Goodfella's Specialty Pizza Pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, hamburger, mushrooms, green pepper, black olives and onions. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$21.54+

Meat Lovers Pizza Pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon and hamburger. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$21.54+

Veggie Lovers Pizza Mushrooms, green peppers, black olives, onions and tomatoes. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$21.54+

BBQ / Teriyaki / Buffalo Chicken Pizza BBQ/teriyaki/buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, and mozzarella. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$21.54+

Alfredo Pizza Alfredo sauce and mozzarella. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$21.54+

White Pizza Ricotta, mozzarella, Parmesan and fresh garlic. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$21.54+

Philly Cheese Steak Pizza Roasted Beef, Sauteed Mushrooms, Onions, Green peppers and Mozzarella. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$21.54+

Lasagna Pizza Ground beef, ricotta, fresh garlic and roasted red peppers. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$21.54+

Margarita Pizza Garlic, fresh basil, fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, ricotta and Parmesan. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$19.74+

Fajita Chicken Pizza Taqueria sauce, Fajita chicken, sauteed red pepper, green pepper, onion, cilantro, mozzarella. Choice of 12" small, 14" medium, 16" large or 18" extra large.

$21.54+

Meat Lovers Stuffed Pizza (16" Large) Pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, mozzarella, onions, green peppers and fresh garlic with side of marinara sauce. Please note that this item has a 45 minute bake time.

$39.54

Deep Dish Sicilian Pizza (16" Large) Any toppings. Chicken or Meatball with extra charge.

$21.54

Goodfellas Sides

Side of Alfredo Sauce 7" Bowl

$4.74

Marinara Sauce 7" Bowl

$4.74

Side of 1 Chicken Breast

$4.74

Extra Side of Ranch Dressing

$0.90

Extra Side of Marinara Sauce

$0.90

Desserts

Tiramisu

$5.10

Cheesecake Choice of chocolate, strawberry, or plain.

$5.10

Cannoli Choice of plain or chocolate.

$5.10

Drinks

Fountain Drinks Served with your choice of Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper, Orange, Pink Lemonade, Iced Tea

$2.58

2 Liter Soda Served with your choice of Coke, Diet Coke, Dr. Pepper, Diet Dr. Pepper or Sprite.

$3.54

Cans of Soda Choice of coke, dr. pepper, or diet dr. pepper.

$1.62

Bottled Water

$1.62

Lunch Specials

Hours Today: 11:00 am - 2:00 pm

These items are not currently available

Stromboli and Drink Lunch

$9.54

Calzone and Drink Lunch

$9.54

2 Slices of 1 Topping Pizza and Salad Lunch Includes a drink.

$9.54

The Works Cold Sub and Drink Lunch Includes lettuce, tomato, black olives and special dressing.

$9.54

Cappicolla Cold Sub and Drink Lunch Includes provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, black olives and special dressing.

$9.54

Salami Cold Sub and Drink Lunch Includes provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, black olives and special dressing.

$9.54

Ham and Provolone Cold Sub Lunch Includes lettuce, tomato, black olives and special dressing. Served with a drink.

$9.54

Turkey Cold Sub and Drink Lunch Includes lettuce, tomato, black olives and special dressing.

$9.54

Philly Cheese Steak Hot Sub Lunch Includes a drink.

$9.54

Chicken Parmigiana Hot Sub Lunch Includes a drink.

$9.54

Meatball Parmigiana Hot Sub Lunch Includes a drink.

$9.54

Sausage Parmigiana Hot Sub Lunch Includes a drink.

$9.54

Eggplant Parmigiana Hot Sub Lunch Includes a drink.

$9.54

Sausage and Pepper Parmigiana Hot Sub Lunch Includes a drink.

$9.54

Linguine with Clam Sauce Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Linguine Primavera with Pink Sauce Lunch Green peas, mushrooms, carrots and fresh tomatoes. Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Lasagna Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Manicotti Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Cannelloni Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Stuffed Shells Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Cheese Ravioli Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Ravioli with Sauce Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Fettuccine Alfredo Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Cheese Tortellini with Pink Sauce Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Spaghetti Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Ziti Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Baked Ziti Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads.

$9.54

Ziti Al Vodka with Pink Sauce Lunch Served with garlic knots and salads. Choice of hot or mild.

$9.54

Back to Menu

259 ratings

May 31, 2026
Excellent
Feb 16, 2026
Great pizza
Jun 14, 2024
Not cooked long enough dough was not done only outer crust
Apr 30, 2022
Great best one ever
Jan 23, 2022
I?ve tried everything in the menu at least once and never been disappointed, the food is always great.
Dec 3, 2021
missing add ons
Aug 18, 2021
Great experience! Quick and easy!
Jun 20, 2021
Paid for toppings and 2 were not on pizza
May 27, 2021
Always a great experience!
Apr 30, 2021
We love Goodfella's. They're food is amazing and they always deliver on time.
Apr 28, 2021
First left instructions not to ring door bell or knock when delivered... they did both. Second added pineapple and mushroom to Stromboli which is a closed pastry... you can see where they had to cut it open to add ingredients which shows they are not made fresh. Third both extra order of fried mushrooms' and cheesecake was so small was not worth the high price.
Apr 9, 2021
Great pizza and service as always!
Feb 21, 2021
Did not deliver pizza we waited they finally sent a message closed
Oct 5, 2020
pizza had cheese on one side an very little sauce
Jul 31, 2020
Too greasy
Jun 28, 2020
food tasted bland the speg. noodles were tuff to old not soft over all will o be ordering this item again
Mar 28, 2020
Best Local restaurant in the area
Feb 27, 2020
The Eat Street online ordering was great! The pizza even came earlier than we expected. Unfortunately, the product was sub-par. We usually enjoy Goodfella?s pizza, but this time it appeared slightly undercooked. The crust was soft toward the middle and none of it was browned. Disappointing.
Nov 6, 2019
Pizza was very cold. Not good at all.
Nov 2, 2019
This is the third time in a row that we have ordered online for pickup and we get there at the requested pickup time and goodfellas has not begun our order. We end up waiting 20+ minutes additional for the order and no apology.
Oct 21, 2019
Always a well-made, flavorful pizza
Aug 4, 2019
Awesome Lasagna and side salad!
Jun 5, 2019
The ONLY place we order pizza from!
Jun 3, 2019
Prompt and friendly delivery. Good neighborhood pizza pie.
Jan 22, 2019
our cheese pizza hardly had any sauce or cheese on it. you only can order from the delivery service a large. the calamari and cheese sticks were frozen like you can buy at kroger. was disappointed
Dec 15, 2018
35 mins late. Called and said he should be pulling up and then 30 mins later he did.
Nov 21, 2018
Good as always
Nov 4, 2018
The pizza was half-done, the order was wrong, and it took almost 2-hrs to receive my order.
Oct 23, 2018
Food is always awesome. Prepared and delivered quickly. Guests loved it
Oct 22, 2018
The food is great, but the delivery is always at least 15 minutes late. I recommend ordering early.
Oct 21, 2018
Food was good but one our pizzas almost came through the box probably from sitting in the bag for so long. Delivery took double the time and we don't live far. Driver even admitted that he stopped for gas.
Oct 13, 2018
Calzone was cold and tasted awful it appeared undercooked some ingredients inside tasted awful
Oct 12, 2018
Ordered for pickup 3 times now and each time it is ready 20 minutes or after the scheduled pick up time. As I?m writing this I?m waiting for today?s order that was supposed to be picked up 15 minutes ago and no ETA in sight.
Oct 11, 2018
Ordered a large pizza, and it is LARGE!! I wonder how big extra large is. Very good pizza, will definitely order again.
Oct 9, 2018
It was Ok... nothing special. A little over priced for the taste and quantity of the toppings.
Oct 6, 2018
Salami sandwich was disappointing. Very little salami and cheese. All bread, and the bread wasn?t very good.
Sep 29, 2018
Amazing!!
Sep 27, 2018
Tried a new Italian restaurant in Wylie and I WAS NOT disappointed. We got the grilled chicken al vodka and eggplant rollatini THEY WERE DELICIOUS! Staff was very friendly during the pickup. Excited to try the HOT MEATBALL and Fried mushrooms
Sep 23, 2018
Worst experience ordering a pizza ever, by far. Over 2 hours for delivery, pizza was cold, greasy, and soggy. Spoke to the owner about my dissatisfaction. The good news is i spoke to the owner. The bad news is i spoke to the owner who should be nowhere near the customer. He (Craig) and one if his excon cooks were rude and couldn?t care less. Will never order from this dump again. In the end, i did receive a refund, but only after driving to the restaurant and seeing them in person.
Sep 11, 2018
Salads are always fresh and green! Pizza was delicious!
Aug 26, 2018
Awesome pizza and service
Jul 22, 2018
Delicious food...made exactly to our requests...and excellent customer service.

Goodfella's Pizza & Subs

Popular Items

Appetizers

Salads

Bowls (Gluten-Free)

Hot Subs

Cold Subs

Entrees

Pastas

Pizza by Slice