Name: North Shore Pizza and Subs
Address: 4503 Monona Dr A, Monona, WI, 53716
Rating: 4.3

Appetizers

Salads

Cold Subs

Hot Subs

House Roast Beef Sandwiches

Steak Subs

Pastrami Subs

Gyros

Combos

Pasta

Choice of penne or spaghetti with garlic bread.

Pizza

Specialty Pizza

Kids Menu

Reviews for North Shore Pizza and Subs

73 ratings

Feb 19, 2026
The food is always amazing. The driver was so nice.
Feb 18, 2026
Very good. Driver warned me of a delay in delivery, and I was very appreciative. It also ended up not being that much of a delay anyway.
Dec 12, 2025
We decided we didn't much care for bbq pizza (in general) but the pizza was exactly what was ordered and the salad and poppers were tasty.
Nov 17, 2025
Good food and fast delivery. Thanks!
Oct 22, 2025
Favorite pizza. Dennis is amazing. The driver was so adorable and funny.
Oct 18, 2025
Northshore is our go to. The driver was prompt and a nice dude.
Jul 30, 2025
Pretty good! Falbos is better but they don?t deliver Mondays.
Jul 23, 2025
Love this place!! Old school arcade, good pizza and a amazing steak special sub!
May 19, 2025
Always delicious!
May 7, 2025
Best pizza in Madison!
Apr 27, 2025
Always great. Shout out to Dennis!
Apr 12, 2025
Northshore is the BEST.
Mar 30, 2025
This is the closest you can get to New York pizza. Dennis, the owner, is an awesome guy. The delivery driver, Kevin, was so fast and super cool.
Dec 13, 2024
Always Fresh, Delicious and reasonably priced. Yummeh!
Nov 1, 2024
Sadly, the pizza wasn't very tasty... It was just meh.
Mar 23, 2024
I received an incorrect order and everything was cold.
Jan 28, 2024
Pizza was late and cold
Jan 8, 2024
North Shore is hands down the best pizza in the Madison area. I?ve never had anything on their menu that wasn?t excellent. The prices and portions are reasonable for their pizzas and one of their small sandwiches is substantial in my opinion. The service is good, timely, and friendly. This is the only pizza place I go to now.
Aug 18, 2023
Food was and is Always Awesome. Eat Street not so much. No call or text upon dropping our order off. Finally went downstairs and our order had been sitting there long enough to be lukewarm. Very unhappy.
Aug 16, 2023
This order was disappointing as have been the last couple. Pizza crust has been burnt... gone way beyond crispy. It's actually black! The chicken wings also were burnt & very dry. Again, this has also happened with the last couple of orders. I must say that we have ordered from this place numerous times since it opened and had always thought the food was excellent. The first time our order was less than tasty, we thought it was just a fluke like maybe they were rushing to get our order out before closing . But the quality has continued to be poor in the last two orders since that previous "bad" one. We will give this restaurant another chance but, it might have fallen off our "go to" list. Sorry to say that because we prefer supporting local eateries rather than the large chains
Aug 6, 2023
Wasn?t the best. Got cheeseburgers and the meat was watery and on sub buns wasn?t expecting that should have a disclaimer. The meat didn?t look cooked all the way either.. Mozzarella sticks weren?t any better.
Jun 14, 2023
I ordered the meat lover's pizza, chicken wings, and curly fries. The pizza was fairly middle-of-the-road, not bad, but definitely won't go out of my way to order again. The fries were a little undercooked such that they were somehow chewy like bubblegum, though to their boon they were nicely seasoned. However the surprising star of the meal was the wings. They were much larger than what most places serve, while being perfectly cooked and juicy, but being so large, they could benefit from larger sauce cups.
Mar 28, 2023
Food was excellent! The pizza was very tasty, and the fries came hot and crispy!
Mar 23, 2023
We've ordered from North Shore many times (since they opened) and have had high praise for the food. That said, what was delivered last night was NOT up to the usual quality. The pizza crust was burnt... bottom as well as top. And not just a "little browner than usual.". It was black & definitely left a burnt taste in your mouth. The wings were slightly burnt & very dry. (Note: their wings are usually cooked perfectly & very juicy.). Disappointed in last night's food to say the least & hope it was an unfortunate exception. Will order again to see if the next order(s) will make it back to awesome as before.
Mar 19, 2023
Nothing against Northshore. Eatstreet delivered our pizza to the wrong address. You apparently can't talk to anyone from eatstreet. By the time we figured out that it was at the neighbors it had been outside in 20 degree Temps for a half hour. If I wanted frozen pizza I would have bought one at Metro.
Feb 19, 2023
We never got our order!
Jan 1, 2023
This was the 3rd time we've ordered from North Shore in the last 2 months. The food was really good each and every time. From appetizers to pizza to subs to wings, you can't go wrong! Glad they opened on Madison's east side. We prefer to order from small locally owned businesses and will definitely be ordering again... soon!
Dec 28, 2022
The roast beef sandwich came freezing cold with unmelted cheese. The meat was gray, pink, and fatty. Yuck! The lamb gyro is clearly frozen meat and came soggy and the pita was cold. :(
Nov 5, 2022
fresh and hot
Nov 3, 2022
First time ordering and it was great. Had a variety of things and they were all delicious.
Oct 22, 2022
Food was good. Mozzarella sticks and the sauce were excellent!
Oct 16, 2022
We love this place!!!! Awesome pizza with a chewy crust and flavorful sandwiches
Sep 25, 2022
Best pizza I?ve had since my last visit to the East Coast. There are other good pizzas in the Madison area, but nothing as good as this.
Sep 9, 2022
The steak sandwich was huge and tasted great!

Back to Menu

North Shore Pizza and Subs

Popular Items