- Popular Items
- Formaggio Pizza, 10"Four cheese blend atop pizza sauce. Add your favorite toppings.$14.00
- TiramisuMade in house with espresso and kahlua soaked lady fingers, mascarpone, cocoa.$8.00
- CheesecakeGraham cracker crust cheesecake plain or with berry topping.$9.00
- Brownie SkilletChocolate chip, chocolate brownie, bourbon salted caramel, vanilla ice cream.$10.50
- Fettuccine Alfredo with ChickenScratch made with aged cheese.$25.00
- Starters
- Sample PlatterCheese bread, cheese curds, crispy chicken tenders and onion haystack. Served with a variety of dipping sauces.$20.50
- Seafood Stuffed MushroomsLobster, crab, shrimp, mozzarella, in white mushrooms caps.$15.00
- Spinach Artichoke DipSpinach, garlic, artichoke hearts, tomato cruda, with choice of tortilla chips or crostini.$16.50
- Cheese BreadGarlic bread with Italian cheeses.$7.50+
- Risotto BallsFried panko breaded risotto, white wine, italian cheeses with aioli and marinara.$14.50
- WingsSeasoned wings, blue cheese dressing, and buffalo sauce. Bone-in.$9.00
- Chicken TendersHand breaded chicken tenderloins lightly fried and served with your choice of dipping sauce.$11.50
- Italian NachosPasta chips, alfredo, Italian cheeses, pepperoni, Italian sausage, tomatoes and banana peppers.$8.00+
- NachosTortilla chips with beef, chicken, or pork, cheese sauce, fresh jalape?o, black olives, sour cream, guacamole and pico de gallo.$16.00
- Red Onion StrawsTortilla chips with beef, chicken, or pork, cheese sauce, fresh jalapeno, black olives, sour cream, guacamole and pico de Gallo.$10.00
- BruschettaTomato, basil, red onion, garlic, hero cheese, crostini and balsamic glaze.$16.00
- Pastas
- Served with soup or salad, or upgrade to crock of baked French onion for additional cost.
- SpaghettiSpaghetti with scratch made tomato sauce.$17.00
- Spaghetti with MeatballSpaghetti with scratch made tomato sauce.$23.00
- Cheese Ravioli (6)Cheese filled pasta, choice of marinara or Alfredo.$23.00
- Meat LasagnaCasserole style with beef, sausage, Italian cheeses, marinara.$28.00
- Fettuccine AlfredoScratch made with aged cheese.$19.50
- Fettuccine Alfredo with ChickenScratch made with aged cheese.$25.00
- Fettuccine Alfredo with ShrimpScratch made with aged cheese.$28.50
- Cajun GrillGrilled chicken, andouille sausage, spicy red cream sauce, penne.$29.50
- CarbonaraPenne, bacon, mushrooms, peas, garlic cream sauce.$24.00
- Chicken CarbonaraPenne, bacon, mushrooms, peas, garlic cream sauce, chicken.$29.50
- Shrimp CarbonaraPenne, bacon, mushrooms, peas, garlic cream sauce.$33.00
- Chicken ParmigianaBread chicken, mozzarella, spaghetti, marinara.$29.50
- TetrazziniSpaghetti, white wine alfredo, italian cheeses, herb crust topping.$23.00
- Chicken TetrazziniSpaghetti, white wine alfredo, italian cheeses, herb crust topping.$28.50
- Shrimp TetrazziniSpaghetti, white wine alfredo, italian cheeses, herb crust topping.$32.00
- Seafood CannelloniLobster, shrimp, ricotta, mozzarella, seafood cream sauce.$26.00
- Portabella Penne (GF)Portabella mushroom, artichoke hearts, roasted tomato, balsamic butter, parmesan, balsamic glaze.$26.00
- Bruschetta Chicken (GF)Grilled chicken, fresh tomatoes, basil, red onion, shave cheese, capellini tossed in balsamic butter, and balsamic glaze.$29.50
- Shrimp Capellini (GF)Shrimp, asparagus, and tomato, white wine, garlic butter.$28.50
- Steaks & Other Favorites
- Served with a side and soup or salad, or upgrade to crock of baked French onion for additional cost.
- Lemon Basil Salmon (8 oz.)Never frozen grilled salmon, lemon, brazil.$32.00
- CodFried or baked, served with coleslaw.$25.00
- Sirloin (8 oz.)Char grilled, hand trimmed.$28.50
- Ribeye (14 oz.)Char grilled, hand cut, well marbled.$48.00
- Smothered ChickenGrilled chicken, peppers, onions, mushrooms, mozzarella.$20.50
- Sicilian ChickenSeared chicken breast, sun dried tomato sauce basil.$29.50
- Lemon Parmesan ChickenParmesan breaded chicken, honey lemon dressed arugula.$27.50
- Soups
- Minestrone$4.50+
- Soup of the Day$4.50+
- Baked French Onion SoupCaramelized onion, marsala, and provolone.$7.00
- Salads
- Mixed Greens with Dressing$4.50
- Caesar Salad with Dressing$4.50
- Endless Soup & SaladHomemade soup with choice of mixed greens or Caesar salad.$15.00
- Cobb SaladMixed greens, grilled chicken, cheddar, black olives, bacon, egg, tomatoes, red onion, crumbled bleu cheese, croutons, choice of dressing.$19.50
- Chicken CaesarGrilled chicken, romaine, Caesar dressing, Parmesan, lemon, croutons.$18.00
- Southwest SaladMixed greens, seasoned grilled chicken, peppers, tomatoes, onions, bacon, black bean corn relish, tortilla strips, salsa, and chipotle ranch.$19.50
- Burrito Bowl SaladMixed greens, black beans, mexican rice, pico de gallo, guacamole, sour cream, cilantro, red salsa, tortilla chips. Choice of carne asada, pastor, pollo asado, birria or carnitas.$19.50
- Caprese SaladFresh mozzarella, beef steak and grape tomatoes, basil, olive oil, balsamic glaze.$10.50
- Pizzas
- Hand tossed, thin crust, or 10" cauliflower crust for additional cost.
- Formaggio Pizza, 10"Four cheese blend atop pizza sauce. Add your favorite toppings.$14.00
- Margherita Pizza, 10"Fresh mozzarella, basil, oven roasted tomatoes and garlic on an olive oil brushed crust.$18.00
- Benvenuto Pizza, 10"Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, onions, mushroom, black olives, bell peppers, pizza sauce, four cheese blend.$19.00
- Four Meat Combo Pizza, 10"Pepperoni, ham, Italian sausage, bacon, pizza sauce, four cheese blend.$18.00
- Bianca Pizza, 10"Chicken, garlic, white sauce, four cheese blend.$18.00
- Calzones
- Your choice of fillings.
- Build Your Own CalzoneFour cheeses and pizza sauce. Add your favorite fillings.$17.00
- Four Meat CalzonePepperoni, ham, italian sausage, bacon, four cheese blend, pizza sauce.$20.50
- Chicken Broccoli CalzoneChicken, seasoned broccoli, four cheese and alfredo.$20.50
- Sandwiches
- Served with a side, or upgrade to crock of baked French onion for additional cost.
- Hot SupremeItalian roll, ham, pepperoni, salami, mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, red onion, Italian garlic vinaigrette.$18.00
- Grilled Salmon BLTNever frozen salmon, toasted garlic panini, bacon tomato, honey lemon dressed arugula, red onion, dill aioli.$21.00
- Prime Rib MeltGrilled garlic panini, sliced beef, portabellas, onion, provolone, au jus.$20.00
- Smash Classic BurgerPrime ground chuck with choice of lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo.$14.00
- Smash CheeseburgerPrime ground chuck with choice of lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo.$15.00
- Smash Bacon CheeseburgerPrime ground chuck with choice of lettuce, tomato, onion and mayo.$18.00
- Grilled Chicken SandwichGrilled with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and mayo.$16.00
- Crispy Chicken WrapChicken tenders, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, and tomatoes with ranch dressing.$18.00
- Chicken Parmigiana SandwichBreaded chicken, fresh mozzarella, marinara, fresh basil.$16.50
- Tacos Dinner
- Corn or flour tortilla. 3 tacos per order served with rice and beans.
- Carne Asada TacosSeared steak strips, diced onion, pickled red onion, cilantro, pico de gallo, and lime.$19.50
- Carnitas TacosSlow-cooked tender pork, diced onion, pickled red onion, cilantro, and pico de gallo.$19.50
- Al Pastor TacosMarinated pork, diced onion, pickled red onion, cilantro, pico de gallo and pineapple.$19.50
- Queso Birria TacosMozzarella and slow cooked braised beef in a fragrant three chile spice sauce and with a delicious spice mix.$19.50
- Desserts
- TiramisuMade in house with espresso and kahlua soaked lady fingers, mascarpone, cocoa.$8.00
- CheesecakeGraham cracker crust cheesecake plain or with berry topping.$9.00
- Flourless Chocolate TorteChocolate, butter, cocoa, vanilla.$9.00
- Brownie SkilletChocolate chip, chocolate brownie, bourbon salted caramel, vanilla ice cream.$10.50
- Triple Chocolate CheesecakeChocolate crust, bittersweet and milk chocolate cheesecake, dark chocolate ganache, milk chocolate ganache.$9.00
- Sides
- Crispy Brussels Sprouts$4.50
- Fries$4.50
- Garlic Mashed Potatoes$6.00
- Loaded Garlic Mashed Potatoes$8.50
- Garlic Broccoli$4.50
- Parmesan Risotto$4.50
- Beverages
- Coffee$3.50
- Hot Tea$3.50
- Hand Squeezed Lemonade$4.00
- Fountain Soda$3.50
- Italian SodaCherry, Strawberry, or Raspberry.$3.50
- Italian Cream SodaCherry, Strawberry, or Raspberry.$4.00
- Strawberry Basil Soda$4.00
- Sprecher Orange & Cream$4.00
- Sprecher Root Beer$4.00
- Sprecher Lo-Cal Root Beer$4.00
- Club Soda$3.00
- Iced Tea$3.50
Reviews for Benvenuto's Italian Grill - Middleton
No reviews yet.
Back to Menu
- Home
- Madison, WI
- All Madison Restaurants
- Benvenuto's Italian Grill - Middleton
