Jay's Indian Food

Delicious food we will be back

I had the shrimp korma and naan, it was really good.

Delicious

I love Jays food!

Jays is outstanding!

The food here is EPIC!! It riv

Fantastic

Fantastic

Fantastic as always. Love the cashew rice.

Cashew rice is excellent!!

The food was amazing! Our first time but it won't be our last.

Excellent, super hot. Cashew rice is amazing.

Delicious food

Cashew rice is outstanding!!

First time ordering and will definitely be back! So good.

Fantastic food!

Very happy to have some excellent Indian/Nepalese food in the area! We eat by you at least once a week since we have discovered you! So, thank you!!!

Great Indian food. Very authentic.

Delicious!!!

I was hesitant to try this place again after a lackluster experience last year, u

Great tasting g dish.

Awesome food! Beyond delicious.

Fantastic!

Jay's Indian Food is very authentic. So delicious and loaded with fresh spices. There are several bone in dishes, which has it's pro's and con's. We highly recommend Jay's Indian Food. Also, if you order pick-up the prices are cheaper.

Outstanding!!

I finally took the plunge and tried Jay's Indian selection after more recent reviews seemed good. Unfortunately, everything I got really missed the mark. The mixed vegetable pakoda was so close to being great...except that they were way overfried. I was able to try some of them (and the flavor there was pretty good!), but a lot of them were bordering burnt and tasted like it, so I ended up wasting a lot. I also tried the palak paneer and was really excited, as it's one of my favorite dishes. But again, it missed the mark entirely. The base wasn't blended enough, so instead of being a smooth spinach sauce, it was thick and required more chewing than usual. On top of that, my favorite part -- the paneer -- was incredibly overcooked and chewy/dry. Again, the flavors were pretty good, but the execution was subpar. Honestly, all of these are things they can easily address, so I really hope they're reading feedback and take it to heart.

The chicken curry had really small bones that prevented me from taking real bites. I also seemed to have gotten less of an amount, perhaps half was missing. I love the chicken masala though. It was incredibly flavorful.

Awesome!!! Please add more indian menu.

The food was delicious. My butter chicken was missing rice but it was still wonderful.

AWESOME FOOD!

Outstanding! You must try it. Butter chicken, tikka masala....mmmm.

Small selection of food - and all if it was delicious!

I was extremely excited to find Indian food in Sheboygan. However, I was disappointed. I'm not sure how "authentic" it was. I followed a recipe online & that was 100 times better than what I received from Jay's. The food was hot, the rice & naan were good, but the chicken Tikka masala was average, if that. There was a little heat which I liked but there was no depth of flavor. It tasted as though they cooked the chicken & then dumped a pre-made jar of sauce you can find at any grocery store into it. I really don't know how they can justify charging those prices for what they're serving. I would have paid half the amount they charged. That seems fair for what they deliver. Very disappointing. I think if the food was more authentic & they had a good marketing team an Indian restaurant in Sheboygan would be a huge success.

Highly recommend!

Authentic and delicious! Would order again.

The food came in a timely fashion and the temperature was still warm. The chicken tikka masala was not what I was expecting. It was not the traditional creamy smooth curry sauce that is typical of the dish. The sauce had chunks of green pepper and onion.

I ordered butter chicken and paneer tikka masala.. it was nothing like it was supposed to be.. it was just chicken cooked in tomato ketchup.. I was disappointed!

They did not confirm the order for 20 mins because of which eat street had to cancel my order and then when I tried to reorder the restaurant was closed.. very disappointed!