Skip to main content
EatStreet Logo
  • profile
    Sign In
  • cart
    Cart
We've updated our Terms of Use. Please refer to EatStreet.com for details.
Back to Restaurant Search
Nicky's Pizza Menu and Delivery in Sheboygan WI, 53081
  • Nicky's Pizza

  • Pizza
  • 1735 Calumet Dr Sheboygan WI, 53081
    - 254 ratings
  • Hours 11:00am - 10:00pm
  • ETA 60 - 75 min
  • Delivery Minimum $8.00
  • Delivery Cost FREE Delivery

Popular Items

Cheese Pie
$6.84+
The Sheboygan Pie #1 Best Seller! Sausage, pepperoni, covered with extra mozzarella cheese.
$8.24+
Garlic Cheese Bread Choice of marinara or ranch.
$4.25
Classic Gyro Sliced gyro meat, tomatoes, onions, on a pita with tzatziki sauce.
$7.49
Mini Tacos (10) Choice of Salsa or sour cream.
$4.75

No Silverware

No Silverware Required Add this item to your cart and the restaurant will exclude silverware with your order.
Add +

Appetizers

Garlic Bread Choice of marinara or ranch.
$3.25
Garlic Cheese Bread Choice of marinara or ranch.
$4.25
Mozzarella Sticks (6) Choice of marinara or ranch.
$4.75
Broasted Potatoes (4)
$2.25
Chicken Tenders (5) Choice of ranch, honey mustard or BBQ.
$5.49
Onion Rings (8)
$4.49
Mini Tacos (10) Choice of Salsa or sour cream.
$4.75
Fries
$2.25
Jalapeno Poppers (6) Choice of marinara or ranch.
$4.75
Breaded Cauliflower (Spicy) spicyChoice of marinara or ranch.
$4.99
Nachos Nacho cheese, onions, black olives, tomatoes, jalapenos. Add ground beef for extra.
$7.49
Loaded Fries Nacho cheese, bacon, raw onion, sour cream, salsa.
$7.49
Greek Fries Gyro meat, tomatoes, onions, feta cheese, drizzled with tzatziki sauce.
$7.49

Salads

Dressings: housemade caesar, housemade ranch, bleu cheese, french, thousand Island, oil & vinegar, honey mustard or Italian.

Chicken Caesar Salad Grilled chicken, croutons on a bed of lettuce tossed in a housemade caesar dressing.
$8.99
Chef Salad Ham, turkey, lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, mozzarella, cheddar.
$8.99
Greek Salad Kalamata olives, pepperoncinis, feta, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, green peppers. Add gyro meat or grilled chicken for extra.
$7.99
House Salad Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, green peppers, shredded carrots, croutons, mozzarella. Add gyro meat or grilled chicken for extra.
$4.99
Side Salad Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, green peppers.
$2.99

Wings & Things

Mango habanero, buffalo, spicy BBQ, hot garlic, Thai peanut, caribbean jerk, BBQ, teriyaki, Kentucky bourbon, garlic parmesan.

Boneless Wings (Plain with Sauce on Side)
$7.50+
Boneless Wings (Sauce Tossed)
$11.99+

Broasted Chicken Dinners

Includes broasted potatoes, coleslaw and garlic bread.

Broasted Chicken Dinners
$8.00+

Pasta Dinners

Includes side salad and garlic bread.

Spaghetti al Limone Creamy lemon mushroom sauce with grilled chicken over spaghetti.
$11.99
Italian Rigatoni A pink sauce with crushed red pepper, garlic and Italian sausage over penne noodles.
$10.49
Misto Alfredo Alfredo sauce with grilled chicken, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes and parmesan over spaghetti.
$10.99
Spaghetti, Baked or Stovetop With a slow-simmered marinara, this spaghetti is far from basic. Add meatballs or meat sauce for extras.
$8.99
Classic Lasagna
$10.24

Subs & Gyros

Includes potato chips. Substitute fries or a side salad for extra.

Turkey Sub Housemade french bread, mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayonnaise.
$6.99
Ham Sub Housemade french bread, mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayonnaise.
$6.99
Combo (Ham & Turkey) Sub Housemade french bread, mozzarella, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, mayonnaise.
$7.99
Classic Gyro Sliced gyro meat, tomatoes, onions, on a pita with tzatziki sauce.
$7.49
Chicken Gyro Grilled chicken, tomatoes, onions, on a pita with tzatziki sauce.
$8.49

Make Your Own Pie

Cheese Pie
$6.84+

Local Favorites

The Sheboygan Pie #1 Best Seller! Sausage, pepperoni, covered with extra mozzarella cheese.
$8.24+
The Milwaukee Pie The classic started it all! Sausage, mushrooms, onions, mozzarella.
$8.24+
BLT Pie Bacon, mozzarella, topped with mayonnaise, lettuce, tomatoes.
$8.24+
Skinny Chicago Pie Red pepper-infused olive oil, marinara sauce, mozzarella, sausage, tomatoes, garlic, basil.
$8.24+

Artisanal Pies

The Artichoke Pie Pesto, mozzarella, parmesan, artichokes, spinach, sun-dried tomatoes.
$8.99+
Holy Moly Mushroom Pie Olive oil, mozzarella, and havarti, shiitake and portobello mushrooms roasted in sherry and garlic, thyme and rosemary, drizzled with white truffle oil.
$8.99+
Bianco Pie Garlic aoil, mozzarella, parmesan, feta, havarti, basil.
$8.99+
Spinaci Pie Ricotta, mozzarella, spinach, feta, garlic oil.
$8.99+

5-Pound Pies

Deluxe Pie Sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives, mozzarella.
$9.29+
Meat Market Pie Sausage, pepperoni, beef, bacon, smoked ham, Canadian bacon, mozzarella.
$9.29+
Taco Pie Picante sauce, seasoned ground beef, cheddar, mozzarella, topped with sour cream, lettuce, tomatoes, taco chips.
$9.29+
Happy Farmer Pie Garlic, tomatoes, green peppers, black olives, green olives, onions, artichokes, mushrooms, mozzarella.
$9.29+

Calzones & Strombolis

The Godfather Calzone Meatballs, onions, provolone, ricotta, mozzarella.
$9.49
The Godfather Stromboli Meatballs, onions, provolone, ricotta, mozzarella.
$9.49
Hot Italian Calzone Turkey, smoked ham, pepperoni, pepperoncinis, provolone, mozzarella.
$9.49
Hot Italian Stromboli Turkey, smoked ham, pepperoni, pepperoncinis, provolone, mozzarella.
$9.49
Philly Cheesesteak Calzone Steak, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, garlic, provolone, mozzarella.
$9.49
Philly Cheesesteak Stromboli Steak, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, garlic, provolone, mozzarella.
$9.49
The Homerun Calzone Pepperoni, ground beef, mozzarella, cheddar, onions.
$9.49
The Homerun Stromboli Pepperoni, ground beef, mozzarella, cheddar, onions.
$9.49
Make Your Own Calzone With mozzarella, add your favorite toppings for additional extra.
$7.49
Make Your Own Stromboli With mozzarella, add your favorite toppings for additional extra.
$7.49

Beverages

2 Liter Bottle Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt. Dew.
$2.69
20-Ounce Bottles Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt. Dew, Sierra Mist, Rootbeer, Lemonade.
$1.89
12 oz. Cans Coke, Diet Coke, Diet Mt. Dew. Brisk Tea.
$1.25

Back to Menu

Reviews for Nicky's Pizza

1-15 of 60 Reviews
1 to 15 of 60 Reviews
  • check Sort By: Most Recent
  • Sort By: Most Helpful
  • Sort By: Oldest
  • Sort By: Highest Rated
  • Sort By: Lowest Rated
  • (68)
  • (19)
  • (24)
  • (14)
  • (23)
Rated 3 out of 5
Jul 6, 2021
Elizabeth B
Food was ok... But took almost 2 hours to get. Promise time was for 45 min then jumped another hour from that time.
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 3 out of 5
Jun 28, 2021
Lee J S
Recently ordered a pizza with Peperoni, Mushrooms, and Black Olives with Garlic Bread. The Garlic Bread was overcooked and most was rock hard by the time it arrived and the pizza had Peperoni, Mushrooms, and Sausage on it. While I understand there can be problems, a pizza place should be able to get the correct toppings on a pizza.
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 1 out of 5
May 31, 2021
Tony F
Don't accept orders you can't deliver.
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 5 out of 5
May 24, 2021
Justin L
Pizza was good as always. Pasta was really good too. Can't complain at all.
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 5 out of 5
May 15, 2021
Joy A
The food was hot and great!
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 5 out of 5
Apr 17, 2021
Debbie B
Nicky's pizza is always good. Delivered hot out of the oven. Taco and Sheboygan pies are both delicious! Love the thin crust!
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 1 out of 5
Apr 11, 2021
Jon H
Garlic bread wasa very good, The Lasagna dinner was terrible, basically a frozen dinner....
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 4 out of 5
Mar 22, 2021
jelencml@att.net j
Great!
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 1 out of 5
Mar 2, 2021
Brianna R
It has been many years since I have had Nicky's. We ordered a BLT, and taco pizza. The pizzas came with soggy, dripping toppings, lettuce pieces larger than you would eat in a salad, and they added on tomatoes when there was a substitute ordered. The only good part about the order, was that they were out of the crust my fiance wanted, so the soggy BLT
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 3 out of 5
Feb 17, 2021
Chuck W
Not the best we?ve had from Nicky?s
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 5 out of 5
Feb 7, 2021
Dylan B
Best pizza place in Sheboygan. Hands down.
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 4 out of 5
Feb 6, 2021
Kayla S
Chicken skin did taste a little bit like old oil. But that could also just be me.
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 5 out of 5
Feb 3, 2021
Kerry M
Picked up my food at the time it was to be done and it was ready and hot! Food was of good quality and portions were very good! Very pleased and will return and tell friends as well!
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 5 out of 5
Jan 31, 2021
Jake P
10/10 quick service, delicious food
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate
Rated 3 out of 5
Jan 30, 2021
Trista J
Food was 20 minutes late and cheese curds were cold.
Was this helpful?
Report as Inappropriate

Back to Menu

Share your menu feedback with us: menus@eatstreet.com
All Pizza delivery & takeout options in Sheboygan
  1. Home
  2. Sheboygan, WI
  3. All Sheboygan Restaurants
  4. Nicky's Pizza

Your Order

Start Group Order
Nicky's Pizza
Proceed to Checkout $0.00
Empty Cart Illustration

Famished? Fill me up!

EatStreet
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
  • Blog
  • Become a Driver!
Support
  • For Customers
  • Accessibility Statement
  • Restaurant Dashboard
  • API
  • Get EatStreet
  • Get Help
Legal
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • California Privacy Notice
  • Restaurant Terms
Get the App
? 2021 EatStreet
Live Chat