Jay's Indian Food Menu & Delivery Sheboygan WI 53081 | EatStreet.com
Get Help
Skip to main content
EatStreet Logo
  • profile
    Sign In
  • cart
    Cart
Back to Restaurant Search
Jay's Indian Food Menu and Delivery in Sheboygan WI, 53081
  • Jay's Indian Food

  • Indian, Pizza, Sandwiches, Food Delivery Services, Chicken Shop
  • 1710 Indiana Ave Sheboygan WI, 53081
    - 61 ratings
  • Hours 11:00am - 8:30pm
  • ETA 20 - 35 min
  • Delivery Minimum None
  • Delivery Cost $1.99+

Popular Items

Butter Chicken (GF) Chicken thigh pieces cooked in onion and tomato bases curry with cream.
$19.54
Plain Rice
$4.59
Plain Naan
$5.74
Chicken Tikka Masala (GF) Seasoned grilled chicken breast pieces cooked in tomato and spices.
$19.54
Garlic Naan
$6.89

Appetizer

Chips Chilly Crispy french fries saut?ed in tangy sauce with onions and peppers
$14.94
Chicken Chilly Deep fried chicken saut?ed in tangy sauce with onion.
$17.24
Paneer Chilly Fried cottage cheese saut?ed in tangy sauce with onion.
$17.24
Gobi Manchurian Deep fry battered cauliflower saut?ed in tangy sauce.
$16.09
Mushroom Peppers Marinated grilled chicken leg quarter.
$16.09
Onion Pakoda Onion slices coated with seasoned gram flour and deep fry.
$10.34
Mix Vegetable Pakoda Mixed veggies dipped in seasoned batter and deep fry.
$9.19
Chicken Pakoda Chicken thigh coated with seasoned gram flour with other ingredients and fried.
$12.64
Shrimp Basket Seasoned battered shrimps fried in deep oil.
$17.24
Fish Pakoda Marinated fish dry in deep oil.
$13.79
Lamb Stir fry Lamb meat (bone-in or bone-less) stir fry with onion and green pepper.
$19.54
Samosa (2 Piece) Deep fry pastry filled with potato, and green pea.
$8.04
Samosa Chaat Samosa served yogurt, chana with chaat masala.
$10.34

Naan/Paratha

Plain Naan
$5.74
Butter Naan
$5.74
Garlic Naan
$6.89
Cheese Naan
$8.04
Bullet Naan
$6.89
Cherry Naan
$8.04
Cheese Garlic Naan
$9.19

Momo (Dumpling)

Vegetable Momo (Steamed)
$16.09
Chicken Momo (Steamed)
$17.24

Chow Mein

Chow Mein
$16.09+

Rice/Biriyani

Plain Rice
$4.59
Jeera Rice
$6.89
Cashew Rice
$8.04
Vegetable Fry Rice
$9.19
Chicken Fry Rice
$11.49
Egg Fry Rice
$10.34
Chicken Biryani
$18.39
Lamb Biryani
$21.84
Mutton (Goat) Biryani
$19.54
Egg Fry Biryani
$18.39

Main Course (Vegetarian)

Aloo Gobi Aloo (potato) and gobi (cauliflower) cooked with Indian spice.
$16.09
Mutter Paneer (GF) Combination of green peas and cottage cheese (paneer).
$17.24
Palak Paneer (GF) Very healthy spinach cooked with cottage cheese.
$17.24
Kadai Paneer Paneer cooked with green peppers, onion, ginger with other spices.
$17.24
Tofu Masala (V, GF) Semi dry version of tofu cooked with bell peppers, onion, ginger garlic with other spices.
$17.24
Rajma Masala (V, GF) Red kidney bean curry cooked with other ingredients
$16.09
Paneer Korma (GF) Cottage cheese cooked in traditional method in a cashew based gravy.
$17.24
Mushroom Mutter (GF) Combination of green peas and mushroom cooked in semi-gravy version.
$17.24
Palak Corn (GF) Mild creamy spinach cooked with spices.
$17.24
Bean curry (V, GF) Great combination of garbanzo, black and red bean in gravy version with secret spices.
$17.24
Daal Makhani (V) Black lentil cooked and topped with cream and butter.
$16.09
Daal Tadka (V, GF) Yellow lentil cooked with heated spices on oil.
$16.09
Paneer Butter Masala (GF) Cottage cheese cooked in the jays special sauce with butter and cream.
$18.39
Tofu Butter Masala (GF) Cottage tofu cooked in the jays special sauce with butter and cream.
$17.24
Mixed Vegetable Curry (V, GF) Seasoned mixed vegetables cooked with spices.
$17.24
Navaratan Korma (GF) Combination of fresh vegetables cooked in a cashew based gravy.
$17.24
Chana Masala (V, GF) Combination of garbanzo bean cooked in traditional method.
$17.24

Main Course (Non Vegetarian)

Butter Chicken (GF) Chicken thigh pieces cooked in onion and tomato bases curry with cream.
$19.54
Chicken Tikka Masala (GF) Seasoned grilled chicken breast pieces cooked in tomato and spices.
$19.54
Chicken Curry (GF) Chicken thigh (bone-in/bone-less) cooked with spices in traditional method.
$18.39
Chicken Kadai (GF) Marinated bone in chicken cooked with onion and bell pepper.
$19.54
Mushroom Chicken (GF) Slices of mushroom and boneless chicken cooked in tomato and onion base gravy.
$19.54
Shahi Chicken Korma (GF) Chicken cooked in cashew-based sauce with other spices.
$19.54
Green Chicken Korma (GF) spicyChicken cooked in cilantro and serrano pepper in cashew base sauce.
$19.54
Lamb Korma (GF) Lamb pieces cooked in cashew based sauce with cream.
$20.69
Lamb Rogan Josh (GF) spicyLamb pieces cooked in yogurt base curry.
$20.69
Fish Curry (GF) Marinated fish cooked in tomato and onion based curry with coconut milk.
$18.39
Shrimp Curry (GF) Marinated shrimp cooked in tomato and onion base curry with coconut milk.
$18.39
Fish Korma (GF) Marinated fish cooked in cashew base curry with cream.
$19.54
Shrimp Korma (GF) Marinated shrimp cooked in cashew base curry with cream.
$19.54
Mutton Curry (GF) Goat meat (bone in) cooked in traditional method.
$19.54
Lamb Curry (GF) Lamb meat (bone in) cooked in tomato and onion-based gravy.
$20.69
Lamb Kadai (GF) Lamb meat (bone in) cooked in tomato and onion base gravy.
$20.69
Lamb Vindaloo (GF) spicyLamb cooked with potato-based gravy with other ingredients.
$20.69
Lamb Tikka Masala (GF) Lamb pieces cooked with tomato and onion-based sauce with cream.
$20.69
Chicken Vindaloo (GF) spicyChicken cooked with potato based spicy gravy with other ingredients.
$19.54

Jay's Special Order

Tandoori Chicken
$19.54
Mango Lassi
$8.04
Plain Lassi
$6.89
Carrot Pudding (Deserts)
$8.04
Chicken Saag
$19.54
Chana Saag
$17.24
Malai Kofta
$18.39
Paneer Kadai
$17.24
Tofu Kadai
$17.24

Drinks

Soda (20 oz.) Choice of Coke, Sprite, Coke Zero.
$6.31
Red Bull
$6.31+

Back to Menu

Reviews for Jay's Indian Food

61 ratings
    Oct 23, 2025

    Delicious food we will be back

    Sep 29, 2024

    I had the shrimp korma and naan, it was really good.

    Aug 28, 2024

    Delicious

    May 20, 2024

    I love Jays food!

    Apr 5, 2024

    Jays is outstanding!

    Oct 30, 2023

    The food here is EPIC!! It riv

    Aug 14, 2023

    Fantastic

    Aug 9, 2023

    Fantastic

    Jun 9, 2023

    Fantastic as always. Love the cashew rice.

    Jan 26, 2023

    Cashew rice is excellent!!

    Dec 23, 2022

    The food was amazing! Our first time but it won't be our last.

    Nov 9, 2022

    Excellent, super hot. Cashew rice is amazing.

    Oct 21, 2022

    Delicious food

    Sep 19, 2022

    Cashew rice is outstanding!!

    Sep 9, 2022

    First time ordering and will definitely be back! So good.

    Aug 21, 2022

    Fantastic food!

    Jun 28, 2022

    Very happy to have some excellent Indian/Nepalese food in the area! We eat by you at least once a week since we have discovered you! So, thank you!!!

    Mar 22, 2022

    Great Indian food. Very authentic.

    Feb 12, 2022

    Delicious!!!

    Jan 8, 2022

    I was hesitant to try this place again after a lackluster experience last year, u

    Dec 31, 2021

    Great tasting g dish.

    Dec 5, 2021

    Awesome food! Beyond delicious.

    Oct 4, 2021

    Fantastic!

    Sep 9, 2021

    Jay's Indian Food is very authentic. So delicious and loaded with fresh spices. There are several bone in dishes, which has it's pro's and con's. We highly recommend Jay's Indian Food. Also, if you order pick-up the prices are cheaper.

    Aug 26, 2021

    Outstanding!!

    Aug 26, 2021

    I finally took the plunge and tried Jay's Indian selection after more recent reviews seemed good. Unfortunately, everything I got really missed the mark. The mixed vegetable pakoda was so close to being great...except that they were way overfried. I was able to try some of them (and the flavor there was pretty good!), but a lot of them were bordering burnt and tasted like it, so I ended up wasting a lot. I also tried the palak paneer and was really excited, as it's one of my favorite dishes. But again, it missed the mark entirely. The base wasn't blended enough, so instead of being a smooth spinach sauce, it was thick and required more chewing than usual. On top of that, my favorite part -- the paneer -- was incredibly overcooked and chewy/dry. Again, the flavors were pretty good, but the execution was subpar. Honestly, all of these are things they can easily address, so I really hope they're reading feedback and take it to heart.

    Jul 12, 2021

    The chicken curry had really small bones that prevented me from taking real bites. I also seemed to have gotten less of an amount, perhaps half was missing. I love the chicken masala though. It was incredibly flavorful.

    Apr 14, 2021

    Awesome!!! Please add more indian menu.

    Apr 3, 2021

    The food was delicious. My butter chicken was missing rice but it was still wonderful.

    Mar 20, 2021

    AWESOME FOOD!

    Mar 18, 2021

    Outstanding! You must try it. Butter chicken, tikka masala....mmmm.

    Feb 6, 2020

    Small selection of food - and all if it was delicious!

    Jan 4, 2020

    I was extremely excited to find Indian food in Sheboygan. However, I was disappointed. I'm not sure how "authentic" it was. I followed a recipe online & that was 100 times better than what I received from Jay's. The food was hot, the rice & naan were good, but the chicken Tikka masala was average, if that. There was a little heat which I liked but there was no depth of flavor. It tasted as though they cooked the chicken & then dumped a pre-made jar of sauce you can find at any grocery store into it. I really don't know how they can justify charging those prices for what they're serving. I would have paid half the amount they charged. That seems fair for what they deliver. Very disappointing. I think if the food was more authentic & they had a good marketing team an Indian restaurant in Sheboygan would be a huge success.

    Nov 22, 2019

    Highly recommend!

    Oct 26, 2019

    Authentic and delicious! Would order again.

    Oct 25, 2019

    The food came in a timely fashion and the temperature was still warm. The chicken tikka masala was not what I was expecting. It was not the traditional creamy smooth curry sauce that is typical of the dish. The sauce had chunks of green pepper and onion.

    Sep 25, 2019

    I ordered butter chicken and paneer tikka masala.. it was nothing like it was supposed to be.. it was just chicken cooked in tomato ketchup.. I was disappointed!

    Sep 23, 2019

    They did not confirm the order for 20 mins because of which eat street had to cancel my order and then when I tried to reorder the restaurant was closed.. very disappointed!

Back to Menu

Share your menu feedback with us: menus@eatstreet.com
All Asian Food delivery & takeout options in Sheboygan
  1. Home
  2. Sheboygan, WI
  3. All Sheboygan Restaurants
  4. Jay's Indian Food

Your Order

Jay's Indian Food
Proceed to Checkout $0.00
Empty Cart Illustration

Famished? Fill me up!

EatStreet
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Careers
Support
  • For Customers
  • Restaurant Dashboard
  • Get EatStreet
Legal
  • Cashback Rewards Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information
  • Restaurant Terms - Updated 10/25/2024
Get the App
? 2026 EatStreet
We use cookies and other tracking technologies to enhance your experience on our site. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy