New York Pizza - Hayward Menu & Takeout Hayward CA 95361 | EatStreet.com
New York Pizza - Hayward Menu and Takeout in Hayward CA, 95361

New York Pizza - Hayward

Pizza, Lunch
103 ratings

Back to Menu

Reviews for New York Pizza - Hayward
103 ratings
    Jun 21, 2023

    When I lived in Hayward years ago I would always order New York Pizza on A Street. Now I am back in Hayward and, of course, ordered a pizza from New York Pizza. I was so disappointed. New York Pizza used to be the best from any other pizzas ever. But the one I got last night was a big disappointment. There was no flavor to it except for a mound of cheese. I assumed I would eat at least half of it and have the rest for left overs. I was hungry so ate 2 pieces. Today, I threw the rest away. Sad to say, a couple of weeks ago I was at a friend's house and they ordered a pizza from Domino's. Wasn't that great but I'll be honest with you, it was better than New York Pizza. Could be a fluke, maybe a different preparer but I don't think I want to spend another $35.00 for a pizza such as that one. I am so sorry. I don't usually leave bad reviews but this one was a big surprising let down. Delivery person was on time and very friendly.

    Jul 18, 2022

    The pizza was great

    Apr 4, 2021

    Love this Place, Great quality pizza for an even better price ??

    Nov 10, 2019

    The New York pizza on A st has made great recipes that I constantly enjoy, the Chicken tiki pizza was lackluster. The tiki seasoning was barely noticeable (I have a decent pallet) and the cilantro was the only saving grace.

    Aug 31, 2018

    The largest pizza was on the bottom of a pile with 3 pizzas on top. Half the pizza was ruined because the toppings stuck to the top! I'd like a credit or refund from the restaurant.

    Jun 19, 2018

    I ordered the pesto chicken pizza with pepperoni on half. It was delicious!

Back to Menu

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to enhance your experience on our site. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy