Name: Christianos Pizza - Appleton
Address: 2400 S Kensington Dr #500, Appleton, WI, 54915
Rating: 4.1

Salads

Sandwiches

Calzones

Build Your Own Calzone

Build Your Own Pizza

Christiano's Signature Pizzas

Wood-Fired at 800 Degrees. Gluten-free crust available.

Desserts

Beverages

Reviews for Christianos Pizza - Appleton

661 ratings

Jan 3, 2026
The pizza was good, the service was not.
Dec 29, 2025
Only delivered half my order
Dec 19, 2025
great pizza every time and fast friendly service
Nov 23, 2025
They did not listen to my request for no mushrooms. Disappointing.
Nov 6, 2025
There was no salad dressing for the Caesar salad. A small portion of the lettuce had some brown on it. This is unusual for them.
Aug 23, 2025
Excellent!!
Aug 10, 2025
Great as always!
Jul 7, 2025
Pizza arrived cold -should have considered putting it in a warmer container.
May 11, 2025
Great as always!
Mar 2, 2025
Excellent as always!
Jan 25, 2025
Delicious pizza
Jan 19, 2025
cold
Sep 22, 2024
Pizza was not made correctly as to I ordered, delivery person delivered to the wrong apartment and never called because I didn?t have an apartment number supposedly and just dropped it at random apt
Jul 30, 2024
The kids pizza and Classic were both just fine. The Gluten free pizza was so overcooked that it was tough to chew. I stopped eating before I was full due to the fact that it was so tough it was making my jaw sore. I was just disappointed.
May 28, 2024
Very fast service, however the extra sauce we ordered and paid for wasn?t delivered.
May 19, 2024
crust was a bit rubbery, otherwise the flavor was great. I guess we like a crisp crust.
Apr 28, 2024
Pizza was delivered with multiple burnt hills instead of meat. Completely unacceptable!!!!!!!!! Was not the delivery person?s fault, it was Christiano?s fault.
Apr 7, 2024
It was expensive. $40 for a pizza and cheese sticks. Won?t ever get that again
Feb 24, 2024
Not worth the price for how small the pizzas are. Nearly $20 for a "personal" margarita pizza that's straight grease to the point you can barely peel the pieces off the box. Very disappointed with both the price and quality. I would've picked up but that wasn't available on the app. Would not recommend or order from here again.
Feb 17, 2024
The crust was
Feb 13, 2024
The pizza was excellent. Their choice of driver berated me for not answering the door quickly enough even though I selected to leave the order at the door.
Feb 1, 2024
They sent the wrong pizzas. The driver was great but the order was completely wrong. The restaurant mistake 100%
Jan 21, 2024
Pizza and cheese bread were burned. Did not have the additional cheese on pizza as requested. Disappointed with this experience.For total amount paid we doubt we will return.
Nov 19, 2023
Pizza was good, but I put instructions on the order to ring the doorbell and hand the pizza to the homeowner. They rang the doorbell but left the pizza on the porch and ran.
Oct 8, 2023
Over priced for size and toppings on pizza
Aug 27, 2023
We had high hopes and will try again but it took 2 hours and the food was cold.
Jul 24, 2023
It was cold, poorly put on toppings and a little undercook.
Jun 15, 2023
Excellent experience!
Jun 12, 2023
Usually love the pizza. Pizza arrived cold and there was a hair in one of the pizzas as well!
Jun 4, 2023
Although we love you pizza we decided to try your ham sandwich. They arrived soggy due to being in so much oil or grease. The dough was not cooked all the way. We both could not finish the sandwhiches.
May 26, 2023
Our food was cold when it finally arrived. Previous experience had been great, but this order delivery experience was horrible.
May 17, 2023
I think they have the best pizza in town.
May 8, 2023
Absolutely fantastic !
Apr 26, 2023
Their pizza was the best I?ve had in my area and I thoroughly enjoyed it! I loved the fact that I could build my own pizza, even choosing the type of cheese I wanted?lots of choices!
Apr 17, 2023
We did not get the correct order. :( the restaurant said they could make the right order, but we would have to pick it up. We couldn?t leave at the time so it was a waste of money and not what we wanee
Mar 3, 2023
The pizza was excellent.
Jan 21, 2023
Cbr was so plain and crust was hard to tear apart and lack of any flavor was
Dec 30, 2022
The pizza was delivered about 20 minutes late. It was barely warm. I assume the driver got lost bc I am I a new apartment complex. I don't blame her. It took about 15 minutes past the delivery time for me to receive a call about it. I then gave her directions. My apartment os less than 5 minutes from you. The pizza was good, otherwise, but nothing like when it is hot and fresh.
Dec 29, 2022
Pizz
Dec 27, 2022
Food was warm. Delivery was on time. Pizza arrived intact.
Nov 23, 2022
Pizza was cold, salad crisp.
Oct 29, 2022
Very pleased - food made and delivered quickly. Well done!
Sep 16, 2022
My pizza was cold.
Sep 12, 2022
Delivery was fast, the driver was very kind, and the pizza was delicious. Definitely ordering from Christianos Pizza again!
Aug 24, 2022
Pizza was delicious and so wonderful! It totally hit the spot. :D
Jul 16, 2022
As always, great food, delivered hot
Jul 5, 2022
Not what I expect small pizza and was cold. Not the right topping
Jun 14, 2022
Sausage & Cheese Pizza was delicious. Christiana?s is a favorite for my Husband & I. The variety of food on their Menu is great.. Never have been disappointed. They ROCK!
Jun 10, 2022
I did not care for your pizza. The crust was too soft and floppy.
May 27, 2022
The food arrived over 30 minutes later than originally stated and the food was cold, requiring reheating.

Back to Menu

Christianos Pizza - Appleton

Popular Items

Share