Name: Fathead Steve's
Address: 324 Jay St, La Crosse, WI, 54601
Rating: 4.1

Sandwiches

Served with a bag of chips or upgrade to french fries, pickle fries or curly fries for additional cost.

Wraps

Burgers

Quesadillas

Salads

Sides

Sauces

Reviews for Fathead Steve's

128 ratings

Jan 15, 2026
The sandwich and wrap that I ordered for myself and a friend were absolutely disgusting. The dressing on both was clearly expired and made the food inedible. The pickle fries were soggy and disgusting.
Mar 22, 2025
Food was good but no one got the chips we were supposed to get.
Feb 23, 2025
The food was fabulous as usual! Taste, temperature, and accuracy 100%?
Feb 23, 2025
Great food. It arrived quickly, under 20 minutes and it was hot! Mmmm!
Dec 17, 2024
Food was great. One item was forgotten but driver zipped right back and snatched it up for us.
Dec 5, 2024
Food was delicious, but they left out my chips and extra sauce. Order of fried green beans was small, too. I highly recommend the pickle fries!
Nov 1, 2024
food was great! timing of delivery was not. It was prepared as soon as the order arrived, and my notes for the timing were disregarded. I asked for 12, got 11 am instead. I also thought the pulled pork sandwich would come with bar-b-que sauce, but it didn't. The flavor was still awesome and would recommend it!
Jun 21, 2024
Quesadillas are the best!!
Feb 5, 2024
on time and hot and tasted delicious
Oct 1, 2023
I love fat head Steve?s I just didn?t receive my order. I received someone else?s. Then I found my order on my porch later in the night and had no idea on how long. It?s been there
Jul 23, 2023
Fathead Steve's does not disappoint. Sandwiches are delicious with high quality ingredients!
May 4, 2023
Very rude for a delivery driver to discuss tips with a customer. I prefer to tip either cash or on the app once I know I got everything I ordered and if the order arrives on time! The driver William was rude about it!
Jan 14, 2023
The description of the sandwich online versus what was delivered to me was the completely wrong sandwich.
Sep 17, 2022
Driver went above and beyond for this order.
Sep 6, 2022
The food was great, but EatStreet sucked it up in terms of the delivery.
Jul 28, 2022
Fries had no seasoning compared to other times - the fries I had were completely different as well and honestly awful
Jul 14, 2022
Philly steak was delicious, cheese curds a bit too salty but I ate them!
Jul 14, 2022
Food was amazing. The pulled pork was a favorite.
Jun 29, 2022
The pickle fries were fried WAAAAY to much and so there was almost nothing left of the pickle fries.
May 4, 2022
Always good!
Apr 25, 2022
It was spectacular! The fries were so good, and the sandwich was gone too soon. Will definitely order from here again. I?ll tell all my friends too!
Apr 25, 2022
The food was DELICIOUS!
Apr 9, 2022
We never heard of this place & came across it on here. Was nervous, but we got our order quick & loved it. We?ll be ordering again.
Apr 6, 2022
I got the Philly sandwich and fries. Food was outstanding! 10/10 would recommend!
Apr 4, 2022
Good food
Apr 4, 2022
Delicious? somehow the fries were even still crispy when they arrived!
Mar 9, 2022
I didn't get my oder got my money back i really wanted to try the oder but i didnt get it at all suck
Feb 23, 2022
I wish i could get more pickel fries with my wrap next time but such good food
Jan 31, 2022
Love the philly melt and fast service be cool to get truck out to some of the car show we put on....
Jan 15, 2022
Food was delicious!
Jan 15, 2022
My food was cold because the delivery driver made 2 stops before me. The driver is supposed to pick up the food and drive to the customer?s residence. The driver, Chase, said I shouldn?t use EatStreet anymore if I didn?t like it. I asked for a refund and got a $3.00 coupon. Insane!
Nov 21, 2021
Had the chicken bacon ranch wrap and it was delicious!
Oct 16, 2021
So good!!!! Very rich but served hot and order was correct. Your menu mentioned pickle fries, we added the additional charge and were excited to try them but got regular fries. Overall very good though
Oct 11, 2021
I was notified after I placed this order that it was cancelled on me so I then ordered from a different restaurant. That order worked and I got my food but then about an hour later I got my food from Fathead Steves. I just am not sure if I was charged for it, I hope I wasn't because otherwise I wouldn't have ordered from the other restaurant.
Oct 6, 2021
Can?t rate it! Order was cancelled as the order never was processed by the restaurant
Oct 6, 2021
Food was all really good. I had the Mediterranean gyro and loved it. Kids had the Mac n cheese and it looked good too (not just kraft like some places do) and great prices. Will definitely eat here again!
Aug 31, 2021
Didn?t like it. Everything did come hot. Ordered the bacon chicken wrap w/fries and side order of cheese curds. Don?t think that was chicken and I think bacon bits (nasty tasting), didn?t like the fries and no idea of what kind of cheeses where the curds. Didn?t finish any of it. Would rather eat McDonald?s, even at that price.
Jun 12, 2021
Food was absolutely amazing!
Apr 25, 2021
The delivery was fine and showed up within the estimated time but the order was not correct and we were sent 2 wrong entrees. I called the restaurant but they didn?t know what to tell me because they
Mar 14, 2021
First time having the Philly cheesesteak--which was delicious--because I almost always order the Cubano. Recommend both. Arrived hot.
Jan 11, 2021
Food is delicious as always.
Dec 31, 2020
The food was great, but due to confusion over timing and delivery, my order was pushed back nearly a half hour and was barely warm by the time it got to me.
Dec 22, 2020
our food was a little cold and dry.
Nov 16, 2020
The Philly steak is excellent!
Nov 10, 2020
Fathead Steve's Cuban sandwich is a big one, the pork is tender, juicy, flavorful. One of my favorites in the whole area.
Nov 8, 2020
Food was good. Pickle fries cold... Said it would be 1/2 hour... didn?t get food till 1 hour 5 minutes
Oct 25, 2020
Had the pulled pork sandwich w/pickle fries delivered to work twice now. Both times it arrived early, was hot, and very tasty.
Sep 12, 2020
I?ve had about half their menu and liked everything. Delivery arrives hot and I?ve probably ordered delivery or takeout about a dozen times without there ever being a mistake.
Jul 15, 2020
Awesome! Love you beautiful Creaturez! Thank you
Jun 28, 2020
Perfection!

Back to Menu

Fathead Steve's

Popular Items