozzarella topped with our cheese & herb shake. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Santa Fe PizzaWe're talking KC masterpiece BBQ sauce topped with house blend cheese, diced red onions, marinated chicken, red bell peppers and fresh cilantro. Grab a slice of the southwest, partner. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Thai Pie PizzaThe terrific south pacific! Thai peanut sauce topped with our house blend cheese, cilantro, broccoli florets, yellow onions, sweet red bell peppers and diced chicken breast. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- The Ranch PizzaAn employee favorite! We start it off with buttermilk ranch dressing and add our house blend cheese, red onions, fresh diced tomatoes, crumbled bacon and diced chicken. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Veggie-Out PizzaOh, your momma will be proud! Our classic Italian sauce topped with house blend cheese, broccoli florets, fresh diced tomatoes, Wisconsin mushrooms, red onions, green bell peppers and ripe black olives. Choice of small (10 inch), medium (14 inch), or large (16 inch).$16.40+
- Pocket Pizzas
- CalzoneA generously portioned pocket pizza, but, well, for your mouth. Filled with your choice of any two toppings, folded into a 10" pizza crust with our homemade ricotta sauce and house blend cheese. Brushed with garlic butter and baked fresh in our ovens. Served with a side of our chunky marinara.$13.00
- StromboliA bit like a calzone, but not since we fill this delicious pocket pizza with classic Italian sauce, then add house blend cheese and your choice of two toppings. Comes with side of chunky marinara.$13.00
- Chicken & Wings
- Chicken Strips with FriesYou know you love'em, we do too! 6 delicious crispy chicken tenders perfectly fried to a golden brown and served with our thick-cut french fries and your choice of dipping sauce. Choice of 6 strips or 4 strips.$11.30+
- WingsChoice of 6 wings or 12 wings.$10.75+
- Fish & Shrimp
- Fish BasketChoice of 2 pieces or 3 pieces.$15.80+
- Shrimp BasketNothing shrimpy about this basket with 12 pieces of golden brown battered and fried shrimp, served with french fries, coleslaw and remoulade sauce.$16.90
- Pasta
- All pasta dishes are served with garlic bread. (add broccoli, mushrooms, fresh garlic for an additional price or meatballs, chicken, artichoke hearts, spinach, red peppers for an additional price).
- Mix & Match PastaServed with garlic toast. Choose your favorite noodles: cavatappi, spaghetti, fettuccine or ravioli (cheese). Then choose your sauce: marinara (classic meatless tomato sauce), meat sauce (ground beef & Italian sausage in tomato sauce), alfredo (cream, butter & parmesan) or pesto (basil, garlic, parmesan & olive oil).$11.25
- Cheese RavioliCheese ravioli with pesto sauce.$11.25
- Chicken AlfredoA house favorite! Creamy alfredo sauce and oven roasted chicken on a bed of fettuccine. Served with toasted garlic bread. Enjoy this classic.$14.15
- Mac & CheeseCavatappi noodles, creamy alfredo sauce, Monterey jack & sharp cheddar cheese, salt & pepper.$14.15
- Meat LasagnaLayers of noodles, ricotta, mozzarella, tomato sauce, mushrooms, tomatoes, yellow onions, ground beef, and Italian sausage. Served with garlic bread.$14.15
- Mediterranean Lasagna$14.15
- Pasta With Sauce$11.25
- Dressings, Sauces, and Sides
- 1000 Island Dressing$1.45
- Alfredo Sauce$3.40
- Balsamic Vinaigrette Dressing$1.45
- BBQ Sauce$2.00
- Bleu Cheese Dressing$1.45
- Caesar Dressing$1.45
- Fat Free French Dressing$1.45
- Fat Free Ranch Dressing$1.45
- French Dressing$1.45
- Garlic Butter$1.45
- Greek Dressing$1.45
- Horseradish$1.45
- Icing (2 Pkg)$3.15
- Italian Dressing$1.45
- Ketchup$1.45
- Marinara Sauce$1.45
- Mayo$2.00
- Mild Buffalo Sauce$2.00
- Nacho Cheese$2.00
- Parmesan Cheese$0.15
- Parmesan Peppercorn$1.45
- Pesto Sauce$5.10
- Ranch Dressing$1.45
- Red Pepper Flake$0.60
- Remoulade$3.40
- Side Jalapeno$1.70
- Side Pineapple$1.70
- Sour Cream$1.45
- Spicy Classic$1.45
- Sriracha$1.45
- Thai Peanut Sauce$2.00
- Desserts
- Cannoli CakeA unique take on the traditional Italian dessert. This incredibly moist cake features creamy ricotta filling with chocolate chips in between three towering layers of yellow cake. All topped by a smooth mascarpone whipped cream frosting and garnished with crushed pistachio for the full cannoli experience. Mangiamo!$9.65
- Cinna NuggsLet's start with dessert. Fresh, homemade cinnamon donut holes, served with vanilla icing.$7.85
- New York 5th Cheesecake$9.65
- Turtle CheesecakeA slice of creamy, sweet cheesecake. Ask about our current selection.$9.65
- Chocolate Chip Cookie$3.10
- Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream$9.65
Reviews for Glass Nickel Pizza - Menasha
No reviews yet.
Back to Menu
- Home
- Appleton, WI
- All Appleton Restaurants
- Glass Nickel Pizza - Menasha
