Goodfella's Pizza & Subs

Excellent

Great pizza

Not cooked long enough dough was not done only outer crust

Great best one ever

I?ve tried everything in the menu at least once and never been disappointed, the food is always great.

missing add ons

Great experience! Quick and easy!

Paid for toppings and 2 were not on pizza

Always a great experience!

We love Goodfella's. They're food is amazing and they always deliver on time.

First left instructions not to ring door bell or knock when delivered... they did both. Second added pineapple and mushroom to Stromboli which is a closed pastry... you can see where they had to cut it open to add ingredients which shows they are not made fresh. Third both extra order of fried mushrooms' and cheesecake was so small was not worth the high price.

Great pizza and service as always!

Did not deliver pizza we waited they finally sent a message closed

pizza had cheese on one side an very little sauce

Too greasy

food tasted bland the speg. noodles were tuff to old not soft over all will o be ordering this item again

Best Local restaurant in the area

The Eat Street online ordering was great! The pizza even came earlier than we expected. Unfortunately, the product was sub-par. We usually enjoy Goodfella?s pizza, but this time it appeared slightly undercooked. The crust was soft toward the middle and none of it was browned. Disappointing.

Pizza was very cold. Not good at all.

This is the third time in a row that we have ordered online for pickup and we get there at the requested pickup time and goodfellas has not begun our order. We end up waiting 20+ minutes additional for the order and no apology.

Always a well-made, flavorful pizza

Awesome Lasagna and side salad!

The ONLY place we order pizza from!

Prompt and friendly delivery. Good neighborhood pizza pie.

our cheese pizza hardly had any sauce or cheese on it. you only can order from the delivery service a large. the calamari and cheese sticks were frozen like you can buy at kroger. was disappointed

35 mins late. Called and said he should be pulling up and then 30 mins later he did.

Good as always

The pizza was half-done, the order was wrong, and it took almost 2-hrs to receive my order.

Food is always awesome. Prepared and delivered quickly. Guests loved it

The food is great, but the delivery is always at least 15 minutes late. I recommend ordering early.

Food was good but one our pizzas almost came through the box probably from sitting in the bag for so long. Delivery took double the time and we don't live far. Driver even admitted that he stopped for gas.

Calzone was cold and tasted awful it appeared undercooked some ingredients inside tasted awful

Ordered for pickup 3 times now and each time it is ready 20 minutes or after the scheduled pick up time. As I?m writing this I?m waiting for today?s order that was supposed to be picked up 15 minutes ago and no ETA in sight.

Ordered a large pizza, and it is LARGE!! I wonder how big extra large is. Very good pizza, will definitely order again.

It was Ok... nothing special. A little over priced for the taste and quantity of the toppings.

Salami sandwich was disappointing. Very little salami and cheese. All bread, and the bread wasn?t very good.

Amazing!!

Tried a new Italian restaurant in Wylie and I WAS NOT disappointed. We got the grilled chicken al vodka and eggplant rollatini THEY WERE DELICIOUS! Staff was very friendly during the pickup. Excited to try the HOT MEATBALL and Fried mushrooms

Worst experience ordering a pizza ever, by far. Over 2 hours for delivery, pizza was cold, greasy, and soggy. Spoke to the owner about my dissatisfaction. The good news is i spoke to the owner. The bad news is i spoke to the owner who should be nowhere near the customer. He (Craig) and one if his excon cooks were rude and couldn?t care less. Will never order from this dump again. In the end, i did receive a refund, but only after driving to the restaurant and seeing them in person.

Salads are always fresh and green! Pizza was delicious!

Awesome pizza and service

Delicious food...made exactly to our requests...and excellent customer service.