- Popular Items
- Single 1/2 lb. BurgerOn a hard roll.$8.99
- Johnny Prince?s Famous Hot Dog - Plain$3.50
- 2 Egg and Meat Breakfast PlatterServed with home fries and toast.$9.99
- Home Fries - Small$4.25
- French Toast Short Stack (2 Pieces)$5.99
- Breakfast Platters
- Served with home fries and toast.
- 2 Egg Breakfast PlatterServed with home fries and toast.$5.99
- 2 Egg and Meat Breakfast PlatterServed with home fries and toast.$9.99
- Egg White Breakfast PlatterServed with home fries and toast.$6.99
- Egg White and Meat Breakfast PlatterServed with home fries and toast.$8.99
- Breakfast SamplerTwo pancakes or French toast, two eggs any style, home fries and Taylor ham, bacon and sausage. Served with home fries and toast.$13.99
- Fish and Grits BreakfastServed with home fries and toast.$8.99+
- Fish and Grits with 2 Eggs Any StyleServed with home fries and toast.$16.99
- From the Griddle
- Pancakes$2.99+
- Short Stack Pancakes (2 Pieces)$5.99
- Chocolate Chip$6.99+
- French Toast with Meat$9.99
- Pancakes with Meat$9.99
- French Toast with Meat and 2 EggsAny style of egg$11.99
- Pancake with Meat and 2 EggsAny style of egg$11.99
- French Toast$2.99+
- French Toast Short Stack (2 Pieces)$5.99
- Omelettes
- Served with home fries and toast.
- Cheese Omelet$7.99
- Mexican Omelet$8.99
- 3 Meat OmeletteTaylor ham, bacon, & sausage.$11.99
- Western OmelettePeppers, onions, & ham.$9.99
- Garden OmelettePeppers, onions, mushrooms, tomatoes, & cheddar cheese.$8.99
- Healthy Veggie OmeletteBroccoli, spinach, mushrooms, tomato, & onion.$8.99
- Spinach Omelet$8.99
- Egg White Omelet$8.99
- Egg Omelet$6.99
- Meat Omelet$9.99
- Breakfast Sandwiches
- Made with 2 xl eggs on white, wheat, rye or kaiser roll. Bagel, croissant, english muffin or wrap for additional cost.
- Egg Breakfast Sandwich$3.75
- Egg and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich$4.25
- Potato and Egg Breakfast Sandwich$5.00
- Pepper and Egg Breakfast Sandwich$4.99
- Italian Sausage & Egg Breakfast Sandwich$8.99
- Meat and Egg Breakfast Sandwich$7.25+
- Meat and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich$8.00+
- Meat, 2 Eggs and Cheese Breakfast Sandwich$7.75+
- Steak and Eggs Breakfast Sandwich$8.50+
- Johnny Belly Buster Breakfast Sandwich3 eggs, ham, sausage, pork roll, bacon, & hash brown stuffed into 8" sub roll.$9.99
- Johnny Belly Buster with Cheese Breakfast Sandwich3 eggs, ham, sausage, pork roll, bacon, & hash brown stuffed into 8" sub roll.$10.99
- Our Fresh Homemade Soups
- Fresh Homemade Soup$3.99+
- Fresh Salads
- Greek SaladKalamata olives, feta, stuffed grape leaves & anchovies.$10.99+
- Santa Fe SaladFresh crispy romaine, blackened grilled chicken, diced tomato, red onions, black beans, corn & tri colored tortilla strips, comes with chipotle ranch dressing on the side$12.99+
- Santa Fe Salad with Shrimp$13.99+
- Garden SaladFresh iceberg lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers and your choice of dressing.$7.99+
- Caesar SaladFresh romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, croutons & caesar dressing.$8.99+
- Chef SaladFresh iceberg lettuce, tomato, onions, cucumbers & hard-boiled egg, covered w/ ham, turkey & your choice of cheese & dressing.$11.99+
- Cobb SaladBacon bits, boiled egg, chopped peppers, onions & tomato over lettuce & crispy or grilled chicken.$14.99+
- Gyro Chicken SaladFresh iceberg lettuce, tomato, onions & tzatziki cucumber sauce with a sliced pita on the side.$12.99+
- Gyro Beef SaladFresh iceberg lettuce, tomato, onions & tzatziki cucumber sauce with a sliced pita on the side.$12.99+
- Hot Sandwiches
- The BlackjackFresh chicken cutlet covered with bacon, melted pepper jack cheese & chipotle ranch dressing on our soft sub roll.$9.99+
- Buffalo Chicken Wrap$9.99
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich$8.99
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich Wrap$9.99
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich Sub$11.99
- Italian Grilled Chicken Sandwich RollMozzarella, roasted peppers, balsamic dressing.$9.99
- Italian Grilled Chicken Sandwich KaiserMozzarella, roasted peppers, balsamic dressing.$9.99
- Italian Grilled Chicken SubMozzarella, roasted peppers, balsamic dressing.$12.99
- Italian Grilled Chicken WrapMozzarella, roasted peppers, balsamic dressing.$9.99
- Chicken Cutlet SandwichThinly sliced, breaded then fried fresh chicken breast on a hard roll, white or wheat.$8.99
- Chicken Cutlet SandwichThinly sliced, breaded then fried fresh chicken breast on a hard roll, white or wheat.$9.99+
- Italian SausageSausage, peppers & onions. Marinara sauce is optional. On a hard roll or on an 8" sub roll.$9.75
- Fried Chicken Cutlet BLT$12.99+
- Grilled Chicken Cutlet BLT$12.99+
- Grilled Chicken CaesarMarinated grilled chicken, fresh romaine, parmesan cheese & caesar dressing$10.99+
- Beef Cheese SteakPeppers or onions optional.$11.99
- Chicken Cheese SteakPeppers or onions optional.$10.99
- Grilled Cheese$5.99
- Fish SandwichFreshly breaded & fried whiting.$9.99+
- BLT Sandwich$8.99
- Chicken Parm SandwichThinly sliced, breaded & fried fresh chicken breast covered in marinara sauce w/ your choice of provolone or mozzarella cheese on an 8? sub roll$9.99+
- How You Doin SubSweet Italian sausage & marinated grilled chicken sliced up mixed together and topped with peppers, onions & melted mozzarella cheese on our 8" soft sub bread then toasted on our hot grill.$13.99
- Ragin CajunMarinated blackened grilled chicken with cajun spices, mixed veggies and then topped with pepper jack cheese.$12.99
- Cuban SandwichFresh marinated, pork shoulder, sliced ham, swiss cheese, pickles, mayo & mustard on our special pressed grilled long roll.$13.99
- Fresh All Beef 1/2 Lb Burgers
- Single 1/2 lb. BurgerOn a hard roll.$8.99
- Double 1/2 lb. BurgerOn a hard roll.$13.99
- Triple 1/2 lb. BurgerOn a hard roll.$18.99
- Cheeseburger$9.25
- Double Cheeseburger$16.50
- Triple Cheeseburger$22.50
- Bacon CheeseburgerOn a hard roll.$12.50
- California Hamburger1/2 lb. burger topped with lettuce, tomato, raw onions, pickles & mayonnaise on a hard roll.$10.99
- California Cheeseburger$11.99
- Double California Cheeseburger$17.99
- Route 1&9 BurgerHalf pound burger topped with bacon, onion rings, cheese and BBQ sauce on a hard roll.$11.50
- Monster BurgerTwo 1/2 lb. burgers with pork roll, bacon, cheese, onion rings, lettuce and tomato on a hard roll.$21.99
- The FatBurger1/2 lb. burger topped with bacon, egg & cheese on a hard roll.$12.99
- Jersey Burger1/2 lb. burger with pork roll, egg & cheese on a hard roll.$12.99
- Double Italian Burger(2) 1/2 lb. burgers topped with peppers, onions, melted provolone cheese & potatoes. Marinara sauce is optional. All on an 8" sub roll.$15.99
- Italian Burger on a Hard Roll (Single)$10.99
- Veggie Burger$8.99
- Pizza Burger$10.50
- Hot Dogs
- Johnny Prince?s Famous Hot Dog$3.50+
- Cheese Dog$4.00
- Chili Cheese Dog$5.00
- Italian Hot DogPepper, onions & potatoes.$11.99
- Quesadillas
- Cheese Quesadilla$7.99
- Chicken & Cheese Quesadilla$12.99
- Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla$13.99
- Chicken Fajita Quesadilla$13.99
- Steak & Cheese Quesadilla$14.99
- Fish & Cheese Quesadilla$14.99
- Quesadilla Burger$11.99
- Cheeseburger Quesadilla$13.99
- Shrimp Quesadilla$15.99
- Breakfast Meat, Egg and Cheese Quesadilla$11.99
- Gyros
- Beef GyroLettuce. tomato, onions & tzatziki, cucumber sauce on a fresh hot 8" pita.$12.99
- Chicken GyroLettuce. tomato, onions & tzatziki, cucumber sauce on a fresh hot 8" pita.$11.99
- Fish GyroLettuce. tomato, onions & tzatziki, cucumber sauce on a fresh hot 8" pita.$13.99
- Cold Subs & Sandwiches
- Egg Salad$7.99+
- Tuna Salad Sandwich$9.99+
- Chicken Salad Sandwich$9.99+
- Italian SandwichHam, provolone, salami, cappicola.$8.99+
- Tuna Melt SubOn white wheat, rye or roll.$12.99
- Club Sandwich$12.99
- Pastrami$10.99+
- Ham$7.99+
- Ham with Cheese$12.99
- Turkey with Cheese$12.99
- Tuna with Cheese$12.99
- Grilled Chicken with Cheese$12.99
- Roast Beef with Cheese$12.99
- Roast Beef$9.99+
- Turkey$8.99+
- Wings
- WingsServed with homemade buffalo sauce, carrots & celery. Choice of dips: bleu cheese, honey mustard, barbecue, ranch or chipotle ranch.$10.99+
- Baskets
- Jumbo Shrimp (6) with Fries$14.99
- Chicken Fingers (6) with Fries$12.99
- Chicken Fingers (6) with Large Fries$14.99
- Mozzarella Sticks (6) with Fries$8.99
- Chicken Fingers$9.99
- Johnny Pince's All Natural Homemade Hotdog Chili "To Go"
- Johnny Pince's All Natural Homemade Hotdog Chili "To Go"$2.50+
- Sides
- Bacon$4.00
- Beef Bacon$5.00
- Side of Steak$6.00
- Corn Beef Hash$5.00
- Turkey Ham$4.50
- Sausage$4.50
- Turkey Bacon$5.00
- Italian Sausage$6.00
- Corned Beef Hash$4.50
- Turkey Bacon$5.00
- Home Fries$4.25+
- Fresh Muffins$3.25
- Fresh Muffins with Jelly$3.45
- Hash Brown$1.25
- Toast$1.25
- Toast with Jelly$1.50
- Oatmeal$5.25
- Bagel with Cream Cheese$3.99
- Bagel with Butter$2.99
- Bagel Plain$12.26
- Roll with Butter$1.78
- One Egg$1.00
- Grits$4.25
- Beverages
- Coffee$2.02+
- Tea$2.02+
- Hot Chocolate$2.02+
- Iced Coffee$3.00+
- Box of Joe$21.00
- Fountain Soda$1.00+
- Orange Juice$2.34+
- Bottled Water$1.00
- Milk$1.50+
- Red Bull$3.50+
- ShakesStrawberry, Vanilla & Chocolate.$6.00+
- Can Soda$1.41
- Apple Juice$2.34
- Cranberry Juice$2.34
- Grape Juice$2.34
- Grapefruit Juice$2.34
- Yoohoo$2.34
- Monster Energy$3.99
- Pure LeafSweet, unsweet & lemon$2.34
- Snapple$2.34
- Arizona Iced Tea$2.34
- Green Tea$2.34
- 20 oz Bottle Soda$2.34
- Gatorade$2.34
Reviews for Johnny Prince's Bayway Diner
No reviews yet.
Back to Menu
- Home
- Newark, NJ
- All Newark Restaurants
- Johnny Prince's Bayway Diner